PhillyTablet Inquirer Daily News
philly.com
email
font size
comments
34
options
 
Sunday, March 13, 2011

"I don't want to have people who just agree with me. I want people who are continually pushing me out of my comfort zone."

-- Barack Obama, June 18, 2008.

Barack Obama lied.

Again.

He lied because somebody -- a good man, a decent man, and a respected spokesman for the U.S. State Department -- pushed Obama out of his comfort zone this week. And so what happened? -- the Obama administration forced him out of his job. Apparently Obama does just want to have people who agree with him. Imagine that.

Truth be told (heh), the biggest outrage in this story actually is not the firing of the State Department spokesman, P.J. Crowley (pictured at top). It's the episode that Crowley spoke out about -- the bizarre and immoral treatment of alleged Wikileaks leaker Pfc. Bradley Manning, who according to multiple news accounts is being held under conditions that make Gitmo look look like a halfway house for inside traders.

It started out like this:

Made to endure strict conditions under a prevention of injury order against the advice of military psychiatrists, he is treated like no other prisoner at the 250-capacity Quantico Brig detention facility in Virginia. Despite that he is yet to be convicted of any crime, for the past 218 consecutive days he has been made to live in a cell 6ft wide and 12ft long, without contact with any other detainees. He is not allowed to exercise or have personal effects in his cell, and for the one hour each day he is allowed free from his windowless cell he is taken to an empty room where he is allowed to walk, but not run.

One of the few people to have visited Manning, David House, spoke yesterday of how he had witnessed his friend go from a "bright-eyed intelligent young man" to someone who at times has appeared "catatonic" with "very high difficulty carrying on day to day conversation".

And it got worse:

Military jailers are forcing Bradley Manning, the 23-year-old soldier accused of passing classified documents to WikiLeaks.org, to strip naked in his cell at night and sleep without clothing, a requirement his lawyer says was imposed after Manning made a "sarcastic quip" about his confinement.

So basically the administration that ran on a platform of ending torture of suspected al-Qaeda terrorists and closing Guantanamo has not only not closed Gitmo (yes, Congress was a big part of that, but still..) but is now inbhumanely treating a United States soldier who's accused of a serious crime. This is an unforced error, to use the kindest possible languiage. It is not George W. Bush's fault or Dick Cheney's fault that Barack Obama's Pentagon is torturing Bradley Manning. It is only Barack Obama's fault.

It took P.J. Crowley to see the emperor's new clothes. Speaking last week at an informal panel at MIT* on new media, Crowley was asked about the Manning case and blurted out the truth. He said the circumstances of Manning's detention have been “ridiculous and counterproductive and stupid.” Those five seconds of brutal candor cost Crowley his job today -- although, for what it's worth, he is an American hero to me and to many others.

Look, this is not a commentary on what Manning did or not do. He is charged with a serious offense under the law in leaking classified documents. His advocates call him a whistleblower. I'm not sure what Manning's defense will be but I do know two things: 1) he is entitled to his day in court, just like anyone else and b) he is also entitled to be held in humane conditions, not a form of torture -- sleep deprivation is torture -- which may aimed at forcing a confession.

I'm 52 years old, and I'm constantly amazed at how much about human nature I still don't really get. What exactly goes on in Obama's mind? He's a smart and supposedly idealistic guy who came of age during the Reagan years, who surely -- those first times he dared to dream about the Oval Office -- saw himself taking all the obvious hypocrisy. Instead, he is taking presidential hypocrisy to new levels. What switch got turned off, or on, that stops him from ordering a halt to the mistreatment of Bradley Manning?

How does Barack Obama look in the mirror some mornings?

* Corrected from initial version.

Posted by Will Bunch @ 7:33 PM  Permalink | 34 comments
Comments   
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 7:53 PM, 03/13/2011
    I say we impeach him. With me, Willy?
    Wilhelm Von Humboldt
  • 0 like this / 2 don't   •   Posted 8:03 PM, 03/13/2011
    Sorry Will, incarcerating a traitor is not "torture". You are way off the mark, and your naïveté, if spread to American leaders and decision makers, is going to get Americans killed. Grow up. Wake up. Man up.
    Mr. Smith
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 9:28 PM, 03/13/2011
    Not simple incarceration--solitary and naked incarceration is not justified in any case--and I do not think that there is any proof that Manning was a traitor.
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 10:00 AM, 03/14/2011
    Manning's a traitor? How do you know that? You watched it on TV? Is that all it takes to make you believe? There is a word in the dictionary for this kind of behavior: It's calle being Gullible...you know, as in being naïve. BTW, yours sure spread to American leaders, since you seem ready to swallow whatever they say w/o any proof.

    As per you, he's guilty before being even charged. This is typical of the Communist regimes; also in Zimbabwe or Ivory Coast. You love them dictators?
    LoupBlanc
  • Comment removed.
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 8:11 PM, 03/13/2011
    Obama is a politician, just like Bush and Cheney. The only difference is he is a politician that happens to share a majority of your ideals. But he is nothing but a politician in the end. Kind of makes that whole "Hope and Change" thing pretty funny if you ask me.
    phillyjeffsr
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 9:29 PM, 03/13/2011
    Not a very good politician if he keeps losing his base--which includes me normally, but some of this is really disturbing. One begins to think about third parties.
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 8:23 PM, 03/13/2011
    Willy how do you look in the mirror in the morning? Dude you are no Oil Painting!
    CrashTestCorzine
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 8:55 PM, 03/13/2011
    Obama's getting a hard lesson in just how annoying, and self-righteous liberals actually are.
    jmc
  • 0 like this / 1 don't   •   Posted 8:56 PM, 03/13/2011
    You can't treat Manning poorly enough. He's a traitor.
    bobbyd24
  • Comment removed.
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 9:03 PM, 03/13/2011
    Will what you continue to see his Obama believes that he is best for the country. That he is the answer. He is a fascist at heart and dreams of a cult of personality.
    Captain Terrific
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 9:08 PM, 03/13/2011
    This is a comedy routine...right? This can't be serious post lamenting the treatment of a traitor.
    georgel
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 9:16 PM, 03/13/2011
    The Nuremberg war trials established that "just following orders" is no excuse for a soldier covering up war crimes. Bradely Manning upheld his oath to defend the Constitution. Those who did not do not like have their illegal war crimes exposed.
    tom-104
  • 0 like this / 0 don't   •   Posted 9:22 PM, 03/13/2011
    With so many in this thread who think they're certain of Manning's guilt, it's a wonder he needs a trial at all.
    peter.milley


View comments: 1  |  2  |  3
About Will Bunch
Will's new book: Learn about it here and purchase it here.


Will Bunch, a senior writer at the Philadelphia Daily News, blogs about his obsessions, including national and local politics and world affairs, the media, pop music, the Philadelphia Phillies, soccer and other sports, not necessarily in that order.

E-mail Will by clicking here.

PLEASE COMMENT WITH PASSION...

...but not with racial slurs, potentially libelous allegations, obscenities or other juvenile noise. Such comments will, at our discretion, be deleted in their entirety, and repeat offenders will be blocked from commenting. ALSO: Any commenter advocating killing any government official will be immediately banned.

Thanks.

Blog Roll
Philly/National
 
Atrios
 
Kiko's House
 
Suburban Guerilla
 
Booman Tribune
 
All-Spin Zone
 
Philly (Dragonballyee)
 
Afro-Netizen
 
Rowhouse Logic
 
MyDD
 
Bad Attitudes
 
Billmon
 
iFlipFlop
 
CorrenteWire
 
upyernoz
 
Tattered Coat
 
Fables of the Reconstruction
 
Slacktivist
Philly
 
Citizen Mom
 
The Next Mayor
 
Philly Future
 
Philadelphia Will Do
 
Philebrity
 
Young Philly Politics
 
Phillyblog
 
Welcome to Phillyville
 
Phawker
 
A List of Things Thrown Five Minutes Ago
 
Keystone Blog
 
Philadelphia - America's Hometown
 
BlankBaby
 
Above Average Jane
 
Phillyist
 
Metroblogging Philadelphia
 
The Clog
Politics
 
Josh Marshall
 
Daily Kos
 
Juan Cole
 
Oliver Willis
 
Andy Borowitz
 
War and Piece
 
Wonkette
 
BuzzFlash
 
Raw Story
 
Cursor
 
Crooks and Liars
 
Swing State Project
 
Kevin Drum
 
Talk Left
 
AmericaBlog
 
Hullabaloo
 
Mad Kane
 
Think Progress
 
Jesus' General
 
The Carpetbagger Report
 
Majikthise
 
Echidne of the Snakes
 
David Sirota
 
Glenn Greenwald
 
TBogg
 
Fire Dog Lake
 
Taylor Marsh
 
Matthew Yglesias
 
Jon Swift
 
Drudge Report
Sports
 
Beer Leaguer
 
The 700 Level
 
Dick Polman
 
Balls, Sticks and Stuff
 
Shallow Center
 
Philling Station
 
Phillies Nation
 
A Citizen's Blog
 
The Good Phight
Media
 
Romenesko
 
Editor and Publisher
 
Pressthink
 
Buzzmachine
 
The Inksniffer
 
Media Bloodhound
 
Eat the Press
 
Mickey Kaus
 
Media (Huffington Post)
If you must
 
Blinq
 
The Corner
 
Instapundit
 
Andrew Sullivan
 
Free Republic
 
James Taranto
 
Blonde Sagacity
 
ScrappleFace
 
Blogorrhea