Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH
share
email
font size
options
 
Thursday, July 31, 2008

 

How about this for a deal: I'll stop writing about how John McCain is embarrassing himself when he stops embarrassing himself.

His latest, most personal, assault on Barack Obama is further proof that the so-called "maverick" has trashed his own promise of high-minded discourse, and instead embraced the gut-kicking Bush political template of the past eight years. Indeed, you don't have to be an Obama fan to conclude that the latest assault is juvenile. I say this because a fair number of Republicans - some speaking anonymously to the press, with others, including former McCain aides, speaking on the record - have already judged the assault to be juvenile. Or, as ex-McCain intimate John Weaver prefers to call it, "childish."

I'm referring to McCain's attempt, in a new TV ad and in a new campaign memo, to paint Obama as an effete, high-living political version of Paris Hilton. This is the old-school Republican style, dating back to the zaps aimed at Mike Dukakis 20 years ago, as practiced by the party establishment attack dogs that McCain, supposedly, has stood against for so long. It is no accident that this strategy is now preeminent; within the past month, several veterans of the '04 Bush campaign have taken the reins.

Maybe it'll work (as it did against John Kerry in 2004), and maybe it won't (as it didn't against Bill Clinton in 1992, when the attack dogs tried to link him to values-challenged celebrity Woody Allen). McCain risks undercutting his own reputation (in many quarters) for rectitude. But what fascinates me most at the moment is the bizarre nature of his arguments. Let's go to the McCain campaign memo, released yesterday:

It states at one point, "Only a celebrity of Barack Obama's magnitude could attract 200,000 fans in Berlin who gathered for the mere opportunity to be in his presence. These are not supporters or even voters, but fans fawning over The One." Well, excuse me for asking, but are we supposed to believe that there is something wrong with the notion that a potential American president might be popular abroad? Is the prospect of a closer bond between America and its western allies supposed to be...a bad thing? Where were the McCain people back in the '80s, when Ronald Reagan was often welcomed abroad by a sea of waving American flags?

The McCain memo also states, "Only celebrities like Barack Obama go to the gym three times a day, demand MET-RX chocolate roasted-peanut protein bars, and bottles of a hard-to-find organic brew -- Black Forest Berry Honest Tea..." Again, are we supposed to believe that there is something wrong with working out in a gym and being healthy? Isn't it a good thing to pay attention to one's health, especially since so many overweight and unhealthy Americans contribute to our health cost crisis? Isn't it a good thing that a potential president is seeking to be in peak shape for the world's toughest job?

And are we supposed to believe that there is something wrong or weird about eating protein bars - which, at this point, are so mainstream that they're often sold at the corner grocery store, as a healthy antidote to junk food? And is there supposed to be something effete or elitist about liking Honest Tea, which, apparently unbeknowest to the McCain campaign, was purchased five months ago by the effete elitists at the Coca Cola company?

But the real problem with the Mcain strategy is its fundamental hypocrisy. McCain himself has been a celebrity since Barack Obama was 11 years old.

When McCain came home from Hanoi in 1973, he was instantly immortalized with a photo on the front page of The New York Times (in that pre-CNN, pre-Internet era, scoring a page-one Times photo was the ultimate media coup). Soon thereafter, he wrote about himself in a long article in U.S. News & World Report. He has since written three books, and inspired at least three biographies. He has trekked 12 times to The Daily Show, 10 times to Jay Leno's couch, eight times to David Letterman's couch, three times to Conan O'Brien's couch, twice to The View, and surfaced as a bit actor in an episode of 24.

And there's more. Long before McCain the celebrity showed up on Saturday Night Live this past spring, he hosted an episode in 2002 (the first sitting U.S. senator ever to do so), and introduced his musical guests, The White Stripes. Heck, producer Lorne Michaels even donated $2300 to McCain's campaign last year (the sole Republican on Michaels' list), and I don't ever recall McCain giving back that celebrity money. Indeed, one grievance that many Republicans have long nurtured about McCain is his celebrity-mongering.

How long will the Bush apparatchiks who are now embedded with McCain stick with this faux-populist attack on Obama? Unless they can gain some traction and reverse the polls this summer, they may be tempted to drink something a lot stronger than Honest Tea.

 

Posted by Dick Polman @ 1:52 PM  Permalink | 61 comments
Comments   
Posted 02:25 PM, 07/31/2008
jwad56
Overweight and unhealthy Americans for McCain please check in!
Comment removed.
Comment removed.
Posted 02:34 PM, 07/31/2008
LJL
Actually, this may not be a bad strategy. Go to any WalMart, where apparently the majority of americans shop. Good luck finding more than 3 people under 250 pounds. With every passing day I am more convinced that a well-spoken, educated, fit, multi-racial former law professor in no way can win an election in this country, since the majority of americans are illiterate, uneducated and fat. As for the inherent hypocrisy in McLame's campaign, most americans can't spell hypocrisy, let alone understand it's nuances in political ads.
Posted 02:39 PM, 07/31/2008
AHiredGun
Honestly, Xi Jah, I wish you would stop drinking whatever the neocons are giving you and wake up and smell the coffee. Unless you are wealthy or upper middle class, the Republican Party won't be doing a blessed thing for you. Go ahead, keep goose-stepping toward the neo-con spin. You sir, are an embarassment.
Comment removed.
Posted 02:50 PM, 07/31/2008
jmc
McCain's a celebrity because he actually did something to earn that status. Obama, like Paris Hilton, gets fawned over for, up to this point, no apparent reason. What does he bring to the table other than the fact he is young, handsome, and gives good speeches. So far we see all style and no substance, hence the Paris Hilton comparisons. All you liberal, protein bar eating health nuts remember that George W. Bush is the healthiest most physically fit President ever. You don't want to be like him, do you?
Posted 02:50 PM, 07/31/2008
yobill626
Who DOESN'T take care of themselves in this century? Playing basketball is Obama's way of keeping his body fit (& his mind sharp), just like Bush rides a mountainbike. At least his choice of snacks & beverages is good. Heck, drinking those organic teas is better than if he were drinking any of those crappy Budweiser beers. Maybe McCain can send him over a few Bratwursts from the Sausage Haus he was at last week? C'mon, guys...
Posted 02:51 PM, 07/31/2008
LJL
Thanks, lone, for proving my point.
Posted 02:55 PM, 07/31/2008
yobill626
jmc: Keeping fit appears to be one of the few good things Bush does to keep his mind sharp. God only knows how much worse his decisions would have been if he didn't ride his mountainbike.
Posted 02:56 PM, 07/31/2008
squintymc
The Hiltons have given quite a bit to McCain's campaign...someone needs to do some cross-checking over at his camp. Not to mention, his lovely blonde heiress wife has quite a bit more in common with Miss Paris than does Obama. Further, he's wasting an awful lot of cash and steam on these very creative ads while everyone's at the beach. What I find so hilarious about this whole scrap is how impressed I was the day after the Iowa primary that every news organization in the world was covering Obama's win...even though Britney Spears, queen of coverage, had a standoff with police and got carted off to the looney bin the same night. Not a bit of coverage for two whole days, totally drowned out by Obama. I, for one, find that to be a hugely positive development. If anything, Obama is the anti-Britney, and any attention he garners at the expense of celebrity nonsense is a net gain for the country and the world. I also thought it was hilarious that one of McCain's advisors talked about Paris's "fans"...she may be famous, but I've never met a Paris Hilton "fan" in my life. Maybe the old coots over at his campaign are the fans they're referring to? She's less attractive in person, fellas, try to relax.
Posted 02:58 PM, 07/31/2008
Mark55
We're drowning in fat, which all of us are paying for. Heart attacks at young ages, etc. Guts hanging over belts everywhere you go. Truly embarassing. Sure, let's make fun of someone working out. Makes sense to me. We need to get fatter, not fitter.
Comment removed.
Comment removed.
Posted 03:01 PM, 07/31/2008
squintymc
jmc - one thing that I really like about Obama is how he is capable of identifying positive traits worth emulating in others, even Bush. He also runs his campaign like a business and respects religion, like Bush. Kudos, I say. Oh, and he's famous for BEING A UNITED STATES SENATOR. You know, there's only 100 of those at a time. Small potatoes, obviously. What a jerk, right?
Posted 03:06 PM, 07/31/2008
ILikeIke
Dukakis, Kerry and Obama have been and are being portrayed as elitist, effeminant softies because they ARE elitist, effeminant softies. Mr. Polman is within his right, as are the other Obamatrons, to carry all of the water that they please for their blessed Messiah. What troubles me is that are offended by ANY criticisms of their Chosen One. Can we hold any objections to such an unknown holding the most powerful office in the world? I dare Mr. Polman to offer one criticism of the Obama World Tour, er, presidential campaign. If not, any sense of balance, insight and objectivity - which I used to enjoy in your column - had gone completely out the window. It is a shame to see such an enlightend political observer drinking the Kool-Aid for this unqualified lightweight.
Posted 03:07 PM, 07/31/2008
jwad56
And they wonder why they are called elitist? Saying this ad will work on fat stupid Americans isn't elitist? The author and his supporters on this board are so fit and smart and beautiful and can't understand why so many fat lazy Americans don't want Socialism. Go figure.
Comment removed.
Comment removed.
Posted 03:25 PM, 07/31/2008
bon
I don't have much to say about this article. Obama is an effete, empty shell. This makes him more similar to Paris Hilton or Spears than Hillary Clinton or John McCain. McCain's criticism of Obama is fair. Obama and his supporters would do well learn to deal with it. They are starting to sound an awful lot like this guy: http://link.brightcove.com/services/link/bcpid271557392/bctid1701226987
Posted 03:27 PM, 07/31/2008
DTWexpat
As I recall, the Dems knocked W pretty roughly in his first term for a poor work ethic due to the amount of time he devoted to exercise. It was an invalid criticism then, and it is now as to Obama, but let's have some consistency from both sides.
Posted 03:27 PM, 07/31/2008
DTWexpat
As I recall, the Dems knocked W pretty roughly in his first term for a poor work ethic due to the amount of time he devoted to exercise. It was an invalid criticism then, and it is now as to Obama, but let's have some consistency from both sides.
Posted 03:30 PM, 07/31/2008
Mark55
Zombies? We talkin zombies? You mean like the zombies that listen every afternoon to the bozos on right-wing radio? Those zombies?
Comment removed.
Posted 03:42 PM, 07/31/2008
Mark55
Zombies on both sides. Those on the left that blindly worship Paris-types. Those on the right that blindly worship Fat Rush/Hannity types.
Comment removed.
Posted 03:51 PM, 07/31/2008
birdsfaninnc
You right wing nut jobs on this blog just crack me up. You constantly cry about polman being biased....well that the hell? HE'S A LIBERAL BLOGGER!!!! How stupid are you people? Do you right right wing blogs and complain that they probably cast mccain in a positive light while trashing Obama? Oh i'm sorry, you probably don't know who Obama is. You people usually refer to him as Baraq or Hussein. since you clearly can't find any serious flaws in him, your only hope is to use his middle name or misspell his first name.
Posted 03:51 PM, 07/31/2008
JeffA
wow. guy goes on vacation only to return to the sad sight of the Polman board strongly populated by a half dozen Obama haters who offer little more than talk-radio smears. Does anyone care that while we argue whose wife is less likable, the banking crisis entered its next phase - bailout - without so much of a nod toward accountability. Where's the debtor's prison for the bankers, brokers, homeowners, and speculators? Any bank that loosened its' requirements to the point of not requiring proof of income should have its' executives jailed and their assets seized. Any broker found falsifying loan documents to push a deal through should get the same treatment. Any homeowner found to be speculating on a quick flip of their home should be left to work their way through personal bankruptcy. grrrr..
Comment removed.
Comment removed.
Posted 03:57 PM, 07/31/2008
Mark55
birdsfaninnc, Xi Jah is typing as he is listening to Hannity. Actually, he is listening to Hannity, who tells him what to type.
Comment removed.
Posted 04:04 PM, 07/31/2008
tom - wilmington, de
So I guess bashing McCain for being a celebrity upon his return from Hanoi...where he spent how many years in a POW camp...is the same thing as Obama being a celebrity from his experience as a community organizer. Yeah, I see the correlation. And what's this about Reagan being a celebrity? When he first took office, it was feared he was going to start WWIII. The Europeans were aghast at his policies towards the Soviets, some even being against his stances. He became a celebrity and drew a huge crowd at the Berlin wall after serving as president for 7 years and helping defeat Communism by standing up to them, Yeah, I can see the correlation between Reagan being a celebrity and Obama, who served as a US Senator for 146 days before beginning his campaign for president and has absolutely no legislation attached to his name. Boy is that a stretch.
Posted 04:07 PM, 07/31/2008
tom - wilmington, de
The point of the ad is that Paris Hilton is a celebrity without really having achieved anything and with no real accomplishments. Same goes for Obama, who incidentally will solve the energy crisis by making everyone keep their tires properly inflated and yesterday played the race card in Missouri.
Posted 04:07 PM, 07/31/2008
tom - wilmington, de
The point of the ad is that Paris Hilton is a celebrity without really having achieved anything and with no real accomplishments. Same goes for Obama, who incidentally will solve the energy crisis by making everyone keep their tires properly inflated and yesterday played the race card in Missouri.
Posted 04:09 PM, 07/31/2008
Mark55
Xi, Play stupid all you want but you know what I mean. You right-wing nuts fawn all over your favorites just as badly.
Comment removed.
Posted 04:16 PM, 07/31/2008
Mark55
Well, there's always Bob Barr if he gets on the ballot. Too bad McCain doesn't make your leg tingle. I guess if he toed the party line 100%, like a good Republican would, that would be fine, right? Oh well. Can't have it all, can you?
Posted 04:35 PM, 07/31/2008
afrazier24
lonewolf Please think for yourself for once and stop repeating all of those McCain camp talking points. You quote that garbage directly from them like it's fact when 99.9% of the stuff they put out is debunked with in a few days. Gosh what happened to people actually thinking? McCain did something to be a hero? Getting shot down doesn't make you a hero! Graduating 894th out of 899 students at your school doesn't make you fit to lead. Crashing 5 naval aircraft doesn't make you fit to serve! What has this geriatric so called war hero done besides flip flop and lie sense this election cycle started? He gets the "celebrity" treatment by the press after all of those gaffes went unmentioned. People like lonewolf scare me because they don't look at facts all they see is party lines.
Posted 04:44 PM, 07/31/2008
thelastRepublicaninPhilly
Obama rather go to the gym and get a photo-op then visit injured troops.
Comment removed.
Comment removed.
Posted 05:52 PM, 07/31/2008
tom - wilmington, de
Interestingly, in the poll link from the post, it is mentioned that Obama has LESS solid and leaning Electoral Votes than the previous week....which means the polls are already reversing. Funny how that was not mentioned in either the post or any of the comments.
Comment removed.
Comment removed.
Posted 08:22 PM, 07/31/2008
mcnuckel
Tom, is that similar to when Tom Ridge asked us all to go out and by duct tape in case of a terror attack? The new (or old) publican motto "cry a lot and lie a lot"
Posted 08:32 PM, 07/31/2008
jjfalcon35
The way Obama paralyzed the Clintons playing the racial victim card is not going to work against McCain in the general. People are not stupid. Here is the clearly less qualified and lessexperienced candiate for the job blocking criticism hiding behind racial discrimination, trying to prevent judgement on his record and background. Nice try Barack aint gonna work
Posted 09:41 PM, 07/31/2008
JimR
Xi Jah, you must get real here. Polman is a political commentator. This is a blog site. By definition, this is an opinion function! Polman is a Lib. If you think that you will get anything other than LibSpeak, try another site. You can't seriously log in here to get names, dates, places, news. You can be a journalist and blogger and Polman hasn't been anything BUT an opinion giver/analyzer for a long time. YOU also get to give your opinion on this Lib center.
Posted 11:19 PM, 07/31/2008
tom - wilmington, de
Tom Ridge and duct tape? Is that the best you can do? Once again, the liberal method is to attack and say "Oh yeah, well same to you too" instead of confronting something stupid their candidate said. More Obama talking points straight from the Keith Olberman playbook. Did anybody else check out the poll that was highlighted above? One interesting point in it is that Obama has lost what were termed sold electoral votes and has a lot of "leaning" electoral votes. McCain actually picked up solid electoral votes in the past week...when Obama was on his world tour. So it looks as if the poll swing referred to above is already taking hold.
Posted 02:25 AM, 08/01/2008
yobill626
tom: I read the attachment. The numbers were interesting, but as pollsters have stated everywhere, it is too early to hang on specifics. Trends & "big-picture" numbers are what they look at in July --- & even they are fleeting. The numbers you mentioned improved for McCain, but it still shows Obama over 300 & McCain at under 240. He needs to put together a run of these. If he does it, I surely hope it is because he is presenting his view of the issues, not because the Rove wing of his staff took over his campaign. We are presented with a clear, distinct choice in this election. If what you & the other RW's claim --- that McCain is a better candidate because he's on the correct side of more issues, communicating that is what should propel him to victory. I can't remember when the last day McCain didn't focus on what Obama was doing, as opposed to just sticking to his own message (whatever that is). For someone who has sacrificed so much for his country, he's looking pretty sad to me.
Posted 02:32 AM, 08/01/2008
yobill626
tom: A more important issue...was it worth it going to the Eagles training camp? People say you have to go when they are doing the 7 on 7 drills...
Posted 06:57 AM, 08/01/2008
frankg962
Tom, I'm with Yobill, how was the training camp?
Posted 06:59 AM, 08/01/2008
jjfalcon35
The sad reality is that Mccain has been talking about his vision for months and the media all but ignored him pursuing Obama celebrity appeal. He had to become more aggressive, creative pointing out distinctions to attarct media attention
Comment removed.
Posted 08:41 AM, 08/01/2008
tom - wilmington, de
yobill and frank...the training camp was well worth the time. They ran several "two minute drills" with the full offenses going against the full defenses. McNabb looked very good but Kolb had an off day. There were several nice catches and runs (Westbrook looks like he wants to make a point) and a lot of real smacks that made the crowd go "ooohhh". Some of the players also joke around with the fans during the day. My sons really enjoyed it and got David Akers autograph afterwards on their footballs. The only disappointment was the autograph tent, where you need a ticket within a certain range to get in and we just missed it. But it was definitely worth the trip. And yobill, I agree with your analysis, it is too early to make anything of the polls. I also wish McCain would concentrate more on what he stands for, but I also believe he has to knock Obama down a peg or two...the guy is really on a high horse and I believe he is beginning to believe his own press clippings. His ego, even for a politician, is huge (he even has a transition team in place already from what I hear) and needs to come back down to where is the presumptive NOMINEE for president and not the presumptive president.
Posted 09:04 AM, 08/01/2008
JimR
I hope there's someone in Obama's camp that visits the reality chamber once in a while. Tom is right. Obama seems to believe his own press releases. Sometimes the Obama folks are in the parellel universe. Some of this will have to wear off. He caught the focus because he initially appeared to be so much different, so much "outside the beltway" and we're seeing that he's just part of the club. After Labor day, the field will change and the polls will get more realistic.
Posted 10:10 AM, 08/01/2008
p-diddy
Real men drink mead and eat gruel. But if McCain is targeting the fat and stupid vote, Obama better watch out. We're the fattest country on earth.
Posted 10:15 AM, 08/01/2008
p-diddy
Do you think a guy who sings "Bomb Iran" and jokes about the Iranian people dying of cancer DOESN'T have a big ego?
Posted 10:25 AM, 08/01/2008
CB
squintymc - "What I find so hilarious....is how impressed I was the day after the Iowa primary that every news organization in the world was covering Obama's win...even though Britney Spears...had a standoff with police..." Guess that means Backtrack Obama is now the king of tabloids? Dubious distinction, but probably right, all fluff and no substance.
Posted 12:51 PM, 08/01/2008
yobill626
tom: After the pitiful poor planner we have as President, its a good thing for somebody to be thinking 2 or 3 steps ahead of where he is. However, I would warn him to keep his eye on the ball.
Posted 11:39 PM, 08/07/2008
p-diddy
Cannibals unite for McCain!
About Dick Polman

Cited by the Columbia Journalism Review as one of the nation's top political reporters, and lauded by the ABC News political website as "one of the finest political journalists of his generation," Dick Polman is a national political columnist at the Philadelphia Inquirer. He is on the full-time faculty at the University of Pennsylvania, as "writer in residence." Dick has been a frequent guest on C-Span, MSNBC, CNN, NPR and the BBC. He covered the 1992, 1996, 2000, and 2004 presidential campaigns.

ARCHIVES

All commentaries posted before April 18, 2008, can be accessed at www.dickpolman.blogspot.com.