Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH
share
email
font size
options
 
Thursday, July 31, 2008

 

How about this for a deal: I'll stop writing about how John McCain is embarrassing himself when he stops embarrassing himself.

His latest, most personal, assault on Barack Obama is further proof that the so-called "maverick" has trashed his own promise of high-minded discourse, and instead embraced the gut-kicking Bush political template of the past eight years. Indeed, you don't have to be an Obama fan to conclude that the latest assault is juvenile. I say this because a fair number of Republicans - some speaking anonymously to the press, with others, including former McCain aides, speaking on the record - have already judged the assault to be juvenile. Or, as ex-McCain intimate John Weaver prefers to call it, "childish."

I'm referring to McCain's attempt, in a new TV ad and in a new campaign memo, to paint Obama as an effete, high-living political version of Paris Hilton. This is the old-school Republican style, dating back to the zaps aimed at Mike Dukakis 20 years ago, as practiced by the party establishment attack dogs that McCain, supposedly, has stood against for so long. It is no accident that this strategy is now preeminent; within the past month, several veterans of the '04 Bush campaign have taken the reins.

Maybe it'll work (as it did against John Kerry in 2004), and maybe it won't (as it didn't against Bill Clinton in 1992, when the attack dogs tried to link him to values-challenged celebrity Woody Allen). McCain risks undercutting his own reputation (in many quarters) for rectitude. But what fascinates me most at the moment is the bizarre nature of his arguments. Let's go to the McCain campaign memo, released yesterday:

It states at one point, "Only a celebrity of Barack Obama's magnitude could attract 200,000 fans in Berlin who gathered for the mere opportunity to be in his presence. These are not supporters or even voters, but fans fawning over The One." Well, excuse me for asking, but are we supposed to believe that there is something wrong with the notion that a potential American president might be popular abroad? Is the prospect of a closer bond between America and its western allies supposed to be...a bad thing? Where were the McCain people back in the '80s, when Ronald Reagan was often welcomed abroad by a sea of waving American flags?

The McCain memo also states, "Only celebrities like Barack Obama go to the gym three times a day, demand MET-RX chocolate roasted-peanut protein bars, and bottles of a hard-to-find organic brew -- Black Forest Berry Honest Tea..." Again, are we supposed to believe that there is something wrong with working out in a gym and being healthy? Isn't it a good thing to pay attention to one's health, especially since so many overweight and unhealthy Americans contribute to our health cost crisis? Isn't it a good thing that a potential president is seeking to be in peak shape for the world's toughest job?

And are we supposed to believe that there is something wrong or weird about eating protein bars - which, at this point, are so mainstream that they're often sold at the corner grocery store, as a healthy antidote to junk food? And is there supposed to be something effete or elitist about liking Honest Tea, which, apparently unbeknowest to the McCain campaign, was purchased five months ago by the effete elitists at the Coca Cola company?

But the real problem with the Mcain strategy is its fundamental hypocrisy. McCain himself has been a celebrity since Barack Obama was 11 years old.

When McCain came home from Hanoi in 1973, he was instantly immortalized with a photo on the front page of The New York Times (in that pre-CNN, pre-Internet era, scoring a page-one Times photo was the ultimate media coup). Soon thereafter, he wrote about himself in a long article in U.S. News & World Report. He has since written three books, and inspired at least three biographies. He has trekked 12 times to The Daily Show, 10 times to Jay Leno's couch, eight times to David Letterman's couch, three times to Conan O'Brien's couch, twice to The View, and surfaced as a bit actor in an episode of 24.

And there's more. Long before McCain the celebrity showed up on Saturday Night Live this past spring, he hosted an episode in 2002 (the first sitting U.S. senator ever to do so), and introduced his musical guests, The White Stripes. Heck, producer Lorne Michaels even donated $2300 to McCain's campaign last year (the sole Republican on Michaels' list), and I don't ever recall McCain giving back that celebrity money. Indeed, one grievance that many Republicans have long nurtured about McCain is his celebrity-mongering.

How long will the Bush apparatchiks who are now embedded with McCain stick with this faux-populist attack on Obama? Unless they can gain some traction and reverse the polls this summer, they may be tempted to drink something a lot stronger than Honest Tea.

 

Posted by Dick Polman @ 1:52 PM  Permalink | 61 comments
Comments   
Posted 02:25 PM, 07/31/2008
jwad56
Overweight and unhealthy Americans for McCain please check in!
Comment removed.
Comment removed.
Posted 02:34 PM, 07/31/2008
LJL
Actually, this may not be a bad strategy. Go to any WalMart, where apparently the majority of americans shop. Good luck finding more than 3 people under 250 pounds. With every passing day I am more convinced that a well-spoken, educated, fit, multi-racial former law professor in no way can win an election in this country, since the majority of americans are illiterate, uneducated and fat. As for the inherent hypocrisy in McLame's campaign, most americans can't spell hypocrisy, let alone understand it's nuances in political ads.
Posted 02:39 PM, 07/31/2008
AHiredGun
Honestly, Xi Jah, I wish you would stop drinking whatever the neocons are giving you and wake up and smell the coffee. Unless you are wealthy or upper middle class, the Republican Party won't be doing a blessed thing for you. Go ahead, keep goose-stepping toward the neo-con spin. You sir, are an embarassment.
Comment removed.
Posted 02:50 PM, 07/31/2008
jmc
McCain's a celebrity because he actually did something to earn that status. Obama, like Paris Hilton, gets fawned over for, up to this point, no apparent reason. What does he bring to the table other than the fact he is young, handsome, and gives good speeches. So far we see all style and no substance, hence the Paris Hilton comparisons. All you liberal, protein bar eating health nuts remember that George W. Bush is the healthiest most physically fit President ever. You don't want to be like him, do you?
Posted 02:50 PM, 07/31/2008
yobill626
Who DOESN'T take care of themselves in this century? Playing basketball is Obama's way of keeping his body fit (& his mind sharp), just like Bush rides a mountainbike. At least his choice of snacks & beverages is good. Heck, drinking those organic teas is better than if he were drinking any of those crappy Budweiser beers. Maybe McCain can send him over a few Bratwursts from the Sausage Haus he was at last week? C'mon, guys...
Posted 02:51 PM, 07/31/2008
LJL
Thanks, lone, for proving my point.
Posted 02:55 PM, 07/31/2008
yobill626
jmc: Keeping fit appears to be one of the few good things Bush does to keep his mind sharp. God only knows how much worse his decisions would have been if he didn't ride his mountainbike.
Posted 02:56 PM, 07/31/2008
squintymc
The Hiltons have given quite a bit to McCain's campaign...someone needs to do some cross-checking over at his camp. Not to mention, his lovely blonde heiress wife has quite a bit more in common with Miss Paris than does Obama. Further, he's wasting an awful lot of cash and steam on these very creative ads while everyone's at the beach. What I find so hilarious about this whole scrap is how impressed I was the day after the Iowa primary that every news organization in the world was covering Obama's win...even though Britney Spears, queen of coverage, had a standoff with police and got carted off to the looney bin the same night. Not a bit of coverage for two whole days, totally drowned out by Obama. I, for one, find that to be a hugely positive development. If anything, Obama is the anti-Britney, and any attention he garners at the expense of celebrity nonsense is a net gain for the country and the world. I also thought it was hilarious that one of McCain's advisors talked about Paris's "fans"...she may be famous, but I've never met a Paris Hilton "fan" in my life. Maybe the old coots over at his campaign are the fans they're referring to? She's less attractive in person, fellas, try to relax.
Posted 02:58 PM, 07/31/2008
Mark55
We're drowning in fat, which all of us are paying for. Heart attacks at young ages, etc. Guts hanging over belts everywhere you go. Truly embarassing. Sure, let's make fun of someone working out. Makes sense to me. We need to get fatter, not fitter.
Comment removed.
Comment removed.
Posted 03:01 PM, 07/31/2008
squintymc
jmc - one thing that I really like about Obama is how he is capable of identifying positive traits worth emulating in others, even Bush. He also runs his campaign like a business and respects religion, like Bush. Kudos, I say. Oh, and he's famous for BEING A UNITED STATES SENATOR. You know, there's only 100 of those at a time. Small potatoes, obviously. What a jerk, right?
About Dick Polman

Cited by the Columbia Journalism Review as one of the nation's top political reporters, and lauded by the ABC News political website as "one of the finest political journalists of his generation," Dick Polman is a national political columnist at the Philadelphia Inquirer. He is on the full-time faculty at the University of Pennsylvania, as "writer in residence." Dick has been a frequent guest on C-Span, MSNBC, CNN, NPR and the BBC. He covered the 1992, 1996, 2000, and 2004 presidential campaigns.

ARCHIVES

All commentaries posted before April 18, 2008, can be accessed at www.dickpolman.blogspot.com.