Eagles' Midterm Report Card
The Philadelphia Inquirer Blog - Eagles
Eagles' Midterm Report Card
Jeff McLane and Jonathan Tamari
It's the Eagles' fall break so we offer our midterm grades for the team's Class of 2010-11:
OFFENSE (B)
Since the horrendous first half against Green Bay in the opener, the Eagles’ offense has found its groove, whether it has been Michael Vick or Kevin Kolb under center. That’s a notable achievement considering that the quarterbacks have dissimilar styles. Offensive coordinator Marty Mornhinweg deserves credit for formulating successful game plans that cater to each quarterback.
His spread-’em-out scheme against the Lions worked to perfection, as did his misdirection-filled play-calling against the Falcons. He could not find a way to penetrate the Redskins’ Cover-2 defense, however, and made some questionable late-game decisions (Chad Hall?) in the Titans loss.
Mornhinweg cannot be tagged for the offensive line’s woes. That blame rests solely on coach Andy Reid, who made the Stacy Andrews-Jason Peters mistakes and did nothing to upgrade the unit in the off-season.
Running backs (A-): LeSean McCoy has done it all: He has rushed for a healthy 4.5 yards per carry and five touchdowns and has led the team with 38 receptions. Even more impressive is how he has done it: with a broken rib and often making tacklers miss. Owen Schmitt has been a nice surprise, providing strong blocking and reliable hands when needed. The Mike Bell bust brings the grade down. The Eagles don’t have a reliable complement to McCoy — or a backup if Shady gets hurt.
Quarterbacks (A-): How did the Eagles get here? Oh, right, they traded Donovan McNabb and handed the job to Kolb. He got hurt, and Vick stepped in and played well. Kolb was demoted, and Vick was given the starting spot. Vick got hurt, and Kolb stepped in and played well. And now, Vick, supposedly close to recovery, will return and start against the Colts on Nov. 7.
Whew. For all the chaos, the quarterback position has been one of the brighter spots for the Eagles, especially when you compare the performance of Vick/Kolb to the way McNabb has played in Washington. Now there’s a quarterback dilemma.
Wide receivers/tight ends (B): The grade of the Eagles’ pass catchers is weighed down slightly by Brent Celek. A year after his breakout season, the tight end’s numbers are down across the board. Starting wideouts DeSean Jackson and Jeremy Maclin have been dazzling for the most part. But Jackson had his concussion, and even before that he was having trouble getting the ball. Jason Avant’s production has slipped, but Riley Cooper appears to be a keeper and could see more time in the second half of the season.
Offensive line (C-): The Eagles have allowed 21 sacks, second worst in the league, and 41 quarterback hits, third worst. Those numbers would be worse if not for some Vick heroics. The line seemed to stabilize until the Tennessee game. The linemen have done well downfield to help pop some big screen plays, and the running game has been moving well. But the blocking crew has combined for 17 penalties, led by Peters’ five.
DEFENSE (C+)
The Eagles are giving up 22.4 points per game, 20th in the NFL, and every time they plug one leak, another seems to open. Most important, they have allowed three big fourth quarters. The D has created some big plays, though. The Eagles’ 16 takeaways are tied for fourth in the NFL, and their 21 sacks rank fifth.
Defensive line (B): Because of the pressure generated by the front four, the Eagles haven’t had to blitz as much as they did last season. Their defense, led by relentless end Trent Cole’s six quarterback sacks, is fifth in the league in sacks per pass attempt. End Juqua Parker got off to a fast start but has cooled despite more snaps. Top draft pick Brandon Graham is going through obvious growing pains. The middle of the line has been an improvement over last season because backups Trevor Laws and Antonio Dixon have progressed.
Linebackers (C): Stewart Bradley and Ernie Sims rank third and fifth on the team in tackles, but they often are making stops after allowing decent gains. We rarely see this group in the opposing backfield, and a few tight ends have gotten loose on them. The linebackers as a whole have combined for two sacks and no interceptions. Moise Fokou has helped since taking over for Akeem Jordan.
Defensive backs (C): If report cards were handed out before the Titans game, this group might have fared better. But cornerback Ellis Hobbs and free safety Nate Allen were so bad in that game that it’s hard to justify a higher mark. Hobbs was just OK before the Tennessee debacle, anyway. Allen was better, equaling cornerback Asante Samuel, with three interceptions. But he wasn’t tested very much considering that he is only a rookie. That should change. Samuel still has tackling issues, but he’s as good a cover man as there is. Strong safety Quintin Mikell looks more like his 2008 self.
SPECIAL TEAMS (C-)
The Eagles have been hurt by big returns that set up opposing scores. They are near the bottom of the league in both punt and kickoff coverage. The punt- and kick-return games have been average. Sav Rocca is in the top 10 in both punting average and net average. David Akers’ four misses tie him for third most in the NFL, although they all came in one bad week.
COACHING (B)
The impulse is to look at “The Tennessee Meltdown” and “The Washington Gut-Punch,” (Great rock band names, huh?) and conclude that Andy Reid and his assistants have done a subpar job through seven games. But factor in three road victories and an impressive stomping of Atlanta and what you have is pretty much what you would have expected in the bye week: a 4-3 record.
Expectations were tempered for a relatively young team before the season, with many forecasting a record between 8-8 and 10-6. But somewhere along the line (maybe it had something to do with the weak NFC), hopes were raised and then tempered in Tennessee.
Reid, too, got caught up in the fever and ditched his rebuilding, retooling, whatever-you-want-to-call-it plan
when he made the quarterback switch. It remains to be seen whether he made the right call. So far, with a patchwork offensive line and coordinator Sean McDermott’s Jekyll-and-Hyde defense, quarterback appears to be the least of his worries.
Buy Eagles tickets Buy Eagles tickets 
soprano...I wish you would only hit submit once. LOSER!
face it Reid should be fired...he has been out coached in every big game the Birds played...made bad draft picks and personal decisions...time for a change...please take howie and joe with you andy...don't let the door hit you on the way out!!— PHILLYMARK- Yes, we've had very good QB play for the most part, which I'd average out to a B-plus. In three games, the overall QB play was just okay at best --yes, the three losses.
if yuou want to just look at passer rating, yes, you can read off a chart that both Vick and Kolb have higher passer ratings than McNabb. And they should: they have much better skill players, a stable system and don't think the Skins' O-line is any better.
Still, McNabb (with medicocre stats, to be sure) went to a 4-12 team, and they are 4-3. The eagles were 11-5 last year, and they are also 4-3. The Skins won the head-to-head in Philly.
That all means a little more to me than the lazy reading of passer ratings. They're not individuals playing the same golf course.— MG44 - Look at the teams we have beat, aside from Atlanta (which may be a fraud) the other three teams were absolute stiffs. The talent on both the team and coaching is a C- to a D. Hobbs will hurt this team again if given the chance
- Wow!I wish I had you homers when I was in school. The Eagles are a giant D- in all areas.Start with the clueless Lurie/Banner/Reid "front office" and go no further. As Dennis Green stated "they are what we thought they were". LOSERS !!!— soprano50
- Wow!I wish I had you homers when I was in school. The Eagles are a giant D- in all areas.Start with the clueless Lurie/Banner/Reid "front office" and go no further. As Dennis Green stated "they are what we thought they were". LOSERS !!!— soprano50
- Wow!I wish I had you homers when I was in school. The Eagles are a giant D- in all areas.Start with the clueless Lurie/Banner/Reid "front office" and go no further. As Dennis Green stated "they are what we thought they were". LOSERS !!!— soprano50
- 4-3 as a team = C+.— rubicon24
- 4-3 as a team = C+.— rubicon24
- Young teams are tough to grade. This is the transition year. Vick will star but I'd bet he's gone next year but Klob is getting there. 'B' is better than I'd hoped at this point and it is deserved.— jjthree
8-8 and an A+ DRAFT ...johnnyu- Green Pants (F)— Rabe56
- I don't know how Graham is going through growing pains. He was supposed to rush the passer on 3rd downs, pretty simple. Dline has to keep Bunkley off the field and stay with Dixon,he's playing much better.— watsonmr
- fire McDammit and let the D coach itself! Opie!— osi is hurt boohoo
- "
DeSean Jackson and Jeremy Maclin have been dazzling for the most part. But Jackson had his concussion, and even before that he was having trouble getting the ball." this is not exactly a true statement, Kolb couldn't get Jackson the Ball.... Vick to Jackson seems to be a lethal combination with some degree of consistancy. This Riley Cooper could be the Eagles slot receiver.... Jackson is to small a receiver to continue on crossing routes. Celek, a funny thing about crossing the middle in the NFL is that it changes a players desire to play in the NFL and rather quickly. Celek's arms have seemed to have gotten shorter since last year, at least between the hash marks.
Ernie Sims is a bust, period. Cut him now. Trade Hobbs and package special teams coach Bobby April to Camden High before their trade stock further diminishes...
— Dexter - Hmmm....8/16 is 1/2. If my 5th grade math is correct, right Keyboard? Oh well, 7 games is enough for them. I'd like to see the secondary step it up a notch. Place on next years to-do list, right next to "draft o-line". Allen is a good surprise and I'm excited to see what he's going to do in the future. McGlynn is also better than expected. I'm anxious to see where this season is headed. Not quite sure we've seen this team's identity yet. Playoffs, with this division? Just might!
- Shouldn't midterm be after game #8?
- How does giving up the second most sacks and third most hits on the QB, plus all the penalties translate into a C- for the OL? More like D- IMO. How does 20th in the NFL in points allowed translate into a C+? C- maybe. Coaching B? No way. Too many dumb penalties and lack of making in-game adjustments. Who really wrote this piece...Eskin?
- "But he wasn’t tested very much considering that he is only a rookie. That should change." - in reference to Nate Allen. You better believe Peyton is licking his chops for the game two Sundays from now. This team is who we thought they were: A team that will beat the bad teams and lose to the good teams. Is Atlanta really that good, or are they being very advantageous against the lesser teams? If the Eagles can go 2-3 before the Dallas game, they have a shot of stealing a playoff berth, because at that point Dallas (twice) and Minnesota might be out of the running and could care less.
— ESFjellin - If we don't win 40-3 every week, then I give a D- grade:the musings of the typical Philly blogger. Get real people.— tommy_the_k
- Wow, I'd give lower grades because I just don't believe the team is competitive.— 4thand10
- they've won 4, lost 3 and you think they're not competitive? that's odd. If they weren't able to compete they'd be 0-7 — HuskerEagleFan
- the way this season is playing out the Eagles are right in the mix. I give them an incomplete as the only thing that matters is not how they start but how and where they finish. 4-3 followed by 6-3 gives them 10 wins. The games against the cowboys that seemed like losses in august may now be walkovers. Giants make too many turnovers and there is no way we lose again to the Redskins. A young team should get better as the season goes along.— notch44
- Coaching should be a C at best. Their failure to make adjustments resulted in losses to Green Bay and Washington. The defense should be a C-. Offensive line grade is reasonable since they do a good job with the run.— arrowamy
Average would be a C. Fat Andy hasn't earned a B, not by a longshot. Factor in the grades of Andy the GM (or if you prefer, Howie the Puppet GM) and Bottom Line Joey, this team is lucky to rate a C. For as winnable as this division is, the Eagles are not good enough to win it even in a weakened state.— Doctor D- If the offensive line has given up the second most sacks in the league, then how the heck do you rate them a "C-"? I rate the O-Line a flat "F". They failed! Our defense is ranked 20th in the league, so how do you rank them a "C+"? Middle of the packed is about 15-16th, that is where "C+" is. I rate the defense a flat "D". Our QBs have been great, I give them a straightup "A". Coaching gets a "C" at best. Mainly because I give Mcdermott a flat "F". He has been a HORRIBLE Defensive Cordinator for TWO years now. This guy is in over his head and he is not getting everything out of this defense. He has cost us two wins already. He needs to be replaced.— ChrisM
- Forget the letter grades. This team is average. There are some that are above average, such as Vick, McCoy, Jackson and Maclin. Likewise there are some that are below average, such as Graham, Peters, Jordan and Hobbs.
Nonetheless at the end of the day, they are average. They have been able to go out 4-3 because the league this year is so . . . average.— BMJ - Isn't the NFL, as a whole, average every year? Do you mean the Eagles have been able to go out 4-3 because the NFL is worse than in previous years?
Comment removed.
i give the team as a whole a solid B at this point.
