Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH  

Sports   

share
email
print
reprint
font size
options
 
YONG KIM / Staff Photographer
Donovan McNabb, who has no Super Bowl ring to secure his legacy, passes under pressure from the Cowboys' Anthony Spencer.
1 of 2
READER FEEDBACK
Will Donovan McNabb win a Super Bowl in Philadelphia?


Gonzo: Close to not close enough

You knew it was coming. When the Yankees won the World Series, every sports fan with half a functioning brain cell braced for the inevitable, saccharine SportsCenter packages.

If you missed them, here's the general gist: Alex Rodriguez is a winner now. Hooray. Let's forget how shady he's always been and celebrate his championship awesomeness.

It's amazing how one title can erase so many mistakes - with steroids and centaurs and especially Madonna. Somewhere, Dan Marino, John Stockton, Patrick Ewing, and other great players who never won championships in their sports weep quietly into their beers - or, in Marino's case, something carb-friendly from NutriSystem. They're all members of the Charles Barkley Close But Not Close Enough Club. Call it the CBCBNCEC for short(er). (I really have to work on my unwieldy acronyms - among other things.)

While I was watching Donovan McNabb and the Birds last night, it occurred to me - not for the first time - that regular-season losses to Dallas always sting, but they don't mean much when evaluating a player's career. Championships trump everything, even falling to the 'Boys. If McNabb finally delivers a parade to Philly, that's what people will remember - just as no one will ever forget it if he ultimately fails in that quest.

Nobody wants to end up as just another guy with gaudy individual numbers but no flashy jewelry on his finger(s). There's a group of talented but titleless players out there who are currently on the CBCBNCEC watch list. To be considered, they have to have serious stats and stature and be older than 30 (which is why you won't find LeBron James below; too soon).

Here, then, are the top five candidates to be inducted into the CBCBNCEC if things don't change:

1. Donovan McNabb: He holds franchise records for attempts, completions, completion percentage, yards, quarterback rating, TDs, and media scrutiny. Among active signal-callers, only Brett Favre, Peyton Manning, and Tom Brady have thrown more touchdown passes. And yet Five is rarely mentioned with those three. (You get one guess why.) If he wins a Super Bowl, though, get ready for teary, A-Rodesque tributes.

2. Allen Iverson: He's one of the best players of his era, not to mention one of the greatest small men to ever dribble a ball. Something tells me he's not winning a championship while "playing" (defined here as sulking in his off-season home in Atlanta) for the Grizzlies. Just a hunch.

3. Ken Griffey Jr.: Despite being fifth on the all-time home run list and inspiring a generation of kids to wear their hats backward, Junior has never played in a World Series. A guy who performed so well during his guest turn on The Simpsons deserves better.

4. Terrell Owens: Among active receivers, he's tied for first in career touchdowns and second in receptions and yards. That's nice, but can we make a sports rule, please? From now on, you have to win something significant before you get a reality show. I feel like that would solve a lot of society's problems. At this point, Owens has a better shot of winning an Emmy than a Super Bowl. That's terribly twisted.

5. Randy Moss: He's tied for first among active receivers in touchdowns, and he's third in yards and fifth in receptions. He also has arguably the best shot to get off this list. If David Tyree hadn't caught that crazy pass off his noggin in Super Bowl XLII, someone else would almost certainly be in this spot. But then they don't call it the CBCBNCEC for nothing.

Bigger plastic surgery mistake: Sammy Sosa or Jerry Jones? (Forget Michael Jackson. Too easy.) . . . All three members of Team Talkin' picked the Birds to win, as did all seven prognosticators from our sister paper. You can't get 10 Philly sportswriters to agree on which bar to visit. No wonder the 'Boys won - bad juju. . . . The Fox pregame show panelists were asked yesterday to predict the Super Bowl winner. Jimmy Johnson didn't hesitate, howling into the camera, "How 'bout them Cowboys!" Remember the old educational, wheel-shaped children's toy with all the barnyard animals on it? You'd pull the string and the arrow would spin and stop on an animal, which would then make a noise. The cow says moooo. And so on. The cow always said moooo. Jimmy Johnson is a lot like the cow, only with better hair.

 


Contact columnist John Gonzalez at 215-854-2813 or gonzalez@phillynews.com.

 

Comments   
Posted 07:04 AM, 11/09/2009
Gino D.
Horrible game. Dumb column. Sinking "news"paper.
Posted 07:56 AM, 11/09/2009
eaglephanatic
"If McNabb finally delivers a parade to Philly..." Never will, in any town, unless he is on the sideline holding a clipboard as a backup.
Posted 08:56 AM, 11/09/2009
Theo1980
McNabb is going into the smiles hall of fame.
Posted 08:59 AM, 11/09/2009
bag853
Sure, McNabb will win a superbowl in Philly...PSYCHE!!! It'snot his fault, though. The management eff'd around for too many years and waited too long to learn how to bring real, young talent to the team. By the time our new "weapons" fully develop into a super bowl worthy group, Kolb will be the quarterback and he will get the super bowl ring. Again, not McNabb's fault.
Comment removed.
Posted 10:09 AM, 11/09/2009
Shimmy
McNabb looks borderline obese. Time to make changes. A couple of steps back before we move forward.
Posted 10:21 AM, 11/09/2009
phasor
The Eagles looked like the Lions in the second half. McNabb does not create momentum. He can feed off momentum but he's not the game changer that he was 5 years ago. McNabb will not deliver a Superbowl with Andy Reid. He's not the quarterback that Reid wants him to be and Reid doesn't pick up on Donavan's strength and instead trys to force him into something he's not.
Posted 10:42 AM, 11/09/2009
bigcityballer
The short answer is F**k NO. I think phasor said it best. This is the most frustrating team in the NFL. Only way McNabb is part of a championship parade in Philly is if the Phillies invite him next season. It's time for Jeff to cut bait with both McNabb and Reid. 11 years of almost. If you are truly interested in winning the Super Bowl it is time to demand more from you coaches and your star QB. Oh, I love Jackson energy but stop with the insipid end zone celebrations. They have spread to your teammates. The Capt Morgan pose? If you need help hoisting your leg - don't do it. Even the worse mutt can lift his own damn leg.
Posted 11:39 AM, 11/09/2009
thingfish
you missed one....Andy McPig
Posted 12:11 PM, 11/09/2009
flyersfannj
Eagles are trying to bore a ten-foot hole (Super Bowl) with an eight-foot drill (McNabb). He will get you close, but will NEVER get you there. Time to get rid of this "tool".
Posted 12:18 PM, 11/09/2009
Zeru77
I dont think Mcnabb is ever going to change back to young quick read mcnabb. Lets just go with Kolb.
Posted 12:24 PM, 11/09/2009
cheesefry
D-nabb is a solid QB but not a champion. Westbrook is done, the O-line is average at best...the Eagles will just miss the playoffs and start the slow sink until the next era begins.
Posted 12:24 PM, 11/09/2009
mattscards
Boy, Those Cowboys sure did look good. The Eagles were whining about a bad spot but they shouldn't have needed someone's help and decision to win the game. It is still early but Dallas is clearly the class of the NFC East.
Posted 12:28 PM, 11/09/2009
JamaicanEagles
Every team in the NFL had there first 15 plays scripted excepted for the Eagles. Andy Ready scrip is, lets go deep on the first play and if that doesn’t work lets run the ball for two yard on second then third and 8yrds lets run a 4yard out. That’s called the McAandy drive. When will Mcnabb stop laughing when he made a bad play? Is it because he just isn’t the competitor that we need at QB to get us to the supper bowl? He is one of the worst QB on third and forth down conversion in the history of the game. If the Defense doesn’t make big plays to put this offence in position to win they can’t do it alone. Example Oakland Raiders game.
Posted 12:33 PM, 11/09/2009
WewantaSBRing
What a bunch of Morons posting today, see you next week after we beat SD.