Monday, July 28, 2014
Inquirer Daily News

Let he who is without sin cast the first stone....

Let he who is without sin cast the first stone....

Let he who is without sin cast the first stone....

In this June 23, 2011 file photo, then-CIA Director-desigate Gen. David Petraeus testifies on Capitol Hill in Washington. Petraeus has resigned because of an extramarital affair.  (AP Photo/Cliff Owen, File)
In this June 23, 2011 file photo, then-CIA Director-desigate Gen. David Petraeus testifies on Capitol Hill in Washington. Petraeus has resigned because of an extramarital affair. (AP Photo/Cliff Owen, File) AP

       Let he who is without sin cast the first stone....

       Cairo. The sudden resignation of David Petraeus as CIA director over an affair makes me very sad, and quite angry.  There's something wrong with a political system that destroys men of his talent over a very human mistake.

        Yes, I know he showed bad judgment and may have considered it a matter of honor to step down.  But I think his resignation should have been rejected.  Can our system really afford to lose him and upend the CIA, yet again, over such a peccadillo?  Do we really have such talent to spare?     

         Petraeus was not accused of any security breach, and – as the whole world now knows - the affair was discovered only tangentially through another FBI investigation.  This is now an unfortunate situation he must resolve with his wife.  But why, at a time when the CIA is crucial in anti-terrorism operations,  and Petraeus so knowledgeable on Afghanistan, Pakistan, Africa and the Middle East, should the country lose his skills because of a personal matter?

         Watching from Cairo,  where guns and jihadis are passing trough from next door Libya and making the Sinai into a new terrorist nexis, I wonder how Petraeus' exit will affect the efforts to curb this problem? Or to deal with the influx of jihadis into Syria, or drone attacks in Pakistan, etc. etc.  

         Who can be surprised that, having served multiple tours in Iraq and Afghanistan over the past decade, under incredible pressure, this disciplined general might have slipped up?  Had he compromised security it would be one thing.  But if not, why should the whole country pay the price for his marital sin?

         The perils of false purity became clear during the impeachment proceedings against President Clinton.  Supposedly that mess was precipitated because he lied, but in reality it was a political vendetta.  It backfired when many of the legislators who decried the president’s immorality were revealed to have committed similar or worse acts in private. 

         Shouldn’t we have learned to be wary of penalizing our leaders for sins of the flesh?

         News reports say the Director of National Intelligence James R. Clapper asked Petraeus to resign, and he agreed.  I don’t know the details. But I do know that even those who criticized Petraeus as overly ambitious  recognize the sacrifices he made for his country.  My many trips to  Iraq left no doubt in my mind that the counterinsurgency strategy he promoted there prevented an even more grisly civil war, and ended the heaviest fighting.  In Afghanistan, he did the best possible with the hand he was dealt.

         Stephen Kinzer has an op-ed in the N.Y. Times Saturday detailing the serial affairs of Allen Dulles, CIA chief from 1953-1961, in the pre-internet days when such behavior wasn’t reported.    Dulles’ compulsive womanizing probably did jeopardize his work, unlike Petraeus’ folly.  But reading this piece made me yearn for the days when national leaders were judged on performance, and their private lives remained just that.

Trudy Rubin Inquirer Opinion Columnist
About this blog

Trudy Rubin’s Worldview column runs on Thursdays and Sundays. In 2009-2011 she has made four lengthy trips to Afghanistan and Pakistan. Over the past seven years, she visited Iraq eleven times, and also wrote from Iran, Israel, the West Bank, Gaza, Egypt, Syria, Lebanon, Turkey, China, and South Korea.

She is the author of Willful Blindness: the Bush Administration and Iraq, a book of her columns from 2002-2004. In 2001 she was a finalist for the Pulitzer Prize in commentary and in 2008 she was awarded the Edward Weintal prize for international reporting. In 2010 she won the Arthur Ross award for international commentary from the Academy of American Diplomacy.

Reach Trudy at trubin@phillynews.com.

Trudy Rubin Inquirer Opinion Columnist
Also on Philly.com
Stay Connected