Flying away on a broken wing?

Carly Smithson in the bottom three.

So if Simon really was trying to help the ringer by telling her she'd picked the wrong song with "Blackbird," we can only assume he overdid it.

Posted by Ellen Gray @ 9:18 PM Permalink | Post a comment

Comments

0 comments

About Inquirer and Daily News
Entertainment Writers

Idol Chatter is a joint Inquirer and Daily News blog about American Idol, with analysis and gossip about what we liked -- and what we didn't -- from every show.

Our idol chatters include:

From the Daily News: Jon Takiff, Regina Medina, Dan Gross, Debi Licklider and Ellen Gray

From the Inquirer: David Hiltbrand, Jon Storm, Peter Mucha and Amy S. Rosenberg

Advertise Here

Get it now

Subscribe to the RSS feed

March 2009
March
January 2009
July 2008
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008