Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH  

Opinion   

share
email
print
reprint
font size
options
 
SARAH J. GLOVER / Staff Photographer
SARAH J. GLOVER / Staff Photographer
READER FEEDBACK
Post a comment


Editorial: Bus to nowhere

Transit strikes always burden commuters, but the timing of yesterday's walkout by SEPTA employees was especially unfair.

Transport Workers Union Local 234 went on strike at 3 a.m. with virtually no warning to the traveling public. More than 5,000 train operators, bus drivers, and mechanics did not report to work, shutting down all subway, bus, and trolley service in the city and bus lines in some suburbs.

That action left many people who must travel to and from work before dawn without any options. It was a cavalier way to treat loyal customers who depend on SEPTA to get to work or school.

The union had authorized a strike a week ago, but many people went to bed Monday night believing a walkout had been averted. The union had agreed under pressure from Gov. Rendell and other elected leaders not to strike during the World Series. But three hours after Game 5 ended in South Philly, the union walked.

So it was strike three for many working stiffs - a waitress trying to ride the Market-Frankford El to her job at a diner in Old City; hospital workers in Center City trying to get home after an overnight shift; a woman who was stranded on the first day of her new job. It was the same for tens of thousands of other riders like them, many of whom don't earn as much as the average SEPTA employee ($52,000).

The strike began on a federal holiday when city schools were closed. Otherwise, the commuter chaos would have been even worse. But it also came on Election Day, making it more difficult for some people to vote before 8 p.m.

As of late yesterday, there was no word of a settlement, raising the prospect of an uglier commute today.

SEPTA's largest union had been working without a contract since March. Neither Local 234 nor the transit agency should have allowed the impasse to drag on this long. It took the threat of a strike during the nationally televised showcase of the World Series to get negotiators closer to a deal.

As for SEPTA's offer, it hardly seems like the kind of affront that would spark a walkout, especially in these tough economic times. Rendell said SEPTA proposed a $1,250 signing bonus upon ratification, a 2.5-percent raise the second year, and 3-percent raises in each of the next three years. The union is asking for raises of 4 percent annually and improved work rules.

SEPTA also offered to increase pension payments to workers (the union contends SEPTA has chronically underfunded its pension plan), and not to increase employees' health-insurance contributions, now at 1 percent.

To many workers out there, and to a legion of the unemployed, such terms sound like a dream, not a reason to ambush commuters with a citywide shutdown of transportation services. If it hasn't, the union should return to the bargaining table with that in mind.

 

Comments   
Posted 05:00 AM, 11/04/2009
nuffera
Fire them all! They should be ashamed of themselves! They have jobs and healthcare, lots of people would love to have their postions! Greed is the moving factor here.
Posted 06:43 AM, 11/04/2009
Magistra
I support unions and have no problem with improving wages and working conditions, but the failure to warn people is simply dirty play. I wonder how all those who need public transportation to get to life-saving treatments like daily radiation or chemo-therapy made out yesterday. This is more than inconvenience.
Posted 07:49 AM, 11/04/2009
ol cranky
I have no sympathy for union employees. Right now, many of us are sweating out our jobs and are not getting any raises (some are agreeing to pay cuts to keep people employed), & agreeing to decrease in health benefits while picking up more of the cost.
Posted 08:37 AM, 11/04/2009
bill at
And today we get a 'coincidental' fire on a crowded R5 line. Animals. This union is nothing but low-rent, gutter animals. But, it's just another day in Obamanation.
Posted 08:37 AM, 11/04/2009
constantine
Sacrebleu! At least they spared the kids. Is not the goal of a strike to create a significant point? Sudden loss makes for a deeper impact. At least they're not striking like they do in France. In France, the unions purposefully try to obtain even more painful havock by obstructions, diversions, or a mess (i.e. dumping loads of sand, manure, milk, etc.). And when the rail workers and bus drivers go on strike, the taxi cab workers complain that the burden of transportation is shifted to them, and they go on strike, too. If they feel pain, they want you to feel pain, too, albeit a different pain that is relieved by government concessions. N'est-ce pas? Otherwise, these are not the best of financial times in which to strike in... although that never stopped unions either here, in France, or elsewhere. If you pay attention, there are other people going on strike around the area, but SEPTA workers were able to gain media attention. Across the pond, British postal workers just went on strike, although their postal service is no more lucrative or effective than the wonderful postal service here that keeps losing my mail unless I pay more for tracking.
Posted 08:52 AM, 11/04/2009
wec4104
I feel badly for the hardship this is causing for many SEPTA riders. However I truly believe that the union members should be left standing in their picket lines until they recognize their value is not what they think it is. The story above mentions the $52K earnings figure. Compare that to the private sector which typically must contibute a significant amount to their own health care costs. Then consider that most companies have no pension at all and have stopped 401K matching programs. Add on the $1250 signing bonus and potential overtime/holiday pay. Layer on the discussed raises and we are looking at an income equivalent to a $65-70K job in the private sector. ...and these numbskulls aren't happy with that?
Posted 09:23 AM, 11/04/2009
AMC4232
Bill, I fail to see how this strike has anything to do with Obama. Wasn't the last strike, which lasted several weeks, smack in the middle of the Bush administration?
Posted 09:25 AM, 11/04/2009
joedog
The average SEPTA employee is gifted $52,00 per annum. That is outrageous. Privatize these goons.
Posted 10:00 AM, 11/04/2009
johnpsheppard
Wishing SEPTA management had enough guts to really draw a hard line in the sand. They don't. So we will suffer through a strike that in the end still gives the union workers way more of an increase than the rest of us and has us all ultimately paying more for continued mediocrity.
Posted 10:23 AM, 11/04/2009
sewell guy
wec104;If the private sector organized maybe they wouldn't be paying so much for their health coverage and would have a pension plan or is that to hard for you to figure out,moron.Why do these people have these things because they ARE organized.The only reason PRIVATE sector people make what they make is because of unions.The private sector has to compete wage wise otherwise they wouldn't make what they make.EVERONE can thank the union movement for saturday and sunday off,the 8 hour work day,not having to bring work home and continue to work while your on your time with your family,the paid holiday,paid vacation,whatever benefits you do have like health coverage,overtime pay,lunch break,profit sharing and on and on and on.All the while you have CEO's making tens if not hundreds of million of dollars a YEAR but you never say a word about that.Your a fool like most of the others who complain on here because you never take a minute to think what the union movement has done to make this the greatest country in the world and the largest economy still.While your at it don't complain about losing jobs to other countries just look at all the labels on your clothes and sneakers and cheap knockoffs while your driving you toyota and then realize your the problem not the UNIONS.Yes I'm a union guy and I don't buy products made in china and I drive an American made car,cadillac as a matter of fact,and I have never crossed a picket line and never will and you Know what I'm damn proud of it
Posted 10:23 AM, 11/04/2009
sewell guy
wec104;If the private sector organized maybe they wouldn't be paying so much for their health coverage and would have a pension plan or is that to hard for you to figure out,moron.Why do these people have these things because they ARE organized.The only reason PRIVATE sector people make what they make is because of unions.The private sector has to compete wage wise otherwise they wouldn't make what they make.EVERONE can thank the union movement for saturday and sunday off,the 8 hour work day,not having to bring work home and continue to work while your on your time with your family,the paid holiday,paid vacation,whatever benefits you do have like health coverage,overtime pay,lunch break,profit sharing and on and on and on.All the while you have CEO's making tens if not hundreds of million of dollars a YEAR but you never say a word about that.Your a fool like most of the others who complain on here because you never take a minute to think what the union movement has done to make this the greatest country in the world and the largest economy still.While your at it don't complain about losing jobs to other countries just look at all the labels on your clothes and sneakers and cheap knockoffs while your driving you toyota and then realize your the problem not the UNIONS.Yes I'm a union guy and I don't buy products made in china and I drive an American made car,cadillac as a matter of fact,and I have never crossed a picket line and never will and you Know what I'm damn proud of it
Posted 11:52 AM, 11/04/2009
Captain Splendor
sewell guy, thanks for the history lesson, but the 1910's are over. Federal and state governments have now made law of a lot of the protections uinions fought for. While they made life better for the working man, they are nothing more than greedy, self serving, free loaders now.
Posted 12:20 PM, 11/04/2009
fedupphilly
Blame the union heads most of the Septa workers do not want to be on strike without pay. Most want to be at work. This is the union making the demands and if you work for Septa you have no choice but to join the union.
Posted 12:22 PM, 11/04/2009
cool guy
sewell, you make a good case for unions, but the charge against unions is exemplified in this situation. can you say that Septa's offer should be turned down in this economic climate? Unions today can be a liability to our economy, as we see now. Seems like the TWU messed up on this one.
Posted 12:32 PM, 11/04/2009
A Friend
I think unions are a great option for simpleton's who can't manage to find and keep a job on their own. If you have minimal intelligence, drive and determination to be successful - get a union job. Go Pedro!
  • Top Jobs
  • Top Homes
  • Top Cars
 
SEARCH JOBS
Graduate Hospital/Ave. of the Arts


$816,900
1810 KATER ST
Huntingdon Valley


$529,900
80 STEVEN DR
SEARCH CARS

Buy Inquirer, Daily News & Philly merchandise here including:

 
Books
 
Movies
 
Page Reprints
 
Photo Licensing
 
Photos