Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH  

Sports   

share
email
print
reprint
font size
options
 
Ryan Howard takes a big cut but produces only a grounder in the eighth. He wound up reaching first on an error, then scored on Jayson Werth's home run.
1 of 179
RELATED STORIES
 
Phillies Zone: Charlie wants an infielder
 
High Cheese: Game 2 lineups and more
 
The Idle Rich: Phillies' bullpen machinations
 
Gonzo: Win over Rockies a measure of sweet revenge
 
Bob Ford: Cliff Lee savors precious moment
 
Sam Donnellon: A second wind from Werth
 
Bill Conlin: Phils weather elements with gusto
 
Phil Sheridan: Just wind, baby: Phils take on elements
 
Paul Hagen: Phillies’ hitters outwork Jimenez
 
Rich Hofmann: Lee lets Phillies breathe a big Cy of relief
 
You Talkin' To Me?: Shining a light on daytime baseball
 
Broad Street Billy: In the stands, colorful fans, and gusts that’ll blow your beer away
 
1:30 p.m: Game 2 pregame chat with Marcus Hayes
 
2:30 p.m.: Rockies-Phillies Game 2 live chat
 
The Phillies Zone: The Inquirer's Phillies blog
 
High Cheese: The Daily News' Phillies blog
Special sections
Photos: 2009 Phillies season
 
Download: Phillies wallpapers for your computer desktop
 
From the archives: 2008 World Series coverage
 
Philly.com's Phillies section
 
Lee strong to the finish in Phillies' Game 1 win over Rockies
 
At windy Bank, field level was calmest place
 
Phillies fans find a way to see game
 
Strong start rapidly goes wrong for Rockies' Jimenez
 
Pitching, timely hitting key for Phils in opener
 
Ibanez looks like his old self
 
For Phils' Werth, Game 1 was a day of adventure
 
Rockies: Lee was masterful in Game 1
 
Rockies meet Cliff (Lee)
 
Phillies Notes: Phillies' Hamels annoyed by day start times
 
Phillies Notebook: For Phillies, no question about Ibanez' health this time
 
Rockies' Jimenez disappointed outing came up short
 
Sun blamed for TV disruption
 
Phillies-Rockies talking points
 
Phillies-Rockies: Who's hot, who's not
 
Phillies-Rockies Game 2 preview
 
Phillies-Rockies Game 2 agenda
 
Cook, Hamels take different routes to Game 2 start
 
Hamels says short rest would be no big deal
 
Spotlight on ... Scott Eyre
 
Wachovia Center invites Phillies fans
 
Dodgers knock off Cardinals, 5-3
 
Dodgers win Game 1 over Cardinals
 
Dodgers solve Carpenter, take Game 1
 
Card starter's been here; LA's just got here
 
Yankees get jump on Twins
 
Yankees follow Jeter to victory over Twins
 
Both teams downplay Bosox' hold on Angels
 
Cops: Ex-Phil Powell's death was suicide
 
Throwing it back: Howard homer returned
 
Fan gets Howard homer ball back
 
Baseball Notes: 'Shame on us,' Tigers' Leyland says of his team's collapse
 
Tribe GM eyes candidates
 
Buy Phillies jerseys, playoff t-shirts, hats, and more
 
Purchase Phillies playoff photos & reprints
Photos: 2009 Phillies
 
Relive the memories: Coverage of the World Series run


Throwing it back: Howard homer returned

The family of a Florida girl, 12, sued over a milestone baseball.

The island of Manhattan for $24 worth of trinkets it was not, but a Florida family was crying foul over a deal the Phillies made with their daughter in exchange for a Ryan Howard home run baseball.

And as is often the case these days, lawyers became involved.

The tale begins with Howard's 200th career home run July 17 in a game against the Florida Marlins. The ball sailed into the outfield seats at Land Shark Stadium, where it was picked up by a 12-year-old girl, Jennifer Valdivia.

That homer made Howard the player in Major League history who got to 200 the fastest - and the tale ends with Jennifer in possession of the ball again.

In between? Valdivia gave the ball up for Howard to keep - before her family hired an attorney, Norm Kent of Fort Lauderdale, Fla, who filed a lawsuit Monday against the Phillies and Howard for in "excess of $15,000."

The next day, Jennifer got the baseball back.

"I have it, finally," Jennifer told the Miami Herald after it was returned.

Kent said Valdivia was at the Phillies-Marlins game with her 15-year-old brother when Howard hit his home run. Valdivia grabbed it, and "within minutes" a Marlins employee escorted her and her brother to see an unidentified Phillies employee.

"In a classic bait-and-switch operation, the defendant Phillies tendered to young Jennifer a signed Ryan Howard baseball, which has a value on the memorabilia market of $150," the suit said, "as compared to the historic baseball, which is worth thousands."

She also got some cotton candy.

Kent said Valdivia also was told to come back after the game to meet Howard. However, the game went into extra innings, and she never did get to meet the Phillies slugger.

Kent said he quickly told Phillies attorneys he wanted the ball returned before the season ended or he would file suit. The initial counter offer, the suit said, was for tickets to a Phillies-Marlins game.

The regular season ended Sunday, then Kent filed suit Monday, which got the prompt response and the return of the ball. From the Phillies' end, spokesperson Bonnie Clark said yesterday that the team would have no comment.

"I'm starting to get some nasty e-mails that we're extorting Ryan Howard," Kent said. "I don't think Ryan Howard even knew what happened."

Despite the ball's value, the attorney said, "The ball is not on eBay. It's under her pillow."


Contact staff writer Mike Jensen

at 215-854-4489 or mjensen@phillynews.com