share
email
font size
options
 
Monday, September 14, 2009

Was signing Jeff Garcia a good move for the Eagles?
Yes
No

The Eagles will sign quarterback Jeff Garcia to a one-year contract, a league source confirmed to the Daily News, and the Eagles later announced.

"Adding Jeff Garcia to the roster is a great idea," injured quarterback Donovan McNabb said in a statement posted tonight on his blog at yardbarker.com. "He knows our offense and how we do things around here. He's a great teammate, and I look forward to working with him again."

The Birds had been expected to try to bring back A.J. Feeley, and they apparently tried to do so, but Feeley flew to Charlotte this evening and said he will sign with the Panthers on Tuesday. Carolina IR'd QB Josh McCown, who suffered a foot injury in the Eagles' 38-10 season-opening win.

"Hard to say goodbye, but yeah, it was a better opportunity," Feeley told the Daily News in a text message.

Eagles coach Andy Reid confirmed the move on his radio show on WIP.

"Jeff's going to come on board with us for who knows how long here," Reid said. "We're lucky that Jeff was available. Someone who knows the offense, has been very, very successful in the offense, and can come in and also be a positive influence for Kevin Kolb and everyone else in the locker room."

"It's a unique situation because Michael (Vick) is suspended for a week and Donovan's banged up. So we don't know how long Donovan's going to be and at the same time we need a second quarterback in there if needed this weekend."

Garcia helped lead the Eagles to the playoffs in 2006 after McNabb’s season ended with an injury. In the process, he became the story of that NFL season and was adored by Eagles fans, including having the team's best-selling jersey.

Garcia started six games for the Birds, going 5-1, in the regular season. The Eagles were eventually knocked out of the playoffs by New Orleans.

Since leaving the Eagles, Garcia, 39, spent the last two seasons with Tampa Bay and then spent training camp this summer with Oakland before he was released.

“I am excited to come back to organization, not excited to come back due to Donovan’s injury," Garcia said in a conference call with reporters. "But I am looking forward to contributing any way I can, whether it’s for a week or two weeks or the entire season.”

A source close to Garcia said the QB's comfort level with the Eagles' system and coaching staff made this an attractive opportunity, even if it is just for the short term. Of course, if Garcia gets on the field and does well, he could play himself into the Eagles' crowded quarterback picture somehow, or, more likely, become more attractive to another team that might need a quarterback, when McNabb returns from a rib fracture.

“I guess when I saw Donovan go down yesterday, the thought crossed my mind that it might be a possibility," Garcia said. "It’s funny, I was on my way to Los Angeles to do pregame stuff for Monday Night Football when my agent told me the Eagles were interested in signing me. I had my driver turn me around.”

The signing was initially reported by ESPN.com.

 Earlier in the day, coach Andy Reid said if McNabb cannot play, then Kevin Kolb would be the starter.

Reid also said he was looking into other options for the second quarterback spot. To add Garcia to the roster, the Eagles will have to cut someone, but that won't happen until he actually signs.

Garcia was signed by the Raiders in the offseason to a 1-year deal, presumably to help mentor JaMacus Russell. He then missed the first two weeks of training camp with a left calf injury and did not play in the first preseason game.

He played sparingly in the preseason, including going 3-for-6 for 12 yards in the finale. He was then released Sept. 5 when teams cut their rosters to 53.

After the Raiders' preseason finale, Garcia seemed uncertain about whether he would remain with the team.
"I haven't played a whole lot in the preseason, so I don't think there's ever really a comfortable feeling, especially when there are so many problems to be fixed it seems," Garcia told reporters, according to ESPN.com. "All I can do is give everything I have to give and try to better myself every day and try along the way help my teammates better themselves. That's all I can ask of myself right now."

*

To read our report on Donovan McNabb's injury, click here.

To read our report about the NFL's determination about the hit on McNabb, click here.

 

 

 

Posted by Daily News staff @ 5:13 PM  Permalink | 115 comments
115
Comments   
Posted 05:19 PM, 09/14/2009
Bubba
I read where he is a disruptive force because he doesn't like being a backup. Does this mean if McNabb cant go Sunday he's starts?
Posted 05:20 PM, 09/14/2009
reddog027
is garcia the best? boy he's better than kevin kolb
Posted 05:20 PM, 09/14/2009
scotty_one
I wonder who they had to release to sign him and how long he was signed for?
Posted 05:21 PM, 09/14/2009
The Red Robot
I hope they release that bonehead Demps.
Posted 05:21 PM, 09/14/2009
spz74
Well, this was a no-brainer...Other than Feely, who else was available?
Posted 05:21 PM, 09/14/2009
Cadiz215
OMG! Wow McNabb, Vick and now Garcia....this is gonna be interesting and crazy!
Posted 05:27 PM, 09/14/2009
djax10
garcia will be in by the 2nd quarter, kolb is flat out depressing
Posted 05:28 PM, 09/14/2009
tornadoh
So now what happens when Kolb sucks out loud and gets yanked for Garcia, who lights it up and leads the Iggles to a win? Can Andy keep insisting he has faith and confidence in Kolb and he is the No. 2 QB if that happens?
Posted 05:29 PM, 09/14/2009
frankludlow
The Eagles got what they deserved. They did AJ wrong, and its gonna come back to haunt them. They gambled by cut Feeley, the only other QB who can play and win in the system, and lost. The front office must be kicking themselves right now. Expect another terrible showing from Kolb this week, and some strange chemistry from Vick-McNabb-Garcia for weeks to come. You went from the most exciting team, to the most desperate and awkward in the league, virtually overnight.
Posted 05:30 PM, 09/14/2009
shnuggleshnee
i got to hand it to them...they really want to win the superbowl this year....this type of action and philosophy would have brought us success much sooner. Oh well, im sure they warranted to believe James Thrash, Pinky, Freddie Mitchel, etc etc etc, were enough to win a superbowl
Posted 05:30 PM, 09/14/2009
Dr. Michael
The Curse of Michael Vick continues...AJ Feeley spurns re-signing with the Phila Dog Killers because he knows father of the year Andy Reid has 4 qbs on the roster now who cant play like the last days of Jon Gruden.
Posted 05:33 PM, 09/14/2009
denny99
The signing of Garcia convinces me that the Eagles have pretty much given up on Kolb. They obviously don't feel he is ready to step in, even for one week. You'd think that Andy Reid would have prepared better, but then we're talking about Andy Reid, a genius if he's any judge.
Posted 05:36 PM, 09/14/2009
Richard Saunders
AHHHHH!!!!!! THIS IS GREAT!!!!!!
Posted 05:37 PM, 09/14/2009
The Red Robot
With Heather Mitts now gone, the void has been filled by Carmella DeCesare. Upgrade.
Posted 05:38 PM, 09/14/2009
dctwmt
Are they throwing potential backups against the wall to see which one sticks?
About Eagletarian Blog
Les BowenLes Bowen has covered the Eagles for the Daily News since 2002. Before that, he spent nearly 13 years covering the Flyers. It took Les only a few seasons after the switch to figure out that there was no penalty box at the Linc, and that the time really wasn't his, despite what Andy Reid kept saying. Les came to Philadelphia and the Daily News from Charlotte in 1983. In the intervening years, he has pretty much lost track of NASCAR, and his accent. He, his wife Barbara, and their two sons live in Haddon Township, New Jersey.

You can now follow Les Bowen on Twitter.

Paul DomowitchPaul Domowitch has been with the Daily News since 1982. He has spent most of his 27 years at the paper covering the Eagles and pro football. For the last 10 years, he’s been a selector for the Pro Football Hall of Fame. A native of Wilkes-Barre and a graduate of Wilkes University, Domo came to the Daily News from the Fort Worth (Tx.) Star-Telegram, where he covered some god-awful Texas Ranger baseball teams. His first beat at the Daily News actually wa s boxing, which he covered just long enough to lose two sports coats to blood spatter before moving on to football. Domo and his wife Shelley, a University of Oklahoma grad and very dangerous to be around following a Sooner loss, have been married 29 years and have raised 2 terrific daughters – Allison, 26, a lawyer and graduate of Boston University School of Law; and Amy, 23, who graduated from Clemson and works in marketing and sales for a professional baseball team.