Oh my: God doc includes all faiths, no insights
These questions have inspired theologians, philosophers, poets, and artists to create some of the world's greatest cultural treasures.
Sadly, they also have led more malicious minds - usually those convinced they had all the right answers - to conceive some of history's most horrific forms of oppression.
Oh My God?, a lavishly shot documentary which poses those questions to scores of average Joe and Jane Q. Publics around the globe and a few B-list celebrities, is anything but a treasure.
But it's not pernicious either.
It's simply banal.
Oh My God? is the brainchild of Brit Peter Rodger, a commercial photographer and adman-turned-filmmaker who has an undeniable talent for producing ravishing images. He shot the film over 21/2 years in 23 countries, including the United States, Tibet, Australia, Israel, Bali, Japan, the Vatican, and parts of Africa.
The film begins with promise. Following a gorgeous montage of landscapes, we are treated to controversial one-liners.
"To kill a homosexual is a good action in the sight of god," says a fundamentalist Muslim.
An American Christian says, "I'm convinced that calling God Allah is blasphemy."
Viewers expecting a stimulating theological smackdown will be disappointed. So will anyone expecting any intellectual stimulation.
As a piece of raw journalism, it is thorough: It would be hard to find a faith, creed, religion, major or minor, that is not somehow represented or referenced. But that is part of the problem: The film seems to be little more than a list of contradicting statements.
As pretty as it is to look at, and comprehensive as it is, God? remains a flaccid, directionless mishmash of views that are given little, if any, intellectual analysis.
Then there are the sagacious celebs: Hugh Jackman, David Copperfield, Ringo Starr, and a few lesser-known entertainment industry insiders add little to the conversation. Rodger has said he wanted to include celebs to "help navigate us through" the material. One wonders whether a qualified historian or theologian wouldn't have served better.
In a sense, Oh My God? is the ultimate TV ad: Slick, and exquisitely constructed, it sells religious diversity a la United Colors of Benetton.
Rodger's conclusion boils down to a few empty truisms: There are lots of different beliefs around the world. To take them too seriously leads to fundamentalism and that's bad.
But faith, mixed in with a good dose of multicultural toleration, is groovy.
As Ringo sums it up, "God is love."
Right on!
Oh My God? *½ (out of four stars)
Directed by Peter Rodger. With Bob Geldof, Hugh Jackman, Baz Luhrmann, David Copperfield, Ringo Starr.
Running time: 1 hour, 38 mins
Parent's guide: Not rated (mature themes, profanity, confused theology)
Playing at: Ritz at the Bourse
Contact staff writer Tirdad Derakhshani at 215-854-2736 or tirdad@phillynews.com.




