Saturday, October 25, 2014
Inquirer Daily News

Cop's sucker punch gives force another black eye

A video showing a Philadelphia police lieutenant unexpectedly punching a woman in the face represents yet another damaging blow to the Police Department's already tarnished reputation.

Cop's sucker punch gives force another black eye

Aida Guzman´s lower lip was split when she was hit by a policeman at Sunday´s Puerto Rican Day Parade. (Yong Kim / Staff Photographer)
Aida Guzman's lower lip was split when she was hit by a policeman at Sunday's Puerto Rican Day Parade. (Yong Kim / Staff Photographer)

A video showing a Philadelphia police lieutenant unexpectedly punching a woman in the face represents yet another damaging blow to the Police Department’s already tarnished reputation.

The images of a decorated cop, Lt. Jonathan Josey, walking up behind a bystander at the Puerto Rican Day celebration Sunday — and then striking her to the ground with two bloodying blows — are shocking and, as a police officers’ group described the scene, “deplorable.”

It’s conceivable that a police Internal Affairs investigation into the incident ordered Monday by Police Commissioner Charles H. Ramsey will reveal details that prove Josey’s actions were within bounds. But there’s certainly no hint of that in the video. Aida Guzman, appears to pose no threat. Nothing in the video suggests she did anything to warrant being pummeled before being arrested on a disorderly conduct charge for allegedly throwing water on police.

So Ramsey needs to make sure the in-house probe is conducted thoroughly and swiftly, with the full results immediately disclosed to the public. The commissioner also needs to offer greater assurances that he has a workable strategy to require higher standards of conduct, especially in the department’s upper ranks.

Was the YouTube video of a Phila. cop punching a woman in the face evidence of police brutality?
Yes, the cop clearly ‘lost it’ in a moment of anger
No, need to know the full story before deciding
Yes, video shows clearly woman was no threat, with back turned to officer
No, officer might have suspected he’d been sprayed with a dangerous liquid, not just water

In addition to Josey, who runs a violence-prevention program in his spare time and has been honored for crime-fighting heroics, several police commanders recently have been accused of misconduct. But a full accounting for Josey’s troubling YouTube moment must be a priority for Ramsey.

About this blog

The Inquirer Editorial Board's Say What? opinion blog showcases the work of the editors and writers who produce the newspaper's daily and Sunday opinion pages.

Find out more about The Inquirer's Editorial Board here.

The Inquirer Editorial Board
Also on Philly.com
Stay Connected