Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH
TEXT SIZE: A A A A
Email this post | Back to Blog home
Friday, September 5, 2008
City Attorneys Ask Court To Reconsider Casino Ruling
A artist's rendering of the proposed SugarHouse casino.

Mayor Nutter's administration asked the state Supreme Court today to reconsider it decision last month that SugarHouse, a proposed casino in Fishtown, has the right to build on 11 acres of state-owned "riparian lands" along the banks of the Delaware river. That property makes up half of Sugarhouse's 22 acres. This is not the first time the Mayor's Office or City Council has asked the court to reconsider a decision on a casino matter. So far, all of the court's rulings have stood without being re-examined.

The city Law Department, in a filing today, argued two points:  That the Court got it wrong when it decided a license to build on the riparian lands issued by then-Mayor Street's administration last year could not be revoked by a new mayor and that it could not be revoked because SugarHouse claimed to have relied on that license while making its casino plans.  SugarHouse, the Law Department wrote, "has proven no such thing."

State Sen. Vince Fumo last month said he and other legislators would appeal the decision in federal court.  SugarHouse has praised the court for its "meticulous legal and factual analysis."

Posted by Chris Brennan @ 6:24 PM  Permalink | 17 comments
SAVE AND SHARE
Comments
Posted by stockdoctor 05:00 AM, 09/06/2008
stupid just plain stupid not to allow this to be built here. so many jobs so much revenue for the city
Posted by Jes44 09:44 AM, 09/06/2008
I totally agree with you StockDoctor... the waterfront is an embarrassment as it currently is. Its amazing that other cities can have really nice waterfronts, but Philly doesnt understand that. Both people in the surrounding tri-state area and the City can both benefit from a revitalized waterfront. Building parks and some bike trails wont do that.
Posted by XDRUM 12:46 PM, 09/06/2008
look at boston,baltimore even new york waterfronts and ask yourself only in philadelphia with it's twenty years of failed planning of our waterfront and the politicians doing there best to stop this significant development,why? Do they have other interest do they have other investors ready to go or do they like it they way it is with thug night clubs that at 2am on weekends the shootings start.
Posted by jlemm 01:09 PM, 09/06/2008
Yes, the City is finally under an administration that takes into consideration the interests of the neighborhoods where these casinos are supposed to be located. Thank God we finally have a mayor who didn't sell out to casino interests and doesn't want to keep the river front a blighted wasteland until casinos build there. The river front can be developed in a way that's friendly to the people living around there and be an asset to the city, as in the Penn Praxis plans. The casinos can be moved to another location away from people's homes from where they provide the same revenue and jobs to the city.
Posted by feudi 03:16 PM, 09/06/2008
I have to agree with jhemm. About the last thing we need is a casino on the waterfront. In fact, government needs to stop using gambling as a source of revenue. It's not only immoral, it's not a wise financial dcision. As we slide into a deep recession until about 2013, the gambling industry will be taking a hit. People always cut back on non-essentials in recessions, and I can't think of any expenditure less essential than wasting my dough in a casino. Nutter is right, and Rendell is dead wrong on this issue.
Posted by equalityman 06:04 PM, 09/06/2008
As a lifelong resident of Philadelphia and 25 year resident of Fishtown, it is clear that a majority of Fishtown residents support the Sugarhouse casino for a variety of reasons; jobs with health benefits, opportunities for local vendors to increase their business, and a development where the community has access to the warerfront area that has been inaccessible for decades. Fishtown does not want another gated condo development and the City very much needs the revenue. In fact the Mayor has included Philadelphia casino revenue in his 5 year budget plan (talk about being disingenious). Our rec centers and schools (but his daughter goes to Masterman)are falling apart but the Mayor continues to spend hundreds of thousands of taxpayer dollars to fight this development that the Fishtown community supports. I supported this guy for Mayor but boy did I make a mistake!
Posted by sweettalk 06:32 PM, 09/06/2008
How much of your tax dollars has the city spent fighting casinos? And how much money does the city lose every day the casinos are delayed? Keep fighting against businesses that WANT to come into the city and keep watching people and businesses flee. Way to go, Philly! You're number one!
Posted by FishTownForever 11:03 PM, 09/06/2008
Another bump in the road for SugarHouse and Fishtown. Desparate attempts to undo clear legal precident and rulings aside, -this is causing nothing but a delay for the inevitable building and welcome which SugarHouse will receive in Fishtown, even as we will be waving goodbye to those who should be representing out interests. The hypocracy is glarring. All of a sudden, Nutter and his minions (who, in the heart of hearts want and need SugarHouse just where it is) weigh in like they CARE about Our (YES OUT RIVERFRONT.) When was the last time Nutter took his family to a picnic in Penn Treaty Park? When was the last time he donned overalls to help clean up the crack needles and trash? But now that neighbors have negotiated a sweet relationship with a business which will bring jobs, revenue and a renewed Riverfront, HE IS SOOOOOO concerned about it. Has he even walked around the so called "effected" blocks which are strewn with trash, broken bottles and crumbling houses? SUGARHOUSE is going to negatively effect them? So Nutter, spend citizen's money to fight one of the best business opportunities and job engines to come to Fishtown. What do u care about us anyway. You are fighting an expensive battle which, no doubt, are enriching lawyers and postponing the jobs and development we need. There's a phrase which comes right out of struggling communities which I know Michael Nutter knows well: GOD DON'T LIKE UGLY. Nutter, come into the Light will you?
Posted by jlemm 12:46 AM, 09/07/2008
"GOD DON'T LIKE UGLY" is right. It means God don't like ugly slot barns that cause people to gamble their money away and attract crime and traffic congestion. It also means God don't like people who when shown a few $$ are ready to throw their river side neighbors under the bus. Yeah, you heard me FishTownForever, GOD DON'T LIKE FACT ("Facts According to Casino Topdogs") and Fishtown don't like the slot barns in its front yard.
Posted by jlemm 08:55 AM, 09/07/2008
As a longtime resident of Fishtown, it is clear that a majority of Fishtown residents oppose the Sugarhouse casino for a variety of reasons: its closeness to residential areas (no other casinos are as close to people's homes as the proposed Sugarhouse casino); the traffic nightmares it will create; the crime and prostitution it will bring to the area and the need to pay for more police; plus many others. Fishtown does not want another gated condo or a slot parlor gambling venue and the City very much needs the revenue, so why not develop the river front the right way (Penn Praxis) and relocate the casino somewhere else. Tell the stubborn casinos owners to relocate so that the city can stop spending hundreds of thousands of taxpayer dollars to fight this development that the Fishtown community opposes.
Posted by daniel_99 09:43 PM, 09/07/2008
If course all of the trades unions want the casinos built - I heard the rate for an experienced plumber is over $100 / hr. The trade unions will always be for any kind of project that involves building something, regardless of any merits or problems. But there are a lot of other major issues to consider that have permanent effects on many others.
Posted by FishtownMom 11:40 PM, 09/07/2008
JL totally WRONG as usual. Fishtowners are frustrated that SugarHouse is not open for business. The MAJORITY of Fishtown residents support SugarHouse. And Daniel..really what comic book are you reading? Plumbers making $100/hour? You heard wrong.
Posted by NotADoneDeal 07:59 AM, 09/08/2008
If you are anxious for SugarHouse to open, you don't really have to wait. Just go outside and throw your money in the gutter. After all, when it comes to throwing your money away . . . don't delay, do it today!
Posted by FishTownForever 05:11 PM, 09/08/2008
I am glad to see progress being made at the SugarHouse site. SH, Fishtown will welcome you, -wait and see! The few who oppose you promise to move away when you open, so PLEEZE open soon. Our neighbors need jobs with benefits (even if the uppity think $25,000 a year jobs with benefits are some how shameful), the RiverFront needs development with pedestrian access and our businesses will be great partners with you. Don't Delay, keep on building today!
Posted by jlemm 07:06 PM, 09/08/2008
"The MAJORITY of Fishtown residents support SugarHouse". This is a lie that has been peddled by members of FACT ("Facts According to Casino Topdogs"), a Sugarhouse funded organization in Fishtown that under the guise of being "grassroots" has been defending and advocating Neil Bluhm's interests, not those of the community. The truth is that there has been no reliable poll to show how many people support or oppose casinos.
About Chris Brennan and Catherine Lucey
PhillyClout
Chris Brennan, a native Philadelphian and graduate of Temple University, joined the Daily News in 1999. He has written about SEPTA, the Philadelphia School District, the legalization of casino gambling, state government, the mayor, the governor, City Council and political campaigns.

Catherine Lucey joined the Daily News in 2002. Since then she has written about murderous drug gangs, political protesters and Harry Potter. For the past two years, she covered the 2007 mayoral election. Now that the battle is over, she has moved down to the City Hall bureau where she will report on the Nutter administration.

Share your tips

Catherine Lucey
luceyc@phillynews.com
Chris Brennan
brennac@phillynews.com