share
email
font size
options
 
Tuesday, October 27, 2009

Eagles coach Andy Reid said during his 610 WIP radio show tonight that he's "counting on" running back Brian Westbrook to be on the field for Sunday's showdown with the New York Giants, but given the medical guidelines for a concussion, that scenario seems unlikely.

Reid confirmed that Westbrook was unconscious after taking a knee to the helmet from Washington linebacker London Fletcher midway through the first quarter of last night's game at FedEx Field. He also said that Westbrook did not remember what had happened.

Those two signs, according to former Eagles and Flyers team physician Art Bartolozzi, indicate that Westbrook suffered a severe concussion. According to the American Academy of Neurology's grading system, Westbrook suffered a Grade 3 concussion, the most severe type.

Reid said Westbrook was put through a battery of neurological tests with trainer Rick Burkholder that were sent to Pittsburgh. Bartolozzi said the University of Pittsburgh has a computer-generated test that helps measure how severely someone has been impaired.

"If he was unconscious he is probably out at least a few weeks," Bartolozzi said. "Amnesia means the hard drive has been shaken. The brain is like a computer. If you lose data, it tells you something is wrong with the computer."

Bartolozzi said it's also difficult for players to retain their fitness level after they have a concussion.

"One of the things that happens with a head injury is that unlike other parts of the body, exercise does not help the recovery," Bartolozzi said. "It's tough to maintain the fitness because the brain doesn't like a lot of conditioning exercises."

If Westbrook does not play, rookie LeSean McCoy will get the start against the Giants.

Jackson honored

Eagles wide receiver DeSean Jackson will be named the NFC offensive player of the week tomorrow after scoring on a 67-yard run and a 57-yard pass during Monday night's win at Washington.

He was the NFC special teams player of the month for September.

Reid said that Jackson's strain foot should not prevent him from playing Sunday against the Giants.

 

Posted by Bob Brookover @ 6:33 PM  Permalink | 19 comments
19
Comments   
Posted 07:12 PM, 10/27/2009
mosquito killer
why do i get the sense that many in the media want westbrook to be out for a few weeks, maybe even the season? do you get some particular feeling of fulfillment by reporting bad news, so much so that you have to try to argue that a player won't play? does bartolozzi know anything about the specifics of the injury? someone tell him to go worry about the teams he works for and stop sticking his nose in where it doesnt belong...
Posted 07:29 PM, 10/27/2009
mikey48
mosquito killer, I dido that Squito! It is like they keep saying from last year Westbrook is done, and if it wasn't for Brian's play toward the end of 08, especially the Cards on Turkey Day. When he tied Wilbert Montgomery for 4 TDs in one game. Then went on to have over 200 combined yards against the Giants in NY, you think we are in the playoffs, or would of got by Minnesota without his electric 73 yard screen for the TD that iced the game??? http://eagles.fandome.com/video/106894/Brian-Westbrooks-4th-Thanksgiving-TD/ http://madgame.com/videos/1711/eagles-vs-vikings-brian-westbrook-71-yard-touchdown-catch-.html
Posted 07:47 PM, 10/27/2009
drbob1
I think two things are at work here: One is that bad news is news, more so than good news; also there are a number of media that have never been fans of this coach or QB; if Westbrook plays the next few weeks, the Eagles will have a much better shot at winning NFC East than if he doesn't; that would drive some of the media nuts. The second thing is that some of these guys are so impressed with their own intelligence that they can make blanket 'one size fits all' medical evaluations on players based on guidelines they've read in a book somewhere, or based on a quote from a doctor that has never examined the patient. Ironically, these are the same guys that get all bent out of shape when a Dave Spadaro , or other non media member attends a news conference , as though only they know to ask Reid such clever questions as: "Why didn't you run the ball more?" and "wasn't that play the middle linebackers fault?". Pitt has a very sophisticated neurology dept; they will determine whether Westbrook is ready to go, based on what they got from the Eagles. One thing I guarantee isn't a factor is genuine concern for Westbrook, because he doesn't appear to go out of his way to ingratiate himself to members of the media.
Posted 07:51 PM, 10/27/2009
NLRdiva
Its as if you are reading my mind and taking the words out of my mouth. If I have to hear about his age and the downhill battle of RB's I will swear off the media completely....Write about something of value for once...He will be fine...If we dont have him...are chance go down hill dramatically!!! Besides that was such a scary moment..NO joke! I can imagine how is family felt....glad he is better
Posted 08:08 PM, 10/27/2009
billgfc
I would believe the doctors who examine and the trainers. It is all speculation otherwise without firsthand data. I believe the NFL does baseline brain scans of some sort that are compared with a test after injury.
Posted 08:12 PM, 10/27/2009
fred13
Time to give Buckley some playing time!!!!
Posted 08:28 PM, 10/27/2009
Gringo4
Time for #7 to buckle his chin strap ...
Posted 08:45 PM, 10/27/2009
MJPD345
Andy Reid says he's "counting on" Westbrook to play Sunday. That means you have no back up plan after Westbrook. Fatboy,, you drafted Lesean McCoy for this exact scenario.You better start pumping the kid up because gametime is a few days away.." Counting on" ?? He has a severe concussion you Dunce..
Posted 09:00 PM, 10/27/2009
wondo40
Get well B-West, get well. If you feel you're able to go Sunday then more power to you. Despite the constant downpour of negativity that surrounds everything you do, real Eagles fans still value you and feel you have a lot left in the tank. Godspeed in recovery, the Eagles need you. BEAT THE GIANTS! BEAT THE GIANTS! BEAT THE GIANTS!
Posted 09:39 PM, 10/27/2009
abellano
I am gratified to see the notes posted in support of Brian and what he has meant and continues to mean to this team. The moron who calls him "softybrook" should check the record books and ask # 5 how many sacks he has avoided over the years because # 36 is not afraid to block. Ironic, now that they have a real fullback he has this to contend with.
Posted 10:04 PM, 10/27/2009
rw55
If Westbrook suffered a severe concussion, there's no way he should play anytime soon. It's not worth the risk--and he sure doesn't owe the Eagles anything. The evidence about the long term effects of these injuries can't be ignored. (Anybody remember Andre Waters?)
Posted 11:32 PM, 10/27/2009
DHowardisdaman
A severe concussion this time is too much to risk next time. Bwest has done it all and should now ride off with a big smile, into the sunset.
Posted 12:12 AM, 10/28/2009
starbird
time for 36 to retire.... he did all andy could ask in the way of sacrificing his health....
Posted 12:12 AM, 10/28/2009
starbird
time for 36 to retire.... he did all andy could ask in the way of sacrificing his health....
Posted 12:32 AM, 10/28/2009
p-diddy
I can't believe that some people want Westbrook to play through this. He had a severe concussion; there's no way he should be playing this week.
About Birds' Eye View Blog

Bob Brookover, left, is in his seventh year of covering the Philadelphia Eagles after spending 15 years covering the Philadelphia Phillies for the Inquirer and two other newspapers. The 45-year-old Brookover lives in Delran with his wife Francine and roots for Notre Dame and Michigan State, the two schools attended by his children, Justine and Ryan. When Notre Dame plays Michigan State, he cheers for the school of the child he likes more at that particular moment.

Jeff McLane, right, joined the Eagles beat in April 2009 after two years of covering colleges, namely Penn State football. Before that he covered high school sports for The Inquirer. Before that he worked in the mailroom (not quite). Informed that his father is no longer covering the Lions, McLane's eldest, three-year-old son said, "You mean Simba, Scar and Mufasa, Daddy?" His two-year-old son -- excited about the move to the Eagles -- said, "Go, Deigo, Go!" or something like that. His wife of five-plus years, however, had a different take on the new job. "Another five years is in question," she said. Check out McLane on Twitter and Facebook for instant updates on the Eagles.