Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH  

Opinion   

share
email
print
reprint
font size
options
 
READER FEEDBACK
Post a comment


Letters: Counselor showed appalling insensitivity

I have been fortunate to know the inestimable value of college mental-health services for my own family and that of others. There is certainly no shame in seeking such help, as your article so wisely points out ("A rise in mental-health help on campus," Monday).

So imagine my shock when I came to the quote from a counselor at La Salle University counseling services: "If you have a parent who is so hyper-concerned that they 'rescue' them, you don't allow them the time that they need to sort of struggle. They're really cheating their child out of their ability to learn to manage their own stress."

Her insensitivity, ignorance, and judgmental attitude are breathtaking in their unprofessionalism, irresponsibility, and lack of insight. Since when is it OK for a clinician to bring her own prejudices - about the parents, the students, or the situation they find themselves in - to the table without any prior knowledge? How many students has she let fall through the cracks because she thought they might be better off to "sort of struggle" before she intervened?

I'd be curious to know what her colleagues at the other schools would have to say about her professional expertise - and I'd certainly think long and hard about sending my child to her college.

Nancy Colman

Philadelphia

Comments   
Posted 06:56 AM, 11/05/2009
happydude
The counselor from La Salle was speaking the truth. Young adults can’t handle everyday stresses because of the overly protective, hyper concerned parents didn’t let them struggle and fail when they were little. Message to parents: stop trying to be your child’s buddy; stop wrapping yourself around your child like bubble wrap, let them experience and deal with life. Society will thank you latter.
Posted 07:23 AM, 11/05/2009
John O
I certainly agree with happydude. When did Americanized young people become so weak and frail that they cannot handle the everyday stress that comes with living. What a generation of weaklings. A recent report by the American military reported that 75% of American young people are both physcially and mentally disqualified from serving in the military. Thats the future of America; a weak whining demanding narcissistic incompetent nation that trains its children to look for help in every conceivable situation and not solve problems by something called inner strength. it is also called the nanny state
Posted 12:15 PM, 11/05/2009
A Friend
That counselor was speaking directly to you, Nancy. You're completely out of touch with reality, darling. I suggest you ask your PCP to prescribe an eighth of medical marijuana. Not only will it help you, but it will aid those who are forced to interact with you.
Posted 01:59 PM, 11/06/2009
brlevinson
Does the LaSalle student health sysytem tell students to "struggle" through sore throats, abdominal pain, or physical injuries rather than providing appropriate care? I doubt it. But unfortunately many people, including happydude, are dismissive of emotional problems, expecting people to "get over it."
Posted 02:19 PM, 11/06/2009
pj katauskas
Being homesick is not a "mental health" problem, nor is struggling with a tough course or two, or dealing with a less-than-perfect roomate. These are the normal challenges of college life that don't require mental health intervention; they require the student to develop some mental and emotional toughness and discipline.
Posted 11:34 AM, 11/07/2009
Ben Dover
alot of lessons learned in life don't come from a book. sometimes you have to let them jump in a puddle to find out they get thier feet wet.
Posted 01:45 PM, 11/10/2009
DelawareLdy
I have to agree with the counselor from LaSalle,today's parents are so busy trying to take care of everything for their children, that they are completely unable to handle anything on their own. the author of the above letter will probably be surprised to know that the counselors opinion is the prevailing opinion at most colleges and universities across the country. These kids can not cope with the basics, like PJ Ktauskas mentioned. I doubt the counselor is saying that she would allow a student to struggle through a real emotional or psychological crisis, being homesick, or not liking your roommate...these are issues that a college student needs to deal with...and yeah they should suck it up and deal with it. Its part of life. Mommy and Daddy cant fix everything and eventually they need to learn that. Somethings you have to handle on your own, its called growing up.
7 comments
  • Top Jobs
  • Top Homes
  • Top Cars
 
SEARCH JOBS
Mount Airy


$450,000
711 SAINT GEORGES ST
Fairmount/Spring Garden


$599,000
646 N SYDENHAM ST
SEARCH CARS

Buy Inquirer, Daily News & Philly merchandise here including:

 
Books
 
Movies
 
Page Reprints
 
Photo Licensing
 
Photos