PhillyTablet Inquirer Daily News
philly.com
email
font size
comments
13
options
 
Tuesday, September 15, 2009

Mayor Nutter was not in Harrisburg yesterday or today, but he is busy lobbying for the city's budget relief package nonetheless.

The mayor sent a letter yesterday to every state senator, urging them to support the twin measures that would allow Philadelphia to generate an estimated $700 million.

Little action was expected in the upper chamber today, with Senate Majority Leader Domenic Pileggi saying he anticipated discussing the legislation with his colleagues during a caucus meeting tomorrow.  A copy of Nutter's letter is below.

September 14, 2009

Dear Senator:

I respectfully request your vote in support of HB 1828 without further amendment
and without further delay.

Since early June, I have been to the State Capitol nearly weekly seeking authorization
of three essential tools that would assist the City with its financial recovery in the wake of the
worldwide economic collapse. I have had the opportunity to meet with many of you to
explain our circumstances, and to detail our own actions to address the issue while discussing
the tools we need from the General Assembly.

On behalf of the City, I have consistently asked for State approval to: (1) defer a
portion of our pension payments for FY10 and FY11; (2) change our pension amortization
period; and, (3) impose a five-year temporary 1% increase in the local sales tax to pay for
pension obligations, including repayment of the deferrals with interest.

HB 1828 contains these provisions. These provisions were in the bill as passed by
the House on August 5th and as passed by the Senate on August 26th. And, they remain in the
bill which was yet again passed by the House and returned to the Senate on Friday,
September 11th. Thus, both chambers have actually agreed to these provisions, and while I
fully understand the legislative process and prerogative of both chambers to add
amendments, the citizens of Philadelphia cannot afford any further delay.

As I have explained, the global economic crisis hit state and local governments hard.
And, since Philadelphia must have a balanced five-year financial plan we were faced with a
$2.4 billion hole. Working on our own, we have fixed $1.7 billion by implementing a variety
of efficiencies and cuts, making major reductions in the workforce, stopping scheduled wage
and business tax cuts, and increasing fees and fines.

We came to the State truly as a last resort seeking a helping hand. Mindful of your
own budget issues, the legislation we seek has absolutely no fiscal impact on the
Commonwealth. It does not cost you one dime. But inaction and further delay will have a
costly impact.

We have to balance a five-year financial plan because our finances are subject to review by
PICA, a state agency that ensures that we don’t use any gimmicks to keep our fiscal house in
order. Under the legislation that created PICA, we are required each year to get approval for
a Plan that shows that we have a balanced budget not just for one year, but for each of five
years. In a vote last Friday, PICA made clear that unless HB1828 is passed by September
18th, we will have to demonstrate how we will maintain a balanced five-year Plan without
the sales tax and pension changes. Unfortunately, the only way to keep the Plan balanced
would be to make devastating cuts to our budget.

The additional workforce and service reductions we will need to make without
passage of HB 1828 will be felt beyond the boundaries of the City. Philadelphia is not an
island, but is integral to the economic health and vitality of the Southeast region and the
Commonwealth.

If HB 1828 does not pass, we will need to find another $700 million to insure a
balanced budget and plan. This means the elimination of 1000 police and 200 fire positions,
reducing trash collection from weekly to twice a month, ceasing operations at two City health
centers, and shuttering entire service departments, including Parks, Recreation, Libraries,
Planning and Commerce. In total, more than 3000 positions will be cut.

Given the magnitude of these cuts and the civil service procedures we must follow to
effectuate layoffs, we initiated implementation on September 10. Citizens and stakeholder
groups have been notified that all recreation centers and libraries will close. Notices were
given of the change in trash collection. And scores have been calculated to prepare for the
thousands of layoff notices that will be sent out on September 18.

These are actions none of us want to take. And, it is unfortunate that they had to be
initiated. But, the simple fact is that the City cannot spend money it does not have.
And throughout this fiscal crisis, we have had to act responsibly and prepare for the worst
while hoping for the best.

I know that you understand the importance of this bill to the City and to the
Commonwealth. And, I remain hopeful that you will approve HB 1828 without further
amendments and without any further delay.

During my numerous visits to the Capitol advocating for HB 1828, I have had the
opportunity to meet many of you. I have learned a lot in a short period of time about the
General Assembly and the importance of developing relationships, sharing information and
forging common ground. For too long, the State and the City have had been reluctant
partners, instead of true partners. I look forward to continuing to work together in a true spirit
of partnership.

Please, I ask for your support of HB 1828.
Sincerely,
Michael A. Nutter
Mayor

Click here for Philly.com's politics page.

Posted by Marcia Gelbart @ 3:29 PM  Permalink | 13 comments
Comments   
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 3:50 PM, 09/15/2009
    It does make one wonder that only if our dear mayor would have continued his efforts at gaining the efficiencies that contributed to the $1.7 billion in-house reduction whether we would still need to plug a $700million dollar hole. Or as CleanupPhilly has pointed out numerously, collected all of the money that is legitimately owed to Philadelphia. Also, what about all of the union contracts that need to be renegotiated and finalized. The 5-year plan submitted to PICA could not possibly include any concessions that are sure to come out of the current labor negotiations. At any rate, as much as we can all appreciate the apparent stick-to-it-iveness that the mayor can be seen exhibiting, the citizenry would have been better served by a little multi-tasking on the mayor's part.
    bizzarrophilly
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 4:05 PM, 09/15/2009
    "Mikey one term" needs to have people in Harrisburg doing this work while he is here running the City! Congratulations to Karen Heller for having the courage to stand up and tell it like it is on Saturday in her article. Hopefully the other reporters in this city and the Editorial Boards will do the same.
    Union Jack
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 5:21 PM, 09/15/2009
    Nutter cut 12 positions, most were unfilled, so far. That is not a "major reduction in the workforce." He's done some dinky things but still carries a huge, bloated patronage machine. This letter is disingenuous.
    CleanupPhilly
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 5:25 PM, 09/15/2009
    One Dem blogger posted that a lot of the property that owes property taxes to the city belongs to "nonprofits." But not every nonprofit is simply allowed to not pay property taxes. The RDA has property that has zeroed out from paying property taxes, and this is corrupt, because this is property that is held by the RDA, and whoever takes the property should take responsibility for the accumulation of tax debt because of delay in development. There is a real cost to the city and schools that these nonprofits, the RDA, and the city hold all this property out of the tax paying base. It's time to show common sense in this, and stop trying to reward "nonprofits" who give money to the party with noncollection of property taxes, or nonassessment, or low assessments as a quid pro quo. It is illegal. Someone will end up going to jail. End this abuse before the FBI serves you.
    CleanupPhilly
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 5:30 PM, 09/15/2009
    The city doesn't have to cut life/limb/sanitation as a first order of business. It just doesn't that is another aspect of this letter that rings hollow, in addition to the humorous assertion that PICA doesn't let the city let the city get away with "any gimmicks." I laughed. The last was a gimmick, a poison pill that PICA could not accept because it was unworkable, full of deliberate flaws and PICA let the city get away with it by passing Plan B instead, and penciling in their own changes to the dates and so forth. This is a sideshow of gimmicks, this whole fiscal year has been a circus of delays and obfuscation as other cities, counties, and states, did the hard work and political heavy lifting of cut, reassessments, and collections. Philly has run out of time and has to start on honest process like the state itself.
    CleanupPhilly
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 5:35 PM, 09/15/2009
    Even Ben Waxman, a very sympathetic Democrat, wrote that Plan C as submitted at the end of August was "a charade," based on the letter that Butkovitz wrote reminding PICA that the budget was too flawed to be considered real. This is so Philly can look as destitute as possible for the state, and it's a sad bit of political prostitution. This is Nutter's best gambit, a page from the play book of Street, without the effective property tax collection. Nutter and Council must try to make these cuts, collections, and reassessments that they should have done all last year. It really is that new day, that new way. Nutter can't rely on the sales tax hike money.
    CleanupPhilly
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 5:37 PM, 09/15/2009
    Let Nutter and Rendell lay off 3000 city workers, raise the sales tax to 8%, and legalize gambling to finance the corrupt city. Maybe the voters will begin to see how bad things really are under Democrat control.
    Liam I am
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 6:55 PM, 09/15/2009
    Philadelphia for sale: Shove casinos down our throats, but close Libraries? What else is left for us? I'd like all the Politicians to climb out of their ivory towers and start taking the losses that the common man has had to take. Start living simpler, without, like the rest of us. Are you struggling to put food on your table? Are you having trouble making your car payment? Of course not the taxpayers are paying for your car! Are you having trouble paying your monthly household bills? Save the state budget and take a pay cut yourself, don't close our Free Libraries! You can do without for a little while. If we have been forced to change our daily lives from this financial problem, you should be forced to make some changes too. Leave our libraries alone, when was the last time _you_ used one? Philadelphia Libraries close, but the city and state tax dollars paid the bill on the new baseball and football stadiums? You say you have no money now, maybe you should second guess the 10 year tax abatements you handed out to big developers. There's your money! How much money in tax breaks did Comcast get for building their new building? They get richer, while we lose our books and gain more high definition channels! It's all about priorities ladies and gentlemen. Philadelphia Libraries close, but we get a "bigger and better" convention center? There's your money! Philadelphia Libraries close, but the football team still plays? It's all about priorities ladies and gentlemen. In 5 years you will be crying that people moved out of the city the there's no tax base. Blame yourselves, do your job better than you are doing now. I'd fire you if I could!
    agentrem
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 8:08 PM, 09/15/2009
    I dont know, when I was waiting in the MSB to get a permit, they were delivering a brand new 60" plasma tv to one of the departments down there for all the new renovations going in the concourse. Beats me, looks like things are going along alright....
    uandwhosearmy
  • Comment removed.
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 7:41 AM, 09/16/2009
    larlib - LET ME GUESS, A WORKER ON THE PUBLIC TEAT?
    Kaiser Sosa
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 9:32 AM, 09/16/2009
    Larlib, Philly is my love and my hobby, and I'm not going anywhere. Don't blame me if you lose your job. The Mayor had all year to do one thing to get the city in position where it won't have to cut your city job, and both he and City Council refused to do ONE thing on that list. Imagine having a to-do list of 20 critical items you must do, and going ALL DAY and not doing one. Now imagine doing that all year. He didn't do AVI, change the millage, take the BRT out of the Philly School District where it would have allowed the PSD to be a better candidate for Rendell's PIT legislation that got shot down and caused Rendell to be termed a "lame duck" for the first time. Nutter and Council didn't collect the overdue property taxes of $425 million or the $1 billion in forfeit bail owed the city by fixing patronage row offices, or arrange to contract out that work to competent apolitical municipal service providers as even rural counties do, no problem. There's still all this property laying fallow that should be paying property taxes but isn't in the city, the RDA, PHA, PAID/PIDC, that those agencies essentially admit is not in the active pipeline, yet there's no mandate to sell it on the open market to cause an increase in property tax revenue. There's no move to accept the mayor's own tax recommendations to move from a wage tax based system to a property tax based system as NYC did. There has only been stasis on revenue issues, (and a cell phone ban). The revenue fixes were passed over. Now Nutter MUST cut your job. Don't blame me. I called this a year ago.
    CleanupPhilly
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 9:35 AM, 09/16/2009
    If larlib is a city employee, s/he will need to get a job here shortly, no offense. Don't kill the messenger. I tried to save jobs by urging action a year ago to circumvent the need for the most drastic cuts. Nutter and Council's response? But Obama will save us, Rendell will save us, Jesus and Mohammad will save us, and then when all else fails there's Brady. How's that working for ya?
    CleanupPhilly


13 comments
About Inquirer City Hall Staff
The Philadelphia Inquirer's Miriam Hill, Troy Graham, and Bob Warner take you inside Philadelphia's City Hall.