Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH
TEXT SIZE: A A A A
Email this post | Back to Blog home
Thursday, April 24, 2008
The Trouble With Obama
Blog Image

Campaign sharpies are busy dissecting Barack Obama's weakness in the Philly suburbs, but I'm going to add something to today's column on his problems with some whites and Jews.

It came via e-mail by Susan Brown, who was canvassing for Obama in her Montgomery County hometown of Dresher. The attorney wrote:

In February I was a 55 year old white woman trying to choose a candidate, feeling drawn to Hillary. Then I listened to Obama speak and I was inspired. I felt as I had not felt since March 16, 1968 (my 16th birthday) when Bobby Kennedy announced he was running for president. So I chose Obama and volunteered to help his campaign.

I cancassed in my local area, Dresher. As I spoke to my neighbors, my heart sank. Several people told me the country wasn't ready for a black president. One person right out said he would never vote for a black person for president. (Stunned, I stammered that he was only half black.) One person said "the blacks get everything already." Three of my Jewish neighbors (and friends) said that they believed Obama either was a Muslim or had Muslim ties.

Well  I guess these people represented more Montgomery County residents than I had hoped. I volunteered for Bobby and have my heart broken on June 5, 1968. I gave up on politics for many years, doing little more than vote. Not until Obama did I feel how I had felt about Bobby. My heart is broken again.

Will we ever have my dream of a president who can bring all races together, and speak to us like adults and not scream and lie and distort the truth? ...

In addition to a cheesesteak, Obama should have had a bagel.

...

Another letter came in after the column, this one from Cherry Hill-reared Dan Berrigan, 23, a grad student in Atlanta. He wonders whether the North is more racist than the South. He writes:

As I watched the Pennsylvania primary unfold I began to see something about Pennsylvania, and the north as a whole that was extremely disheartening. It is the belief held by many whites in Pennsylvania and New Jersey that America is not ready for a black president. To me,  this reeks of racial bias and ignorance. A year ago, I was talking to a friend of mine at lunch who has lived in the south all his life. He mentioned to me that he thought the north was more racist than the south. His reasoning was that in the south, white and black folks have been forced to live together and work together for years now. It's nothing new anymore. Sure there are bigots out there, but most have had to confront their racial biases at some point or another. Basically, it's been forced out into the open. He continued that in the north, people quickly moved out into the suburbs away from blacks in the city and basically have avoided the issue entirely. As a result, many have not had to confront their biases towards a particular race of people. I feel like if Obama had been a white man, people would vote for him with the rationale of, "We aren't ready for a woman president."

We have had black mayors, governors, senators, representatives, and even Secretaries of State. Why is president "off limits"? When does a race of people become 'ready' for America? How is that judged exactly?

Does it require more than the support of millions of people ready to throw their hard earned money at them? And why is it that people in my generation seem to see him as a person almost universally, but older folks can't see Barack for more than his skin color?

I'd be interested to see too how white folks in the south went for
Obama versus white folks in the north. Because frankly, between reading some of the comments posted on Philly.com, and comments made by people I know, I am beginning to believe my friend is right. A large number of people in Pennsylvania, New Jersey, etc. are too simple-minded or afraid to confront their own racial biases, and would rather hide behind a flimsy argument. It's really pathetic. I hope I am wrong, and that my friend is wrong. I understand this argument against Obama is used by people of all states, but why did this seem like the elephant in the room to me?

 

Posted by Daniel Rubin @ 10:29 AM  Permalink | 23 comments
Comments
12:07 PM, 04/24/2008
Unfortunately the same thing happened to me while I was canvassing in a blue collar neighborhood in Delco. Luckily my county did win for Obama, but....if one looks at the town and township breakdown throughout the county, you can easily view it as a snapshot of how the entire state voted: the upper income, educated and more culturally liberal areas (Media, Swarthmore, etc) went for Obama, along with the heavily AA communities. Those more traditional, white Catholic "Reagan Democrats" came out for Hillary. I am trying very hard to stay inspired, after all PA is just one state and there are ten more to go, but the results - not so much the actual losing margin as we shouldn't be surprised it was still almost ten points - of the voting patterns that came out of the counties leave me brokenhearted also. Race is and will be a big factor and whomever tells you it isn't, is as untruthful as those voters who answered the pollsters leading up to the primary. From now on I am going to subract about five-eight points to whatever number Obama is polling and call it the Ed Rendell effect - "this (name your)state isn't ready to vote for a black president".
Posted by domenica
12:14 PM, 04/24/2008
Why not explore why Obama couldn't make more inroads even though he had a huge ad blitz?? Shouldn't he of used these ads as a Bio instead of "Guess what I did?! I went to Detroit to tell them cars are bad" ads.
Posted by jeffreyg61
12:15 PM, 04/24/2008
Obama never had a shot. I called it months and months ago. America will throw Obama a bone, but in the end he will ultimately get CRUSHED. America is not ready for a minority or woman to become President. The social implications are HUGE. A group that had been oppressed through out history, would suddenly have a sense of pride and entitlement. America is not ready for this change. Obama is great man and he is paving the way. In 16-20 years, a minority or a woman will get their shot, but it will be short lived. 1 term, as America eperiences the social effects..and are none too happy with it..
Posted by Leron
12:19 PM, 04/24/2008
Like Susan Brown, I had my heart broken in 1968. As a college student in D.C., I witnessed the city going up in flames in the aftermath of MLK's assassination. The images of the Vietnam War seen on television are also burned into my memory. The death of Bobby Kennedy on the eve of my graduation was the final blow. There has not been a Presidential candidate until Obama who inspires the noble idealism that dissapeared in 1968. I feel so pessimistic about the future of our country and the world.
Posted by irishartdoc
12:38 PM, 04/24/2008
I think this is pessismism is ridiculous. First of all, all the folks who are now deciding that neither a woman nor an African American can be elected president might have thought of that before the Democrats had only that choice. There were a few other options. However, we've go what we've got - which is a President and a government that is a disaster, and a Repubican candidate who was able to do, or did, precious little to head off that disaster. John McCain may be a white guy, but he's a white guy who can't run far enough from his responsibility in this. The problem is that the Democrats have been fighting each other on personality issues instead of going after the Republicans, including McCain, on substance. The tide will turn against McCain when that happens, no matter who the Democratic candidate is. The other part of this is that every Democrat and Democratic candidate needs to get behind the party's chosen representative and work very, very hard. That will come, too, I think. As for the suburbs: yes, I heard all sorts of concerns about Obama and Israel, too, when I went to exercise at the JCC. And there are some folk who will not be assured or assuaged. But McCain has his problems, too, and it is silly to forget that.
Posted by rms
01:12 PM, 04/24/2008
As a registered Republican, I didn't have a part in this fight. However, I was impressed that many of my middle aged male friends who are "blue collar" (as I am) decided to vote for Obama. I disagree that America is not ready for a black president. The Obama supporters are going to have to come to grips with the fact that the events of the last month or so, coupled with a shaky debate performance, make the INDIVIDUAL look as though he may not be ready. Also, when one considers Obama's apparent belief that all he has to do is meet somebody and he can make them like him (I've actually seen quotes attributed to him saying that) or declaring at rallies "at some point tonight you will have an epiphany" etc. - and it's pretty clear the guy needs a slice of humble pie. As for myself, I would vote for a black president in a NY minute if they shared my political beliefs, (Walter Williams, Alan Keys, even Colin Powell before he sullied his otherwise stellar reputation)
Posted by DPJ
01:27 PM, 04/24/2008
This "The country isn't ready for a black president" talk is complete garbage. We've had black governors, black senators, black representatives, and black mayors. Some have done great jobs, some not so great. This country was built on being judged by who you are as a person and your value to society, not on your skin color. In my opinion, people who say "We aren't ready for a black president," are really saying, "I'M not ready for a black president". To me, that speaks loudly to the inner racial biases that still exist. It's pathetic that these people would rather dismiss a man based on his skin color rather than learn about him. My guess is that if Obama were a white man, they would be saying, "We're not ready for a woman president."
Posted by s1apnutz
03:02 PM, 04/24/2008
Obama would need a ticket that can be trusted by Catholics, Jews, blue collar workers, and those who worry about defense and terrorism, which makes Joe Biden the perfect answer as VP.
Posted by atp2007
05:41 PM, 04/24/2008
I agree i think when the democrat nominate a Obama the democrats will come home we can't elect Mccain and for those who won't vote for Obama don't because if you vote for Mccain you are voting against your own economic good all because you can't get over your racist views. I believe there are more americans out there that have more of an open mind and think with their heads instead of their illusions about a person's skin color.
Posted by USMC07
10:08 PM, 04/24/2008
People who say that America isn't ready for a black President don't even know what it means. It's one of those cliche's that sound deep but when you look at it actually has no meaning. It's not like the white ones hve been setting the bar very high.
Posted by SteveMG
01:48 AM, 04/25/2008
I just think a lot of people see through Obama's line of BS. America needs a president who is moderate, reasonable, pragmatic. I think we need the kind of fiscal responsibility we saw during the 1st Clinton administration, not an overzealous penchant for proposed government spending like Obama rallies about. I don't see Obama bringing on a new era of bipartisanship. Amazingly, at a time when moderate thinking wins the Democrats are on their way to nominating the most liberal member of the Senate. Duh? On another level we've seen Rev. Wright and not to mention his congregants, of which Barack Obama is one. We've seen him insult entire subcultures of people in the state of Pennsylvania and you still wonder where the antipathy comes from?
Posted by roadrunner
08:28 AM, 04/25/2008
I'm perplexed. How does losing in Montgomery County by just one and a half points show "weakness"? And how does a Harvard Law degree and experience teaching Constitutional law and being a state senator and U.S. Senator make anyone feel like Barack Obama is not qualified to be President? Does black skin have some bizarre effect on brain function that I'm not aware of? There are some individuals who are apparently "not ready for a black president," but let's not say "America" isn't ready. I think that when all the votes are counted, we'll see that America is solidly behind Sen. Obama -- and when he wins, America will see he does not have to be a white guy to do the job right.
Posted by fudgelady
12:53 PM, 04/25/2008
Still while all that may be true....and the realities of life harden our opinions the bottom line is the economy - Clinton may do well on the unspoken reality that under her husbands leadership the Clinton team for eight years had the economy crackling - the main problem with Bush is he did that for a hand pick chosen few (maybe ten people - including himself, his Dad, Cheney and Baker). The Clintons are more apt to spread the wealth. All the soaring speeches in the world can't hide the fact that Obama has some questionable ties (don't they all) plus an unproven track record. I bet it's Hillary and Edwards and that won't be such a bad ticket.
Posted by JourneyHome
02:55 PM, 04/25/2008
IS ANY ONE ELSE WONDERING WHY HILLARY HASN'T CALLED TO OFFER NUTTER THE VP???
Posted by MkeC
02:57 PM, 04/25/2008
ALL I AM SAYING IS LOYALTY THAT IS DESERVED IS LOYALTY THAT IS REWARDED.
Posted by MkeC
23 comments | View All Comments
About Daniel Rubin

Since joining The Inquirer as a staff writer in 1988, Daniel Rubin has reported from 27 countries, but most of them were small. He's been the European Correspondent for Knight Ridder Newspapers, based in Berlin, and a metro reporter and feature writer for the paper. He wrote the Inquirer's first daily blog, called Blinq. Dan began newspaper work in Norfolk and Louisville, Ky., after getting his undergraduate and graduate degrees from Northwestern University. He has lived in all four commonwealths, most recently in Pennsylvania, with his wife, twin teenage sons and a large, slobbering cowherd.

Visit Blinq 1.0 here.

Blog Roll
Local Interest
 
[ s h a l l o w c e n t e r ]
 
A List Of Things Thrown Five Minutes Ago
 
A Smoke-Filled Room
 
Afro-Netizen™
 
artblog
 
Attytood
 
Balls, Sticks and Stuff
 
Swing and A Miss
 
Blankbaby
 
blonde sagacity
 
Citizen Mom
 
Daily Sally
 
The BM Rant
 
How Appealing
 
iFlipFlop
 
philly
 
Philly Future
 
Tom Gralish's Photo Blog
 
The All Spin Zone
 
The700Level.com
 
slacktivist
 
Suburban Guerrilla
 
The Rittenhouse Review
 
Philebrity
 
Philadelphia Weather
 
Above Average Jane
 
Beerleaguer
 
Phillyist
 
Philadelphia Will Do
 
The Clog
 
This Urban Life
 
Changing Skyline
 
Books, Inq.
 
Philly Skyline
 
The Casual Critic
 
Philadelphia Restaurants
 
Skaroff Blog
 
The Long Cut
 
The Smedley Log
 
Young Philly Politics
 
Politics Philly
 
Philly Burbs Blogs
 
Mental Hopscotch
 
The Daily Jive
 
TheIlladelph
 
The Phanatic
 
Mere Cat
 
Starting A Landslide In My Ego
Poli Sci
 
Booman Tribune
 
My DD
 
skippy the bush kangaroo
 
Brad DeLong
 
pandagon
 
lgf the terrible infant speaks
 
The Daily Howler
 
War & Piece
 
Digby
 
Instapundit
 
Informed Comment
 
The Huffington Post The Front Page
 
Pajamas Media
 
Daily Kos
 
Power Line
 
Power Line
 
Eschaton
Foreign P.O.V.
 
signandsight
 
Der Spiegel Online
 
Guardian Unlimited Newsblog
 
Global Voices Online
 
Economist.com
 
BerlinBites
Media Mania
 
Daou Report
 
Blogspotting - BusinessWeek Online
 
CJR Daily Home
 
First Draft by Tim Porter
 
Hypergene MediaBlog
 
Online Journalism Review
 
Poynter Online - Romenesko
 
PressThink
 
Reflections of a Newsosaur
 
editorsweblog.org
One-stop
 
BuzzMachine... by Jeff Jarvis
 
DeepBlog
 
Joho the Blog
 
Technorati
 
The Command Post - A Newsblog Collective
Arts, Culture, Cheap Thrills
 
Some Velvet Blog
 
Stereogum
 
songsillinois
 
Said the Gramophone
 
Music (for robots)
 
Largehearted Boy
 
Wonkette
 
WFMU's Beware of the Blog
 
THE TOFU HUT
 
Spoilt Victorian Child
 
Blackmail Is My Life
 
Gawker
 
Fluxblog
 
Blogcritics.org
 
ArtsJournal Blog Central
 
Arts and Letters Daily
It's Technical
 
Slashdot News for nerds, stuff that matters
 
Gizmodo
 
Dynamist Blog
 
Boing Boing: A Directory of Wonderful Things
Categories
Archives
 
May
 
April
 
March