Tuesday, December 1, 2015

Destroying the village to save it

The actions of this apparently fervent environmentalist constitute a PR black eye for those who share even the smallest slice of his ideology, and you can be sure anti-environmentlsts are even now readying screeds on how this extremism must be built into our worldview.

Destroying the village to save it

Police block the street in front of the headquarters of the Discovery Channel.  (AP Photo/Jose Luis Magana)
Police block the street in front of the headquarters of the Discovery Channel. (AP Photo/Jose Luis Magana) AP

The hostage situation at the Discovery Channel is ongoing, and we can only hope it will end peacefully. But the "environmental" manifesto posted by the alleged gunman doesn't point to compromise, or, frankly, lucidity.

James Lee's savetheplanetprotest.com (the site is unavailable right now, likely due to the crush of attention it just got) showcased his manifesto, which is difficult to summarize but the gist of it is that as humans are destroying the planet, humanity itself must be stopped.

The problem for environmentalists is that, well, yeah, humans are pretty much destroying the planet. So part of the premise is right. But the rest of this whole incident illustrates how any kind of activism can go awry when the activist feels justified in adopting a "any means necessary" approach.

Not only does it not follow from that premise that humanity itself need be stopped (e.g. if humans somehow stopped destroying the planet the premise would be obviated), but even if one thought that did follow, going into the Discovery Channel with a gun and explosives is doomed to be counter-productive to achieve that goal.

Why discuss this insane situation so sanely? Because whatever happens, the actions of this gunman, apparently a very fervent environmentalist, constitute a PR black eye for those who share even the smallest slice of his ideology, and you can be sure anti-environmentlsts are even now readying screeds on how this extremism must be built into our worldview. (Case in point: As I was typing this, Drudge was spotlighting a phrase in an MSNBC article about how Lee had been 'awakened' by Al Gore's 'Inconvenient Truth.' Still waiting for first 'unabomber' mention.) 

Already Daniel Quinn, author of "Ishmael," has been dragged into the reporting because the first sentence of Lee's manifesto name-checks him as inspiration. Even though Quinn points out that "environmentalism" implies that humans and their concerns are separate from the world at large and thus rejects the term, he will likely be called to comment on a viewpoint that is in some ways diametrically opposed: That humans are not only separate but are a "filthy" "parasite" that must be eradicated in order for the environment to thrive.

This is the twisted logic, and the very real power, of force as a rhetorical device: While it's usually terrible at achieving the very ends to which it's being employed, force, or "power-over," is good at generating chaos and knocking down other, competing goals. It's a dynamic Marilyn French explained at great length in Beyond Power, a book anyone who is interested in challenging the status quo should read - and yes, I'm looking at you, ELF, ALF, SHAC and anyone else who thinks arson or death threats in the name of 'greater good' makes sense.

We'll have more on this later, but the lesson already is that no matter how "pure" our planet-saving goals, creative solutions cannot be generated at the end of a gun barrel. There simply is no war to end all wars.

UPDATE 5:14: Today's crisis is apparently over, with the gunman shot by police, hostages released.

We encourage respectful comments but reserve the right to delete anything that doesn't contribute to an engaging dialogue.
Help us moderate this thread by flagging comments that violate our guidelines.

Comment policy:

Philly.com comments are intended to be civil, friendly conversations. Please treat other participants with respect and in a way that you would want to be treated. You are responsible for what you say. And please, stay on topic. If you see an objectionable post, please report it to us using the "Report Abuse" option.

Please note that comments are monitored by Philly.com staff. We reserve the right at all times to remove any information or materials that are unlawful, threatening, abusive, libelous, defamatory, obscene, vulgar, pornographic, profane, indecent or otherwise objectionable. Personal attacks, especially on other participants, are not permitted. We reserve the right to permanently block any user who violates these terms and conditions.

Additionally comments that are long, have multiple paragraph breaks, include code, or include hyperlinks may not be posted.

Read 0 comments
comments powered by Disqus
About this blog
Earth to Philly is a weblog focusing on earth-conscious technology, trends and ideas, from a Daily News perspective. We look at the "green" aspects of your home, business, food, transportation, style, policy, gadgets and artwork. If you have a Philly-related story, Click here to let us know about it!

The experts at Philadelphia's Energy Coordinating Agency answer your energy questions in our regular feature Stay Warm, Stay Green. Send in your question or questions to energy@phillynews.com.

Look for Jenice Armstrong to supply tips on green living as well as occasional columns on the subject of Green. She also blogs at Hey Jen.

Becky Batcha stays tuned for the here-and-now practical side of conservation, alternative energy, organic foods, etc. - stuff you can do at home now. Plus odds and ends.

Laurie Conrad recycles from her ever-growing e-mailbag to pass along the latest travel deals, fashion statements, household strategies, gadgets, cool local events and other nuggets of interest to those who appreciate a clean, green world.

Vance Lehmkuhl looks at topics like eco-conscious eating, public transportation and fuel-efficient driving from his perspective as a vegetarian, a daily SEPTA bus rider and a hybrid driver, as well as noting the occasional wacky trend or product. Contact Vance with your 'green' news.

Ronnie Polaneczky sees the green movement through the eyes of her 12-year-old daughter, who calls her on every scrap of paper or glass bottle that Ronnie neglects to toss into the house recycling bins. Ronnie will blog about new or unexpected ways to go green. She also blogs at So, What Happened Was...

Sandra Shea and the DN editorial board opine on any green-related legislation or policy. And we'll pass along some of the opeds on the subject that people send us.

Jonathan Takiff will be blogging mainly about consumer electronics - those things that we love to use and that suck too much energy. He'll spotlight green-conscious gizmos made in a responsible fashion, both in terms of materials used and the energy it takes to run them.

Signe Wilkinson draws the comic strip Family Tree, which follows the Tree family as they try to live green in the face of nattering neighbors, plastic-wrapped consumer products, and the primal teenage urge to spend vast quantities of money on hair care products of dubious organic quality.

In addition to these updates from our newsroom bloggers, watch for an occasional feature, Dumpster Diver Dispatches, from Philadelphia's original "green" community of artists, the Dumpster Divers. You'll learn about creative ways to reuse and recycle while you reduce, and about the artists who are making little masterpieces from what others throw out.

  • Dispatch #1: Margaret Giancola's rugs from plastic bags
  • Dispatch #2: Dumpster Divers in City Hall (Art in City Hall series)
  • Dispatch #3: Wild wood, New Jersey
  • Dispatch #4: Dumpster Divers award winners announced
  • Dispatch #5: From sweaters to colorful cuddling
  • Dispatch #6: Green artists retake South Street Sunday
  • Dispatch #7: Isaiah Zagar: He's a Magic (Gardens) Man

    Earth to Philly
  • Latest Health Videos
    Also on Philly.com:
    letter icon Newsletter