Ciao, Carly

Carly Smithson's also in the bottom two, while Jason Castro, who stank up the joint Tuesday, is safe. And after the break, we learn that it's Carly who's going home.


My own theory (beyond the suspicion that Jason's fan base might like his eyes more than his voice) is that there's a sizable portion of "Idol's" fan base that's never going to be comfortable with the lyrics of "Superstar" from "Jesus Christ Superstar."

Even if the singer covers her tattoos.