Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH  

Opinion   

share
email
print
font size
options
 
PAUL LACHINE
PAUL LACHINE
READER FEEDBACK
Post a comment


Commentary

A little adult vigilance might save a child's life

Others can be spared the fate of Charlenni Ferreira.

The recent coverage of the abuse and death of Charlenni Ferreira brought back vivid memories for me.

As the fourth child in my family, I was 5 years old when my mother put me in charge of my 2-year-old brother, Herby. If Herby cried too loudly when he didn't get his way, I was whipped. As I ducked and dodged the sting of a red rubber tube, my mother would yell, "I told you to keep him quiet!"

If Herby wouldn't take a nap, I got another whipping. "Didn't I tell you to make him go to sleep?" And always a frightening warning: "And don't you ever let it happen again."

I have clear memories of my patting Herby on his back until his eyes closed and his breathing became even, then gently removing my hand and holding my breath as I tiptoed from the room.

When he was 5 years old and I was 8, I had to take Herby to kindergarten at our school around the corner. He hated it, and sometimes, when the teacher wasn't looking, he would escape and run the two blocks back home. When I came home for lunch, Mom would be waiting for me behind the vestibule door with the rubber tube in her hand. Holding me by the arm, her beady eyes flashing, she would beat me and scream, "Didn't I tell you not to let Herby leave school?"

Once, while she was whipping me, I finally got up the courage to sob, "But, Mom, he was the one who came back home. Why don't you whip him?" Her response was, "I don't see him now, but I'll get to him later." Herby was standing right there, laughing.

One afternoon, after I tearfully returned to school without any lunch, my third-grade teacher noticed the swollen welts and old scars on my arms and legs, and sent a note to my mother. The whippings stopped.

Many years later, I found that note in a buffet drawer, and I still have it. This is what it says:

Dear Mrs. Love:

You have a darling little girl. Be kind to her. And one day you will be proud of her.

Throughout our adulthoods, I felt the responsibility to continue to look after Herby - not because I had to, but because I loved him. Eventually, because my three older siblings were unavailable to do so, I became the caretaker for my mother and my brother.

In 1978, their health quickly declined at the same time. Full of anger and alcohol, Herby died at the age of 49. Mom died five weeks later. I put his urn in her casket and buried them together.

In 2007, at the age of 81, I graduated from Chestnut Hill College with a master's degree in marriage and family therapy. As the oldest graduate in the history of the school, I received a standing ovation.

Teachers, friends, neighbors, keep watch. All manner of abuse happens in secret, even in "good" families such as mine - two working parents, nice home, well respected in the community.

One of you might save a life. I was blessed to have a teacher who saved mine.

 


Jean Love Robinson lives in Philadelphia.

Comments   
Posted 12:28 PM, 11/02/2009
DonQ
We teach a variety of skills to our children in school simply because we know that they will need them to succeed in life. Why not teach parenting skills? Case in point - My wife's friend's daughter (age 18) had a baby three weeks ago. We went to the hospital to drive her and her baby home. The father is uninvolved, so she went home to live with her mother. In the car, the baby started to cry. Her reaction was - "She's being bad. I'll have to teach her." My wife stopped the car, turned around and told her that if she intended to discipline a week-old baby for crying, she better give her up for adoption. She saw the strong possibility of that girl abusing her baby out of ignorance. A new life is a delicate thing. All it takes is a strong shake, and that baby will be dead or disabled for life.
Posted 01:10 PM, 11/02/2009
johanna
Ms. Robinson. You are a forgiving soul. May God continune to bless you abundantly!
Posted 04:50 PM, 11/02/2009
Magistra
DonQ - Yes, it is important to teach "parenting" skills, but of course, the best teacher is the young mother's own parents. Ms Robinson, bless her, was so fortunate that a wise teacher's non-judgmental and loving comment to her mother ended up saving her life in more ways than one. I think it is highly ironic that the brother whose behavior was ignored turned out to be the weak one. And, Don, kudos to your wife for trying to educate that young and very stupid mom. Babies are often brutalized just for being babies who cry for food, affection, a change of diapers or just to exercise their lungs. I wonder how many babies are punished for dropping things from a high chair when the child's brain is actually wired to do such activity to learn about depth perception? How many babies are smacked because they are not ready for toilet training or drinking from a cup or talking? I am so in favor of early childhood education where both mother and child receive training. It may save lives.
Posted 06:26 PM, 11/02/2009
CountryRose
Yes, Magistra, I totally agree. Mother (and father) and baby should recieve help with the truth of child development early on in a non-threatening environment. Something like a small group of parents and babies learning how to interact/play together, some snacks for all, and mini-lectures from good-dispositioned health care folks on normal baby behavior and such. (I must give kudos to Ms. Love Robinson for her touching essay. I wish each young mom/dad would read it! Bravo!)
Posted 07:48 PM, 11/02/2009
CountryRose
Yet here we go again, Ms.Love Robinson, my friends 20 year old daughter with a two year old son just spoke to me on the phone. On asking how is the little guy, young mom told me he is just so bad. I said hey, he is a good fine little guy, but young mom continued: Oh, no he is just evil; he is a devil. I feel so helpless even among my own friend-group!
Posted 10:24 PM, 11/02/2009
Magistra
Rose, I could tell you stories all day long of parents who think that a baby or toddler is being deliberately evil when all the kid is doing is following the dictates of normal child development. They are just trying to make sense of the world around them, to master language and to do all that while growing and changing. NO OTHER TIME IN OUR LIVES is so much going on inside the mind and body at once. So much abuse occurs by parents who think they are merely training their children to behave a certain way. It is so sad.
6 comments
  • Top Jobs
  • Top Homes
  • Top Cars
 
SEARCH JOBS
Rittenhouse Square


$799,000
224-30 W RITTENHOUSE SQ #2815-6
Garnet Valley


$200,000
7000 Village Way
SEARCH CARS

Buy Inquirer, Daily News & Philly merchandise here including:

 
Books
 
Movies
 
Page Reprints
 
Photo Licensing
 
Photos