share
email
font size
options
 
Tuesday, March 17, 2009

Before the fan base gets too fired up about the (as far as I can tell) nonexistent possibility of trading Donovan McNabb for Jay Cutler, here's a good take on Cutler from CBSsportsline's Clark Judge, a guy whose opinion I respect a lot.

I will add this: People who think Donovan's too much the diva want to replace him with a guy who is trying to get himself traded because his new coach might have considered exchanging him for a quarterback the new coach has more history with. The new coach has twice tried to smooth over the problem and reassure the guy, but the guy won't listen.

Hmm. Yeah, that makes sense.

*

This just in -- according to Pro Football Talk and, apparently, a Baltimore radio station, L.J. Smith has signed a one-year, $1.5 million contract with the Ravens.

Well, at least L.J. has escaped exile to Detroit, which seemed his fate when Atlanta pulled out of the bidding yesterday. But wow. One year, $1.5 million? That's about a third of what the Eagles franchised him for in 2008. And Baltimore has a good tight end, Todd Heap, who makes way more than that. So L.J. is going to back up Todd Heap for a year, and somehow hope that provides a better platform for free agency than his injury-riddled, 37-catch 2008 season.

This only works for L.J. if Heap gets hurt. It's hard to remember a guy with more potential falling farther, faster. The L.J. Smith who was taking over the position from Chad Lewis the year after the Eagles went to the Super Bowl seemed to have years of stardom in his future.

Injuries, inconsistency and missing a few key blocks will do that for you. I think teams are very leery of guys who ought to be better than they are. In the end, they're often more comfortable with guys who might have less talent, but use every bit they have.

*

Outside linebacker Angelo Crowell met with the Buffalo Bills about returning, the Buffalo News reported.

The Eagles have expressed interest in Crowell, agent Todd France told the Daily News on Friday, although France said Crowell was keeping his options open.

Crowell visited Tampa Bay and Detroit last week and has reportedly had preliminary contract discussions with the Bucs.

The Eagles would seemingly be a potentially odd fit for Crowell, given their young group of starting linebackers, all of whom they drafted, plus Omar Gaither, another homegrown player. The Eagles also have second-year man Joe Mays and special-teams ace Tank Daniels, whom they just re-signed.

*

Another pretty astute NFL observer, SI.com's Don Banks, has a new mock draft up. Chillingly for Birds fans who think maybe their team needs to trade up from 21st  and 28th overall to get one of the top OTs, Judge has Baylor's Jason Smith and Virginia's Eugene Monroe going 1-2. It's going to be pretty hard to trade into the top 2. Judge even has the red-flag guy who bolted the combine, Alabama OT Andre Smith, going 13th overall. But Judge has the Eagles getting an OT, UConn's William Beatty, with that 28 pick, after netting Georgia RB Knowshon Moreno (I'm all for that) at 21.

William BeattyWilliam Beatty? I've mostly seen him as a second-round guy, but mock drafts tend to undervalue offensive tackles. Don't know much about him, other than that obviously, he blocked for the running back, Donald Brown, who has drawn the Birds' interest. Otherwise, he might as well be Zelmo Beaty to me. (Everyone reading this who's under 50 is puzzling over that. Sorry.)Zelmo Beaty

*

In other news from around the league, Brian Dawkins missed the start of offseason workouts with his new team, the Denver Broncos, because he was in Hawaii at the NFL Players Association meetings. He is expected back later in the week, the Denver Post reported.

 *

Posted by Les Bowen and Daily News staff @ 10:14 AM  Permalink | 86 comments
86
Comments   
Posted 12:04 PM, 03/17/2009
Chuckle Berry
Gotta love a Zelmo Beaty reference. He earned NBA All Rookie Team the first time they had that in 1963. NBA/ABA career. I believe he retired and coached for the ABA in Virginia. Hey is the LJ Smith story amazing or what? No prospects at all. Sad.
Posted 12:21 PM, 03/17/2009
gordy
Chuck, the truly sad part about L.J. is that we franchised him last year and paid him in the top 5 T.E.'s in the league for a guy who can't even get signed by anyone else. That's how sad the F.O. is
Posted 12:22 PM, 03/17/2009
joeb
LJ Smith.... amazing? sad? I find it more amazing + sad that the eagles used a second round pick AND a franchise tag on the guy.
Comment removed.
Posted 12:36 PM, 03/17/2009
Mark1npt
The FO seems to have quite a track record of mis-reading guyslike LJ, Fredex, McCoy and the list goes on......yes sad, they ever brought him back last year and the tag to boot......then Celek breaks the TE single game receiving record and fat Andy says "the D obviously didn't prepare the same for Celek as they would have for LJ".....right.......what a waste of talent....just another guy that looks good in a uni......tard.
Comment removed.
Posted 12:39 PM, 03/17/2009
Mark1npt
5isapuker, choker, clockmismanager, momentumkiller, snapfumbler, overrated future HOF quarterbacker.....
Posted 12:43 PM, 03/17/2009
tpizza
Cutler is showing an amazing lack of maturity and is acting like a petulant child who needs a good spanking [OK, a time out for you PC folks]. He may have a good arm but he's got a below .500 lifetime record and couldn't win 1 game in 3 to get his team into the playoffs. On the surface he seems to have a very thin skin and may be more trouble than he's worth. He'd never survive in Philly.
Posted 12:50 PM, 03/17/2009
Voytas
5isaKing......I wouldn't quite call a choker a future HOF'er, but I would agree that we would be exchanging one whiner with another. At least we would have a new whiner in town versus the one we've had to hear for the last 10 years.
Posted 01:05 PM, 03/17/2009
mongoS
Cutler had more ints then TDs in one of the biggest collapses in NFL history. He is a whining baby who has not even won a playoff game to validate any passing yardage. A healthy Mcnab wins and outperforms this guy without help. Yet his personality fits exactly what Philly needs. A whining baby for whining fans. I say make it happen!
Posted 01:10 PM, 03/17/2009
smiggs13
Why are eagles fans getting so worked up about this, its never going to happen, the eagles arent going to trade mcnabb and draft picks for cutler and admit they made a mistake by drafting kolb, eagles fans are sounding like met fans these days when it comes to personel moves, everytime a big name player is rumored to be available eagles fans want the eagles to go after him and when it doesn't happen theyre in shock, if the broncos trade cutler there going to trade him to a team with a glaring hole at qb like the lions or bucs, not a team with 2 guys who the coaching staff views as starter material. Don't aggravate yourself and waste your time pleading for this to get done, the eagles will never do this deal
Posted 01:12 PM, 03/17/2009
palmyra21
lonewolf, you're an idiot. McNabb won 2 playoff games since the Super Bowl. How many did Cutler win? Seriously and Cutler couldn't win his division last year, a division with the Raiders and Chiefs.
Posted 01:27 PM, 03/17/2009
Gary Varsho
The Broncos collapse last year had nothing to do with Cutler, their defense was awful and they were on something like their 50th running back by the end of the season due to injuries. All else being equal, I would take the upside and youth of Cutler over McNabb. 5isaKing - first off, its "might as well" and to compare Cutler to Kolb is ridiculous. One is a pro bowler who threw for over 4,000 yards last year, and one is a stiff.
Posted 01:30 PM, 03/17/2009
rascal b. schuylkillian
Trade McNabb straight up for Scott Bakula of "Necessary Roughness" fame.
Comment removed.
About Eagletarian Blog
Les BowenLes Bowen has covered the Eagles for the Daily News since 2002. Before that, he spent nearly 13 years covering the Flyers. It took Les only a few seasons after the switch to figure out that there was no penalty box at the Linc, and that the time really wasn't his, despite what Andy Reid kept saying. Les came to Philadelphia and the Daily News from Charlotte in 1983. In the intervening years, he has pretty much lost track of NASCAR, and his accent. He, his wife Barbara, and their two sons live in Haddon Township, New Jersey.

You can now follow Les Bowen on Twitter.

Paul DomowitchPaul Domowitch has been with the Daily News since 1982. He has spent most of his 27 years at the paper covering the Eagles and pro football. For the last 10 years, he’s been a selector for the Pro Football Hall of Fame. A native of Wilkes-Barre and a graduate of Wilkes University, Domo came to the Daily News from the Fort Worth (Tx.) Star-Telegram, where he covered some god-awful Texas Ranger baseball teams. His first beat at the Daily News actually wa s boxing, which he covered just long enough to lose two sports coats to blood spatter before moving on to football. Domo and his wife Shelley, a University of Oklahoma grad and very dangerous to be around following a Sooner loss, have been married 29 years and have raised 2 terrific daughters – Allison, 26, a lawyer and graduate of Boston University School of Law; and Amy, 23, who graduated from Clemson and works in marketing and sales for a professional baseball team.