15 thoughts on championship weekend
Before we get to my 15 observations from championship weekend, a couple links to share that you might have missed the past couple days.
15 thoughts on championship weekend
Sheil Kapadia, Philly.com
Before we get to my 15 observations from championship weekend, a couple links to share that you might have missed the past couple days.
According to a report, the Eagles did make a push for Steve Spagnuolo, but he chose the Saints over them, largely because of Drew Brees.
And Brian Dawkins talked about the potential end of his NFL career, along with leadership, as it relates to the Eagles.
1. We must start with special teams. There were several great moments in one of the better championship weekends in recent memory, but fair or unfair, these two games will likely be remembered for two players who didn't come through. With 1:44 left in the early game, Joe Flacco drove the Ravens 65 yards to the Patriots' 14. After an incompletion, Billy Cundiff came out onto the field to attempt a 32-yard field goal. And missed. On the replay, it looked like John Harbaugh said simply, "He pushed it." I'm still not sure why Cundiff was running onto the field with just 15 seconds on the play clock. The ball was not snapped until the play clock had just one second remaining. And the Ravens had a timeout to use. But Harbaugh, who made a name for himself coaching the Eagles' special teams, told reporters afterwards that he didn't think his team was rushed.
2. Prior to the miss, Cundiff had attempted 11 postseason field goals and made 10 of them. His only miss was a 47-yarder as a member of the Saints five years ago. He had made nine straight field goals before lining up for the 32-yarder. It's hard not to look on the other sideline and think about how the kicking game has affected the legacies of Bill Belichick and Tom Brady, both of whom will be considered among the best ever, regardless of what happens in a couple weeks. During their first Super Bowl run in 2001, two of the Patriots' three playoff games were determined by a field goal. Against Oakland, Adam Vinatieri hit a 45-yarder to tie the game and a 23-yarder in overtime to win it. In the Super Bowl, he hit a 48-yarder for the win. Again in 2003, two of the Patriots' three playoff wins were by a field goal. Against the Titans, Vinatieri hit a 46-yarder that won it. And in the Super Bowl, a 41-yarder to beat the Panthers. Sure, Belichick and Brady put the Patriots in position to win, but it's amazing to think of how many of those games came down to one final kick.
3. In the late game, the goat was Kyle Williams. The 49ers' defense completely shut down the Giants' offense in the second half. In 12 possessions after halftime (including OT), the Giants punted 10 times. They scored twice. Both came off of special-teams turnovers by Williams. Early in the fourth, a punt hit Williams' knee, and Eli Manning hit Mario Manningham for a 17-yard touchdown on the ensuing possession. And of course, in overtime, Jacquian Williams stripped Kyle Williams to set up the game-winning 31-yard field goal by Lawrence Tynes.
4. While Kyle Williams will take the heat, Alex Smith and the offense had plenty of opportunities. The 49ers managed just one field goal in their final seven possessions. In the regular season, according to Football Outsiders, the Giants' defense ranked 15th against No. 1 wide receivers; 18th against No. 2 wide receivers; and 30th against other wide receivers. Yet, 49ers wide receivers totaled one catch for 3 yards. And that reception, by Michael Crabtree, didn't come until 5:58 remaining in the fourth quarter. Overall, the 49ers were 1-for-13 on third down. Tough to win with those numbers.
5. The 49ers' defense, meanwhile, got plenty of great individual performances. Linebacker Navorro Bowman had a game-high 14 tackles, half-a-sack and a QB hit. Yes, that's the same Bowman who was taken in the third round of the 2010 draft, five spots after the Eagles selected Daniel Te'o-Nesheim. Ray McDonald had 2.5 sacks and a forced fumble. If that name sounds familiar, it might be because McDonald gave the Eagles, and specifically Kyle DeVan, fits during the regular season. The Birds simply could not block him, which was part of the reason DeVan was benched the following week, and Danny Watkins was inserted into the starting lineup.
6. McDonald did a good job of forcing the Manning fumble. But he did a poor job of celebrating while the ball was still loose on the ground. The Giants ended up recovering. Sometimes, luck does play a role. Devin Thomas recovered both of Kyle Williams' fumbles. I took a look at some regular-season numbers, and the Eagles recovered 46.34 percent of fumbles, which ranked 21st. In other words, 20 other teams were luckiers. In 2010, that number was 62.5 percent for the Eagles, which ranked third.
7. Victor Cruz was targeted 17 times yesterday and came up with 10 catches for 142 yards. And he was great on the Giants' final drive of the first half, catching four balls for 56 yards on five targets, helping to set up a 31-yard field goal that gave New York a 10-7 lead. Looking at the regular season, he was the No. 1 big-play receiver in the NFC East. With DeSean Jackson, Jeremy Maclin, Miles Austin, Dez Bryant and Hakeem Nicks in the division, that's quite a feat. Here's how the simple numbers stack up:
| Yards-per-catch | Plays of 20+ yards | |
| Cruz | 18.7 | 25 |
| Jackson | 16.6 | 15 |
| Nicks | 15.7 | 17 |
| Bryant | 14.7 | 17 |
| Maclin | 13.6 | 15 |
| Austin | 13.5 | 9 |
8. Oh, and you might have heard Joe Buck and Troy Aikman mention how Cruz told them he realized things were different for him when the Eagles had Nnamdi Asomugha covering him. Cruz beat Asomugha for touchdowns of 28 and 24 yards, respectively, in the teams' two meetings. He piled up nine catches for 238 yards and three scores against the Eagles in 2011.
9. The defensive MVP of the weekend had to be Vince Wilfork. In the first quarter, his pressure led to a Mark Anderson sack. He dropped Ricky Williams for a 5-yard loss. And he had a sack of his own. In the fourth quarter, on 3rd-and-3, he brought Ray Rice down for a 3-yard loss and then pressured Flacco on fourth down to force an incompletion. Wilfork affected the game throughout.
10. In the first quarter, Ravens cornerback Lardarius Webb was called for an illegal contact penalty, and CBS flashed a stat that it was the team's first penalty in 180 plays. Impressive. John Harbaugh had a disciplined football team. The Ravens were tied for the fourth-fewest turnovers and had the fourth-fewest penalty yards during the regular season. If you're wondering about the Eagles, they were middle of the pack with the 13th-most penalty yards. Also of note, Jim Harbaugh's squad had the seventh-most penalty yards. Vernon Davis had a couple of 15-yarders yesterday, and San Francisco had six penalties for 50 yards.
11. Joe Flacco's performance provides a good example of why we should minimize the use of win/loss records for quarterbacks. I thought he played very well: throwing receivers open, buying time with his feet and for the most part, making good decisions. Overall, Flacco completed 22 of 36 passes for 306 yards, two touchdowns and an interception. He threw what could have been the game-winner, but Lee Evans dropped it in the end zone (with a little help from Patriots defensive back Sterling Moore, who knocked the ball free). And he obviously had nothing to do with Cundiff's miss. Flacco was not perfect, but he played well, well enough for his team to win.
12. I thought Manning played relatively well also against a very good 49ers defense. The numbers were not eye-popping: 32-for-58 for 316 yards and two touchdowns. Manning only averaged 5.4 yards per attempt, but he was under pressure all day, and the run game only picked up 3.3 yards per carry. He had a couple throws that could have been intercepted, but 49ers defenders ran into each other. In three playoff games, Manning's thrown eight touchdowns and one pick.
13. Brady was not sharp: 22-for-36 for 239 yards, no touchdowns and two interceptions. Brady's two lowest playoff QB ratings have been against the Ravens. In 2010, he had a 49.1 rating in a 33-14 loss. And yesterday, he had a 57.5 rating. Afterwards, Brady deflected praise from Jim Nantz and said he sucked pretty bad. I'm guessing Pats fans appreciate that accountability and will forgive him as New England goes to its fifth Super Bowl in 11 seasons.
14. In 2007, the Giants held the Bucs (Jeff Garcia), Cowboys (Tony Romo) and Packers (Brett Favre) to a total of 51 points before reaching the Super Bowl and limiting the Patriots (Tom Brady) to 14 points. This year, the Giants have held the Falcons (Matt Ryan), Packers (Aaron Rodgers) and 49ers (Alex Smith) to 39 points in three games. If they hold Brady and the Pats to 14 points this time around, is the 2012 run more impressive? Probably. Steve Spagnuolo earned a head-coaching opportunity by directing the first run. Perry Fewell could be in position to do the same if the Giants' D plays well in a couple weeks.
15. And some leftovers: 49ers rookie Aldon Smith had 14 sacks in the regular season and two more in the playoffs. ...That sure sounded like a quick whistle to me on the Ahmad Bradshaw fumble/non-fumble in the fourth. ... I was impressed with Ray Lewis supporting Cundiff in his post-game press conference. Lewis has played 16 NFL seasons and knows his chances of getting another Super Bowl ring are shrinking. He could have ripped Cundiff for the miss, but he didn't, saying the Ravens win as a team and lose as a team. ...I'm hoping NFL Films caught the back and forth between Lewis and Brady, who were jawing after a Brady QB sneak. ...Were the offensive lines bad or the defensive lines just really good? I'm leaning towards the latter, but could be swayed. ...Great interception by Bernard Pollard and rookie Jimmy Smith in the end zone in the fourth quarter.
You can follow me on Twitter or become a fan of Moving the Chains on Facebook.
Why the Giants are in their second SB in less than 5 yrs (winning one): 1) Better talent evaluators 2) Better "game day" coaching 3) Better "player manangement" 4) Better QB. 5) Better Defensive scheme. Not rocket science people. A) The Eagles only have 1 or 2 of the first round picks from the past 5+ yrs in the starting lineup. B) Eagles lost several of their games this year in the 4th Qtr C) QB was out of at least 3 games and was ineffective in 60% of the games he did play D) Eagles lost several games by less than 7 pts. E) Eagles blew one game with a 20 pt lead in the 4th Qtr alone.— Citizenc92-
Vontaze Burfict All American Linebacker from ASU.
He is what the Eagles Need.
Google him and agree.
— dmanphilly - Alex Smith seemed unwilling to throw the ball to anybody but Vernon Davis. This lack of confidence happens in championship games sometimes. Remember when Donovan refused to throw the ball to the WRs against Carolina. The window may be small, but you can't keep dumping the ball off or you lose.— banned
- Donovan couldn't throw to the WRs because they got absolutely abused at the line of scrimmage by the DBs. They couldn't get off the line at all.
- With Reid's lousy game day management,same old offensive philosophy and Vick's bad QB-ing expect the same disappointments next season.— RobertB
- Final thought about Vick vs. Manning. Vick played 10-12 games of superb QB in 2010, some of the best ever seen in this town. However the rest of the time, he has been the normal Mike Vick career wise, the greatest QB runner ever with a great arm and propensity to turn the ball over. His health is in decline, and there won't be another 2010 3/4 season from now on. He doesn't have the rest of Manning's skills to compensate.— banned
- Watching the games this weekend should convince the army of Eagles fan lemmings that this team has no shot at a Super Bowl. But keep on spouting the gosple according to Jeffrey, Joe and Andy, buy your jersies and tickets. Eagles are now the worst run franchise in the city, far and away.— jimmymack
- The Eagles will pass of Burfict for an undersized DE from San Jacinto State & Burfict will fall....right into the Giants lap a la JPP.— GMEN7777
- There was a story this weekend about hw the Eagles prefer fast over big on defense. I really didn't get that at all. In their back seven, the only player who would be considered to have above average speed at his position is Rolle. You can contrast that with Coleman who has below average.
So basically the Eagles D is average size and below average speed in the secondary, and below average size and average speed at LB— banned - not to mention Charmin-soft and poorly coached. — coloradoeagle
- The Giants again show the value of a tall, big DL. And their DBs are not afraid to tackle.— 4thand10
- I told you the day after Spags got released he would not come to Philly. After what Reid did to McDermott, (blaming him for the Eagles collapse at the end of the year) no assistant wanted to work for Reid except old retired guys who can't catch on with any other team.
As for comparisons of the hapless Philadelphia Eagles who haven't been a factor since the 60s, when they actually were an elite team with the storied New York Giants who have won so many chamionships and superbowls shows yours and Reid's total ignorance of who thew Eagles are. Also, The Giants have Eli Manning. The Patriots have Tom Brady. The Eagles have Mike cough,cough Vick. Do you understand now????— mario1239 - Man for man...the giants are better....I hate them, but they are better and I am just talking about the coach, the GM, the talent evaluator, the accountant, and the owner.....— nuggett
-
- Like everyone else, the Eagles employ college scouts, but they ignore them in favor of Andy's and Howie's special insight of hidden (usually because it really isn't there) NFL talent. They truly are geniuses at bringing out the hidden mediocrity in underweight players with bad knees, small size and high motors. They have honed their brilliance into the vaunted Leave No Speedy Midget Behind Program, which results in low, low salary caps and high, high profit margins. Maybe that's what Lurie meant when he said Reid has "intangibles."— NM Eagle fan
- This is coming from a major Giants/Eli basher.........
Comparing the Giants and the Eagles is not even a relevant comparison because really the Eagles don't even deserve to be in the conversation.
Giants play big in the playoffs, period! They're always the underdog yet they're always either upsetting someone or at least very much in the game. WHY????
It's simple Defense Defense Defense. And (this one really hurts to say) But their QB is always a money guy. Eli and Phil Simms, not the greatest of all time, not huge stat guys BUT they know how to protect the ball in big games AND they have the YOU KNOW WHAT'S to make the big throws when it counts. Vick and McNabb are/were the polar opposite and the Eagles defenses ALWAYS came up small in the big games, even Gang Green as much as it hurts to say.— Phinally - One thing I hope Michael Vick gets out of the playoffs is how both the 49ers and Packers QBs ran in key situations.
They ran just enough for the 1st downs and what extra was just given to them....but.......
They managed to keep their ribs and brains pretty much intact.
— Ernie Garman - unlike Reid and Eagles, Giants dont rely on "gimmicks" and try to "outsmart" anyone; they simply have a qb who can throw accurately (not try to "run and throw") and try to get players who can block and cover and tackle and receivers who can catch and linemen who are big and can rush the passer and tackle..they preach discipline and doing their jobs and amazingly every few years when they get hot at the right time their method works and they're back in the SB competing for yet another championship... compare that to the Eagles these past 13 yrs with their constant lack of discipline and pay calling, always getting penalized at worst moments, taking timeouts because they are ill-prepared and out-of-sync, our of position, missing tackles, etc etc etc... Eagles fans may hate the Giants but their classic blue collar appraoch to football these past 25 years, and all their success, is something to envy and to imitate..alas Eagles mgmt seems to proud but to continue to doing it "their way" and of course failing— warbiscuit
- Everybody likes to talk about 13 years of Andy and no Super Bowl, but the larger laugh is 25 plus years of "running quarterbacks," starting with Cunningham in '86, Rodney Peete, McNabb, and Vick. No running quarterback has ever won a Super Bowl, Steve Young doesn't count as he was a pocket passer by the time his Niners beat the Chargers. Total statues however, have won it see Trent Dilfer, Brad Johnson, Mark Rypien.— eaglescali
- "Steve Young doesn't count as he was a pocket passer WHO LED HIS TEAM IN RUSHING IN THE SUPERBOWL by the time his Niners beat the Chargers"
There. Fixed it for you.
— JLB - ya, ya, ya and the Eagles will still beat out the gmen next yr for first place in division and then lose in playoffs. That could happen for the next 3 yrs, then the gmen will sneak in the playoffs and make a run to bowl, while eagles go on decline again with no superbowl. Isnt that how it works? Great posts on the running qbs, as an Eagles fan Im tired of that route, please just draft a pocket passer in this years deep QB draft and have him learn behind Vick for a year or two.— peteike
- I wish you would not rub it in with the Bowman info Sheil. What a blown draft that was for the birds, so many quality players missed, Bowman another example— camasbud
- These are the same comments that were posted about the NY Giants in 2006.— MasterOFunk
- ONe item you failed to mention. Jim Harbaugh needs to grow up. He barely acknowledged Tom Coughlin after the game, and he refused to talk to Fox Sports after the game. Hey, Jim! You're not coaching college ball, anymore. And, FTR, as hard as it is for Eagles fans and Eagles "journalists" to admit, you can not include Michael Vick in any conversation regarding quarterbacks, any more than you can include Tim Tebow. And one last thing. Remember: Elite quarterback starts with "E-L-I".— pigday31
- Hindsight is 20-20 but I remember a lot of people had questions about JPP, saying he was more of an athlete than a football player, maturity issues etc. B. Graham was viewed as more NFL ready. This is a fact.
And it certainly does seem like the Giants are one of the best run organizations in sports....but if the Eagles are so terrible, why have they beaten the Giants 7 out of the last 8 times INCLUDING knocking them out of the playoffs when they were the #1 seed?
— juaniflaco - would you rather beat the Giants during the regular season or win a Super Bowl? — coloradoeagle
- Giants have far more heart and are twice as tough. As odd as this is I can't say that I hate this Giants team. They play smart hard football. Our team is soft, just like our owner and fat coaches gut
- As an old boxer once said "everyone has a plan until they get hit" just ask Mike Vick. No SB with him. Eli was hit 29 times. And won. Of course he is much bigger and most importantly tougher than Vick. Tired of these street guys being "the baddest/toughest". It is a myth. Mike got paid and winning is down on the list. Eli got paid and winning is on the top of the list. Eli may look like a dufus but he is a dam good one. Wish we had him.— oldBird
- For once, I agree with warbiscuit. 100%. The Eagles are a joke of an organization compared with the Giants. And why? The Giants -- like the Steelers and the Patriots -- have serious, savvy owners devoted to long-term success. The Eagles don't. That's why the Giants have three Super Bowl wins in the past 25 years, the Steelers six since 1975, and the Patriots three in this century. If the Eagles had owners like that, who demand and expect top-flight performance, they might be mentioned in that group. Instead they have Mr. & Mrs. Film Producer.— Dave Clemens
I thought this was an Eagles spot but with all the GIANTS A## kissing on here hahahaha I am not sure. Five weeks ago y'all the same folks who was saying how weak and mediocre the N.F.C East was...The Division Champion A'ints that finished 9-7 to the Eagles 8-8... A Giants coach 4 weeks ago on the hot seat now he is in the SUPERBOWL... Hey I am sure the A'INTS are looking for some FAKE A$# fans now y'all chance hahahaahhahah- Since you mentioned the 2010 draft, in the 2004 draft Wilfolk was chosen about 5 picks in back of the Eagles selection, Shawn Andrews. Ah, what the heck, he gave us a couple of good years and left, like all of Andy's picks. Oh and whats the chance that you would ever hear Donovan McNabb say he sucked after a game.— watsonmr
- And all you guys wanted Coughlin fired, the reason the Giants win is because they have a great QB.— dwilly
- Whole lotta love for Eli...he had a good season this year, awful last year, not sure why he is getting praised for Sunday, after the 9ers shut down Cruz, Eli did virtually nothing despite throwing almost 60 passes...but the Giants won so the QB gets the credit...just more flavor of the day mentality. Anyone notice that Coughlin is now throwing the ball more than Reid? Belichick too. Understandable, but interesting...which reminds me...where is Hindsight? Come out, come out, wherever you are.— tpizza
- Sheil - we can't blame Harbaugh for Cundiff's miss. If he calls a time out there and Cundiff still misses a chip shot, the media blames him for icing his own kicker a la Jason Garrett. It's a no win. Blame the idiot kicker.— dragoon6
- Not sure what games the author was watching. Flacco was horrible, he had many open receivers all night 'un'covered by non-existent pats' secondary. If he was anything close to Manning (Eli) in skill, that game wouldn't have been close. Manning played really well, made only a few mistakes against great D.— glroark
- Whoever hires Perry Fewell as a head coach is a sucker. The team was 9-7 during the regular season and got beat by some mediocre teams (including the Vick-less Eagles).— p-diddy
- jlcharles: The dream is over when they play New England, then it's back to getting beat by the Eagles.
mario1239: "...Eagles who haven't been a factor since the 60s..." Go ahead and criticize them for not winning a Super Bowl, but don't give me this cr*p about them not being a factor. From 2001-2008 they went to 5 NFC Championship games and one Super Bowl.
4thand10: The Eagles' defensive line in just fine. The Giants defensive backfield is average at best; it's their defensive line that's good. If all the Eagles do is add one decent linebacker, the Eagles' defense will be better than the Giants' next season. Actually, wasn't the Eagles' D ranked ahead of the Giants' THIS season?
I realize this is the Giants' moment. Just trying to provide some perspective to those making irrational arguments.— p-diddy 
I get sick watching Jason Pierre-Paul every week. This is the guy who the Eagles could have had instead of Brandon Graham. They even traded up ahead of the Giants leaving Paul for them.— MoRacker- Hey Eagles fans.......Don't you wish you had a Victor Cruz? hahaha!— MRD
Follow
Sheil on Twitter. And become
a fan of Moving the Chains on Facebook.
Download our NEW iPhone/Android app for even more Birds
coverage, including app-exclusive videos and analysis. Download it here.
