Posted: Tuesday, August 23, 2011, 11:12 AM | 16 comments |
 
options
 
Michael Vick graced the cover of ESPN's NFL preview issue, but who will be the offensive linemen tasked to protect him?

Our eight-day look at who makes the Eagles’ 53-man roster continues today with a look at the offensive line (Here’s the Day 1 look at defensive end).

This position may be the most interesting position when it comes to who stays and who goes because new offensive line coach Howard Mudd has made some drastic changes in terms of style and personnel. A few familiar faces may be on the chopping block.

First cuts come next Tuesday when the 90-man roster is pared down to 80. Final cuts are on Sept. 3.

Likely to keep: 9-10.

Locks: Jason Peters is your starting left tackle. Live with it. Todd Herremans is the left guard unless Andy Reid and company decide that myriad number of (not very attractive) options at right tackle don’t make them queasy. Then Herremans could slide outside, although the Eagles hope to avoid such a move. Top draft pick Danny Watkins is still penciled in as the starting right guard, although he’s a project. Jason Kelce has eked out ahead of stalwart Jamaal Jackson for the starting center spot. Whether he wins or not – and it says here he does – the sixth-round rookie isn’t going anywhere.

Near lock: I’m not sure I get the King Dunlap hate. For a seventh-round pick the Eagles have gotten more than they could rightly ask for from the tackle. He’s not great and his height is always a detriment, but he’s improved with each season in Philadelphia. Dunlap is currently the starting right tackle with Winston Justice and Ryan Harris on the shelf, which is, admittedly, not ideal. But he can play both tackle spots and is a worthy backup. Evan Mathis is a Mudder – not that tall, squatty and athletic. I’m pretty sure St. Joseph’s Prep has a few bigger offensive linemen. But he’s versatile and is insurance at left guard in case Herremans gets the nod to scoot out to right tackle.

Bubble: Even if Jackson isn’t the starter I’m inclined to think he stays. His contract isn’t huge (roughly $1.5 million) and the Eagles need a safeguard in case Kelce struggles. Mike McGlynn would have made Jackson expendable, but he’s played more guard than center under Mudd and has looked, to put it plainly, lost. Hard to believe a 16-game starting center for a playoff team might not make the squad a season later, but that’s the scenario McGlynn faces. He could be trade bait. Harris hasn’t practiced in nearly two weeks because of back spasms. He looked like the man to beat at right tackle early in camp, but has morphed into the second coming of Shawn Andrews. If he’s healthy he’s here, although the Eagles can’t cut an injured player, which would mean he’s here either way. Reggie Wells missed all of camp at Lehigh, so he’s fresher than the rest of the linemen. His signing seemed like a desperate move by a desperate team, but a good showing Thursday against the Browns could help the veteran's cause. Julian Vandervelde was a fifth-round pick so he’s at least assured a spot on the practice squad. I’m sure the Eagles could stow him away there without any other teams plucking him up. Tackle Austin Howard, an undrafted rookie from a year ago, is on the downside of the bubble.

PUP: Justice won’t start the season on the Physically Unable to Perform List, but the prospects of him being back in time for the opener appear dim.

Leave: Reid granted tackle Jose Acuna, an undrafted rookie pickup off waivers, a leave to attend to family matters.

Gone: A.Q. Shipley hardly played last Thursday against the Steelers, but has another year of practice squad eligibility if the Eagles want to keep a center on reserve. The same applies for tackle Fenuki Tupou, who currently has a knee sprain, and guard Dallas Reynolds. Tackle Spencer Johnson is a goner.

Posted by Jeff McLane @ 11:12 AM  Permalink | 16 comments
16
Comments   
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 11:50 AM, 08/23/2011
    A healthy Justice remains the best option at RT. Alas "healthy" is now the operative word.

    The fall of of McGlynn is, indeed, puzzling. Bright enough to make OL line calls while playing C, but not able to p/u Mudd's system. A puzzlement to be sure.

    Starting a pair of rookies - Watkins and Kelce - is "chancy" however the 49ers also started a pair of rookies last season, both of whom played well. So not out of the question.

    Still, a pretty shakey scenario for a team with playoff aspirations.
    FishFryFrank
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 12:13 PM, 08/23/2011
    Ryan Harris is a better player than Winston Justice. Health is apparently going to be an issue though. we all know how backs are, especially with lineman
    Alf
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 12:20 PM, 08/23/2011
    Somebody has to go....after the brain trust realizes without Michael, we go nowhere.....protect his blind side Joe or forget all your good efforts so far....Pick up somebody, release Justice and dunlap....we need good players there, not jsut bodies...
    nuggett
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 12:40 PM, 08/23/2011
    No new news in this article. A little disappointing after reading "A few familiar faces may be on the chopping block."
    Gee Money
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 1:20 PM, 08/23/2011
    Nothing new Gee Money. Another wasted portion of my life. Someone needs to send Tamari back to cover politics!
    Christie-Ate-Me-Again
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 1:35 PM, 08/23/2011
    Why are people shocked about mcglynn?? He wasn't any good last yr. Yes by the end of last season he was decent. But decent dosnt cut it. Yes he was playing out of position too, but he was a big reason Vick was running for his life. Not just him obviously.. The rest of the line helped
    LAdelphia
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 2:39 PM, 08/23/2011
    Get rid of anyone named DALLAS.
    robynk
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 3:45 PM, 08/23/2011
    Why can't Dorembos' roster spot go to someone else. It is a learned skill. It's really a waste to carry a long snapper on the 53 man roster. Bartrum could play some TE.
    shadow22
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 9:32 PM, 08/23/2011
    Agree. It seems a shame to tie up roster spot for a one trick pony other than kickers.
    The Marco Islander
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 11:48 PM, 08/24/2011
    Not all long snappers are created equal. Dorenbos is considered to be pretty good.
    Besides, this is probably not the year you want to mess around with the LS spot. Already have a new kicker and holder, both rookies. Need somebody with NFL experience in there.
    phillychaos
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 6:36 PM, 08/23/2011
    Justice and Dunlap should be working the hotdog stand at the Linc not protecting Vick's blindside. Their calling in life was actually to open a used tire shop near the auto grave yard in Phila. Why is there a problem with two rookies on the Offensive Line, I would rather to rookies with the heart and attitude on the line than a negotiator who Dallas and the Giants use to pad their sack totals.
    Dexter
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 8:08 PM, 08/23/2011
    I've always had the same question as shadow22. Why can't a 2nd string center or TE or whatever be trained to be a long snapper?
    armchairGM
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 10:26 PM, 08/23/2011
    an offensive lineman who cannot draft offensive lineman. the hilarity never ends.
    coloradoeagle
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 12:49 AM, 08/24/2011
    There are a lot of questions on defense too. Casey Matthews looks like a deer in the headlights.
    hallux
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 9:52 AM, 08/24/2011
    Reid and Banner will be cut by week 1.
    Evil Overlord


View comments: 1  |  2
About Jeff McLane and Jonathan Tamari






Jeff McLane (left) began covering the Eagles in April 2009 after covering college sports and Penn State football in particular. Before that he wrote about high school sports and before that he worked in the mailroom (not quite). Find Jeff on Facebook and follow him on Twitter for instant updates on the Eagles.

Jonathan Tamari (right) began covering the Eagles in April 2010. He previously covered New Jersey state government and politics, reporting and writing about elections, policy debates and the many personalities that drive the Garden State, from three recent governors to the many musicians bidding to write the state song. He has been at the Inquirer since June 2008. Follow him on Twitter at @JonathanTamari.

Download our NEW iPhone app for even more Birds coverage, including app-exclusive videos and analysis. Get it here.

Latest Eagles Videos