Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH
share
email
font size
options
 
Thursday, May 29, 2008

 

Barack Obama might be well advised to curb his occasional impulse for telling tall tales, lest the Republicans seize the opportunity to paint him as Pinocchio.

They've proved themselves quite adept at undermining their opponents' credibility. Al Gore, of course, was Exhibit A. He had sought to pad his resume on a number of occasions - by boasting that he was a top speechwriter for Hubert Humphrey in 1968 (he wasn't), by claiming that he came under enemy fire in Vietnam (he didn't), by insisting that he fought the tobacco companies after his sister died of lung cancer (he didn't) - and the GOP wove those incidents (and a few others, plus some that the GOP concocted) into a broad narrative about how Gore was a serial fabulist who could not be trusted with the presidency.

Obama risks serving up the same kind of ammunition. He has already provided several examples. Earlier this week, for instance, he remarked about how he "had an uncle who was one of the, um, who was part of the first American troops to go into Auschwitz and liberate the concentration camp" - when, in fact, Auschwitz, in southern Poland, was liberated by the Soviets in January 1945, at a time when the American troops were 1000 miles away. Obama was apparently referring to a great-uncle on his mother's side who helped liberate Ohrdruf, a camp within the complex known as Buchenwald, in the German region known as Lower Saxony, three months later. So: a misidentified relative, wrong time frame, and wrong geography.

And speaking of the wrong time frame, here's what Obama said in Selma, Alabama back in March, when he was trying to voice his solidarity with the famous Selma march for civil rights: "If it hadn't been for Selma, I wouldn't be here." He was referring to his parents, who marched in that event. He further explained: "So they got together, and Barack Obama Jr. was born. So don't tell me I don't have a claim on Selma, Alabama." But, actually, he has no such claim. He was born in 1961. The Selma march was staged in 1965.

Another time-frame problem surfaced a few months ago, when Obama sought to voice his solidarity with the Kennedys. He declared that he owed his "very existence" to the famous family, because, in his telling, the Kennedys provided the student scholarship money that enabled his future dad to visit America in 1959 and thus meet his future mom. The only problem with that yarn, as it turned out, was that the Kennedys' involvement with the scholarship program, which involved the airlifting of Kenyan students, did not begin until 1960 at the earliest.

Obama fans might deem these incidents to be trivial, but Obama has also fiddled with facts while discussing the people's business. Back in January, he intimated that, as a senator, he led the charge for a new law that compels nuclear plants to disclose low-level radioactive leaks. He said, "(T)he only nuclear legislation that I've passed has been to make sure that the nuclear industry has to disclose whatever they emit anything that might be considered radioactive, and share that with local and state communities. I just did that last year." But, in reality, that legislation did not pass. It got out of committee, but it was killed by the full Senate.

It is hardly unusual, of course, for politicians to pound their chests without empirical justification. Ronald Reagan used to tell world leaders that he witnessed the liberation of the Nazi concentration camps when, in reality, he saw it only on celluloid. Bill Clinton claimed to have "vivid and painful memories of black churches being burned in my own state when I was a child," whereas, in truth, Arkansas historians have said that the total number of burned black churches was exactly zero. And then there is my own personal favorite: the late-'90s claim by New Jersey Democratic Senator Bob Torricelli about how the 1951 Kefauver probe of organized crime was the "first hearing of the Senate I ever witnessed" - which suggests that Torricelli must have possessed superhuman cognitive skills, given the fact that, when the Kefauver probe concluded, he was a mere five days old.

Politicians behave this way for a variety of reasons - to better bond with the audience of the moment, to correct for their own perceived insecurities - and Obama is probably no different in this regard. Indeed, there have been other incidents, including his claim that as a child he became fluent in the Indonesian language within six months (a boast that has been contradicted by his first-grade teacher.) If Obama persists in this fashion, he runs the real risk of being Gored during an autumn election season that might leave him little margin for error. 

Posted by Dick Polman @ 10:48 AM  Permalink | 24 comments
Comments   
Posted 12:04 PM, 05/29/2008
CB
Thanks Dick for the honesty, it might keep you a journalist rather than just another blogger.
Posted 12:07 PM, 05/29/2008
yobill626
I couldn't agree more --- especially for someone who is trying to hang his hat on the perception that he is a politician conducting his campaign on the high road. Saying you're going to take & stick to that high road locks you in to more than simply not putting out purposely misleading or incendiary information. This the Progressives' version of the Family Values position. That is why guys like Larry Craig & Mark Foley got hammered. You can't tell everyone for years that you are "pure as the driven snow" & then get caught looking like yellow ssnow. That's the difference between Hillary & him. When she gets caught lying, almost no one notices --- but she hasn't put herself on that limb. However, if Obama keeps this up, he'll eventually get bit in the butt by a real whopper. As it has with the Family Values guys not acting in a family way, it will be deadly to his Better Way Campaign.
Posted 01:37 PM, 05/29/2008
JeffA
Yes, yes, yes and McCain was happily touring marketplaces in Bagdad without a security worry in the world, and Clinton was landing in Bosnia under sniper fire. We know they lie. It's too bad Obama supporters have to wake up from their fantasy world and realize he's not the messiah because it's so warm and fuzzy inside of a cotton candy machine.
Posted 01:38 PM, 05/29/2008
Sweatheart
At least he's not in the family values party and calling his wife a trollop and a "c*$t."
Posted 01:49 PM, 05/29/2008
JeffA
If anyone is interested, watch this 8 minute video: http://www.cnbc.com/id/15840232?video=755108158 Someone actually suggesting that the Federal Reserve's printing of fiat currency is hurting America and questions the US government's own inflation statistics. Embrace those who question the truth, fear those who know it.
Posted 02:00 PM, 05/29/2008
jack russell
it sounds like buyer's remorse,you've been the lapdog for the wrong candidate.
Posted 02:27 PM, 05/29/2008
JeffA
Jack: to whom r u directing your comment? If it's me, I will say I was backing Ron Paul in January. Then the wheels about came off with the newsletter fiasco. However, some of his messages still resonate.
Posted 02:29 PM, 05/29/2008
JeffA
sweetheart - just the reason to vote for one candidate over another. Let's not discuss policy and steering this ship another direction. Let's keep it focused on who keeps the worst company and who we'd most like to invite for dinner.
Posted 02:37 PM, 05/29/2008
JourneyHome
Obama could literally (not just have the RNC say he said it)but literally on prime time T.V. say he invented the internet - stormed San Juan Hill and is able to leap tall buildings in a single bound. The American people are so pissed off at the big lies told by this administration - the outing of CIA agents, warrant-less wire tapping, the politicizing of the Justice Department, NEW ORLEANS, the total and utter failure of the economy under Bush's watch - the gouging and price fixing at the gas pumps as a pre-text for the drill anywhere profiteering (resulting in zero net gain at the pump for us), the lone gunman disgruntled ex-employee assault on the former esteemed press secretary who apparently grew a conscience - the lack of any foresight or real initiative into alternative fuels, energy sources or transportation alternatives, the roll back of environmental laws, WALTER REED, the rotten tax laws that favor the inner circle at the white house and no one else,Harriet Myers, Browny, Scooter Libby, Dick Cheney's drunken assault with a deadly weapon, the burning of the records in the Eisenhower suite, our lousy health care system, the complete decay and inactivity on the education front, and the total abject failure of anything other than making themselves rich that Obama will be elected in a landslide the biggest this country has ever seen - not to mention the complete overhaul of Congress - it's going to be blue, blue, blue across the board. But things won't change if the voters just disengage as usual after their trip to the polls. If democracy is going to work you have to pick up the phone and call your congressman and be involved on a daily basis - carping on a blog won't get it done - email your representatives, vote your wallet and lets get these payroll taxes rolled back.
Posted 02:43 PM, 05/29/2008
what is truth?
Sorry, but while some of these are certainly problematical, getting which camp was liberated wrong is truly making something out of nothing. That sounds exactly like the type of thing that is handed down in a family and gets a bit mis-transferred along the way. In my own family somewhere along the line it got mixed up that one of my ancestors came from a certain county of Ireland. Then one of my relatives did the research and found it was another county. The fact is he had an uncle who helped served in WW II and helped liberate a concentrsation camp. And really, how many of us refer to our great-unlces just as "uncle"? I would tend to say 99.9%. Misrepresenting legislation passed is one thing, but this other type of meaningless "gotcha" makes political reporting absurd.
Posted 02:50 PM, 05/29/2008
JourneyHome
The American public is so disgusted with the big lies told on a daily basis by this administration, and the overall state of the union Obama could say he stormed San Juan Hill and get elected...the latest spin the disgruntled lone gunman theory out to damage the former esteemed press secretary is just the latest in a pathetic string of atrocities...
Posted 03:15 PM, 05/29/2008
CB
Unfortunately, What is Truth, you and I are not running for President. Supposedly our candidates should be held to a higher standard, and therefore should fact check before inserting foot.
Posted 03:15 PM, 05/29/2008
realsister
I wouldn't have been so polite about it, were I writing the article. Obama is a liar. He has proven that over and over again (remember what he used to say about Rev Wright? Remember what he said about Tony Rezko?). Listening to him, you would think he actually has accomplished something, when in fact, his political career is markedly undistinguished. Listening to him, you would think "Change" and "hope" are actually commodities that he can bring to us, when in fact they are clever political words designed to obfuscate the fact that the man has nothing to offer but empty words. We could have had Hillary and put a Democrat in the White House. Thanks to the sexism of the media and the public, we're likely to have 4 more years of Republican disaster.
Posted 03:53 PM, 05/29/2008
Grill
How about when he said we must get the special interests out of politics and then chanted "SEIU in the house" in his speech in Houston, TX. It was not as if SEIU did not spend over 2.5 million dollars supporting him in his race in Texas or anything. No that could not have happened because we all know Obama does not welcome support from special interest groups, right... Obama equals phony.
Comment removed.
About Dick Polman

Cited by the Columbia Journalism Review as one of the nation's top political reporters, and lauded by the ABC News political website as "one of the finest political journalists of his generation," Dick Polman is a national political columnist at the Philadelphia Inquirer. He is on the full-time faculty at the University of Pennsylvania, as "writer in residence." Dick has been a frequent guest on C-Span, MSNBC, CNN, NPR and the BBC. He covered the 1992, 1996, 2000, and 2004 presidential campaigns.

ARCHIVES

All commentaries posted before April 18, 2008, can be accessed at www.dickpolman.blogspot.com.