Idol Chatter Archive: April, 2008

Bye-bye, Brooke

Comment icon 0 Comments
OK, Brooke White is going home, and it's really sad. Not as sad as it would've been if we'd had to say goodbye to Syesha, who had too good... Read more

A kiss is just another opportunity to return to third grade

Comment icon 0 Comments
At least we can be sure that Paula knew that the first girl Simon ever kissed -- he was 9 -- was going to call into the show tonight, because... Read more

Three men and a babe?

Comment icon 0 Comments
The other David -- the one eerie Paula called "the next American Idol" -- is safe. (See? She is psychic!) Which means that the bottom... Read more

Seeing all, telling nothing

Comment icon 0 Comments
More than 45 million votes came in Tuesday night, Ryan tells us. But hey, Paula already knew that. And, yes, I'm going to belabor the point... Read more

THIS is 'American Idol'

Comment icon 0 Comments
If, like Paula, I belonged to the Psychic Judges Network, I could probably tell you now, before "American Idol" begins, which of... Read more

The Agony of Jason

Comment icon 0 Comments
You have to feel sorry for Jason Castro, don't you? The poor guy. Last week "Memories". This week "September Morn". How... Read more

Divide and Conquer

Comment icon 0 Comments
So let's get Paula Abdul's flub-a-dubs out of the way, first. Yes, we did hear her tell Jason Castro that she didn't like his first song... Read more

The Wind that Shakes out Carly

Comment icon 0 Comments
Thoroughly enjoyed Randy Jackson's explanation of why the would-be Idols had all sounded so measly and overwhelmed the night before: shows... Read more