Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH  

Opinion   

share
email
print
reprint
font size
options
 
READER FEEDBACK
Post a comment


Editorial: Tackling hate crimes

President Obama gave wary gay-rights activists a reason to celebrate when he signed a milestone federal hate-crime bill.

Long overdue, the legislation expands civil rights-era laws by adding violence against people based on sexual orientation, gender, and disability to the list of hate crimes.

Hate-crime laws passed after the 1968 assassination of the Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. covered crimes based on race, color, religion, or national origin.

But hate-motivated violence has prompted attacks in recent years against other victims who deserve the same protection. The legislation represents what Obama aptly called a "long-awaited change" to protect people from being targeted because of "who they love ... or who they are."

The law was named for Matthew Shepard, a Wyoming college student who was beaten to death in 1998 because he was gay, and for James Byrd Jr., a black Texas man dragged to his death by three white men in a racially motivated killing the same year.

Nationwide, there were more than 77,000 hate crimes reported by the FBI between 1998 and 2007. At least 12,000 attacks were motivated by sexual orientation.

Yet it has taken Congress a decade to change the law, partly because of fierce opposition by then-President George W. Bush, who vowed to veto a similar measure. Democrats got the legislation passed - over the objection of many Republicans - by attaching it to a defense-policy bill.

Some critics said the law could be used to stifle free-speech rights and keep conservatives from speaking out against homosexuality or religious beliefs.

But the law clearly is intended to prosecute those who commit violent acts based on their personal bias - not for what they say, regardless of how distasteful. It includes a provision to ensure that a religious leader or any other person can't be prosecuted on the basis of his or her speech, beliefs, or association.

Most states - except Pennsylvania - have hate-crime statutes that already cover sexual orientation. The law signed by Obama makes federal intervention easier if a state drags its feet in prosecuting such cases.

Its passage should reassure gay-rights activists who were concerned that the Obama administration had put their most pressing issues on a back burner.

Expanding the hate-crime law to combat violence against gays is a welcome step.

Comments   
Posted 09:33 AM, 11/14/2009
Ped1045
Eric Holder is perpetrating the largest hate crime ever. By trying these terrorists in NY, is a show of hate and disrespect to all who perished on 9/11! But of course, all he wants is to degrade the past administration. That is what it is all about. These terrorists committed an act of war. Our military should be trying them, not Holder's bogus prosecuters!
Posted 10:19 PM, 11/14/2009
Philly lawyer
This law will not prevent any violent crime from happening. Any depraved criminal who is prepared to murder or assault another human being will not drop his plan because the president approves new legislation. And hate crimes laws take the government too close to the notion of "thought crimes," because investigators will now have to dig into peoples' lives in order to gather "evidence" to prove the bias element in a court of law. This includes what books and newspapers they read and what websites they visit. That sort of investigative work, in addition to being anathema in a free society, is unnecessary as all violent acts are already against the law. This measure is about identity politics, not crime-fighting. What homosexuals want from the President is to take the lead on abolishing "Don't ask, Don't tell" and to reverse his longstanding (though seldom reported) opposition to gay marriage rights.
Posted 11:33 PM, 11/14/2009
George Tomezsko
"Expanding the hate-crime law to combat violence against gays is a welcome step." Nonsense. Such laws are just the latest expression of touchy-feely liberalism and political correctness run amok. This law will have no practical affect. All those endowed with a common sense understanding of sexuality will continue to speak out despite this latest attempt by the left to silence us. The Culture War has only just begun.
3 comments
  • Top Jobs
  • Top Homes
  • Top Cars
 
SEARCH JOBS
Old City/Society Hill


$1,375,000
210 W WASHINGTON SQ #7SE
Rittenhouse Square


$729,000
202-210 W RITTENHOUSE SQ #2403
SEARCH CARS

Buy Inquirer, Daily News & Philly merchandise here including:

 
Books
 
Movies
 
Page Reprints
 
Photo Licensing
 
Photos