Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH
share
email
font size
options
 
Thursday, October 29, 2009

Except for the fact that I love Philadelphia and I want any of our teams to win, I don't care that much about baseball (Go Phillies!!!!!!). But I love any story about management and sports because the lessons apply to any endeavor. So, I'd like to recommend "Money Ball," a baseball book by Michael Lewis. 

Here's how pathetic I am. Even though I read and loved this book, I can never remember the name of the team (it's the Oakland Athletics, way formerly, the Philadelphia Athletics). Anyway, they had a low hiring budget, so their manager, Billy Beane, trusted some number-crunchers who developed a theory about what type of players would create the best success of the team. Success was defined as ability to win games.

The stat the crunchers settled on was not the usual batting average, or runs-batted-in. They looked at on-base percentage (whatever that is) and slugging percentage (another mystery term). The players with high stats in those elements hadn't moved to the top of the draft lists and so were cheaper. The debate was over whether these stats were more predictive of success or  whether the "gut" feeling of scouts had more validity.

Even though I didn't recognize the name of one player and didn't have a clue who Billy Beane is or was, I loved this book, because it raises the question of the value of measurement. 

It seems so easy, in a way. But it is really tricky to come up with a definition of success. (Read a similar discussion in the business book classic "Good to Great.") And then, it is even harder to find the measurement that will match that definition. Because baseball is such a statistics-rich sport with a relative narrow range of goals, Billy Beane's job was fairly easy, although he had to have tremendous courage to overcome immense pressure from his scouts and other baseball old timers.

In the end, .... well, you'll just have to read the book. Meanwhile, go Phillies! Even I know enough to hate the Yankees.        

Posted by Jane Von Bergen @ 4:05 AM  Permalink | 4 comments
Comments   
Posted 11:44 PM, 10/26/2009
JesseH
[crickets...]
Posted 12:29 AM, 10/27/2009
JimG
The Moneyball craze ended a few years ago. The A's have been pretty much a flop since that book came out.
Posted 04:15 AM, 11/01/2009
youngmc100
I also can't believe someone is plugging Moneyball in late October of 2009. Try six and a half years ago! Michael Lewis was at the Free Library then as part of their annual summertime Baseball Writing Panel. Back on June 12, 2003, it was Roger Angell, (the late) David Halberstam, Michael Lewis, Joe Queenan and moderated by Nicholas Dawidoff. Seeing spectacularly shoddy posts like this make me even more depressed that I'm a victim of cutbacks in print media.
Posted 06:15 PM, 11/02/2009
Jane Von Bergen
I'm not plugging the book as a baseball book, YoungMc100. I could care less, as I said, about baseball. I think the idea of Moneyball is intriguing. The idea is that you can find a statistic and use it to measure success. A lot of stock-pickers have various stats that govern their decisions about what to buy. The art is in picking the statistic. But then does an over-reliance on statistics curb other kinds of judgment? A similar debate is happening in education where people wonder if colleges overly rely on SAT tests. Are they the best predictor of success at school? Your response is very narrow. I was trying to talk about a bigger idea while, in the spirit of the season, attaching it to baseball. But I see I drove you all batty.
4 comments
About Jane M. Von Bergen
Jane M. Von Bergen covers workplace issues, health insurance and organized labor for the Philadelphia Inquirer. A longtime business writer, she is now covering her second recession. Von Bergen began her reporting career in fourth grade and then married into it, falling in love with a photographer she met working while working for her college newspaper. They have two college-age sons, neither of whom is studying journalism.
Jobs At a Loss: An Inquirer Series