Tuesday, July 22, 2014
Inquirer Daily News

State Supreme Court Tells City Council: Let Them Speak

Philadelphia City Council meetings may soon get a little more interesting. The state Supreme Court, in a 4-3 ruling made public today, says Council has been violating the state's Sunshine Act by refusing to allow people to comment on legislation during Council sessions. Council argued that its current procedure -- to allow people to comment on legislation when it came up in committee hearings before moving on for consideration by the full Council -- was adequate.

State Supreme Court Tells City Council: Let Them Speak

Philadelphia City Council meetings may soon get a little more interesting. The state Supreme Court, in a 4-3 ruling made public today, says Council has been violating the state's Sunshine Act by refusing to allow people to comment on legislation during Council sessions.  Council argued that its current procedure -- to allow people to comment on legislation when it came up in committee hearings before moving on for consideration by the full Council -- was adequate.

The Homeowner's Association of Philadelphia challenged Council's practice in 2007, amid concerns about legislation that eventually became law requiring property owners to list their city license numbers in advertisements for rentals.  A Common Pleas Court judge ruled against the Homeowner's Association, a decision later upheld by the state Commonwealth Court.

In the majority opinion, Justice Thomas Saylor said the Sunshine Act does not give Council the power to assign public comment to some other sort of meeting.  Chief Justice Ron Castille, writing the dissenting opinion, worried that the ruling would cause "disruption" in Council practices in use for more than 50 years.

“This will have a significant impact for all meetings in the future, way beyond our specific case," said Darrell Zaslow, attorney for the Homeowner's Association. "We look forward to participating with Council effectively and respectfully. We’re sure all citizens will be appropriate with their conduct before Council.”

UPDATE, 4:50 pm:  City Council President Anna Verna just responded to the ruling with this statement: "We are disappointed that only three members of the Court agreed with our position that Philadelphia’s Charter-mandated practice of providing ample opportunity for public comment during the numerous public hearings held by Council committees throughout the year satisfied the “public comment” requirement. Of course, Council will comply with all final decisions of the Pennsylvania Supreme Court and with all statutory requirements, and if that means changing our procedures to provide a public comment period during Council sessions, we will do so."

About this blog
Chris Brennan, a native Philadelphian and graduate of Temple University, joined the Daily News in 1999. He has written about SEPTA, the Philadelphia School District, the legalization of casino gambling, state government, the mayor, the governor, City Council and political campaigns. E-mail tips to brennac@phillynews.com
 Follow Chris on Twitter

Jenny DeHuff is a 2005 graduate of the University of Rhode Island, where she cut her teeth in journalism. A South Philly transplant from New England, she joined the Daily News City Hall Bureau in 2013. For the past several years, she has worked as an investigative reporter exposing corruption in suburban politics, covering sometimes ghastly criminal court cases and following the people’s money and how its spent. In addition to being a dogged news hound, she enjoys reading and writing about travel, animals, Irish whiskey and aviation. E-mail tips to dehuffj@phillynews.com
 Follow Jenny on Twitter.

Sean Collins Walsh is from Bucks County and went to Northwestern University. He joined the Daily News copy desk in 2012 and now covers the Nutter administration. Before that, he interned at papers including The New York Times, The Dallas Morning News and The Seattle Times. E-mail tips to walshSE@phillynews.com
 Follow Sean on Twitter

PhillyClout Team
Also on Philly.com
Stay Connected