Phew, now I disagree with Simon Cowell.

Comment icon 0 Comments
Was Cook's guitar hooked up? Don't matter, Dog, 'cause he was singing his face off. Redundant Randy can still be cool. Archie stunk up the... Read more

Oh no, I agreee with Simon Cowell

Comment icon 0 Comments
How can they never have been in the bottom three, if there are only two left? And is it wrestling or boxing? Isn't supposed to be singing? You... Read more

Idol and wrestling -- puhfect together

Comment icon 0 Comments
This kind of overblown self-importance, "the biggest showdown in show-biz history," is one of the main things that has been turning... Read more

The Suspense

Comment icon 0 Comments
Can anybody even stand it? Will 8 p.m. never come? Read more

Sayonara, Syesha

Comment icon 0 Comments
Unless you are a resident of Sarasota, you're probably neither surprised nor upset at last night's results: the dismissal of Syesha Mercado... Read more

The Idol Thunderdome

Comment icon 0 Comments
Let's talk merit for once, shall we? Who shone like Patti LuPone last night? I think the clear winner was David Cook, who nailed two out... Read more

Syesha's Swan Songs

Comment icon 0 Comments
I'm gonna miss you Syesha. Really. You came on slow and cute, girl (loved that earthy, natural hair do and demeanor to match) and chased... Read more

And Then There Were Three

Comment icon 0 Comments
Didn't they look great together last night, our final four? Singing "Reelin' in the Years" with that marching band choreography.... Read more