Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH  

Opinion   

share
email
print
font size
options
 
READER FEEDBACK
Post a comment


Head Strong: GOP needs new primary process, and fast

The Republican presidential-primary process begins in 27 months. That sounds far removed, but the time for action is now if the GOP wants to nominate an electable candidate instead of one suitable for nomination but not a general-election victory.

That there has been an exodus from the GOP cannot be denied. A Washington Post/ABC News poll released last week found that just 20 percent of respondents identified themselves as Republican - the lowest figure since 1983.

Left behind in the party are the most conservative of voters. Their standing, coupled with the fact that the most passionate at either end of the spectrum are the most reliable primary voters, sets the stage for the nomination of someone in the mold of Sarah Palin, Mike Huckabee, or maybe Mitt Romney. Each is well-suited to excite the base, but when it comes to expanding the tent, you can check the box marked "none of the above."

"The Republican Party's nominating process is not designed to select the strongest candidate with the broadest appeal in the large states needed to win 270 electoral votes in a general election," longtime GOP operative Roger Stone told me last week.

It's time for the GOP to reshape its primary process. Now. The party needs a new strategy to give voice to its remaining middle-of-the-road voters. Recapturing the center will demand a shift in the way the Republican Party nominates its presidential candidates. I see three options.

Change the calendar. The current emphasis on smaller states with conservative electorates subverts the more moderate voices that actually have a chance to win a general election. Example: Since 1976, only once has the winner of a contested Iowa GOP caucus gone on to win the general election (George W. Bush did it in 2000, and he ended up losing the popular vote). The New Hampshire winner, meanwhile, has gone on to claim the presidency just twice after contested primaries - and even that hasn't happened since George H.W. Bush did it in 1988.

My favored alternative? Reorganize the presidential-primary calendar so states with more moderate tendencies get a say earlier.

Republican political consultant Mark McKinnon, who has worked with George W. Bush and John McCain, suggested prioritizing Western states like Arizona and Colorado, as well as Northeastern states like Connecticut. Pollster Scott Rasmussen pointed to New England for potential bellwether moderate states. He called New Hampshire "the most important state in the process."

Regional primaries. Bob Graham, a Democratic former U.S. senator and governor from Florida, once likened regional primaries to college football's Bowl Championship Series. The title game, he reasoned, "rotates . . . from year to year among the traditional bowl games." Graham's plan would similarly carve the country into five regions whose states would vote every three weeks. Like the bowl process, the regional voting order would rotate every election.

Stone told me he favored this approach because it would force candidates to appeal to every section of the country. Meanwhile, making candidates actually run through the end of the process would allow for "a longer and more thorough vetting process for the candidates" and a more exciting one for voters.

The downside? Less of what Graham has called the "political screen" that the old-school retail politicking of Iowa and New Hampshire provides. Rasmussen suggested randomly selecting a small state to lead off the regional primary season to ensure that door-knocking and living-room town halls remain a significant part of the nomination process.

Empower the party bosses. Lawrence Jacobs, director of the Center for the Study of Politics and Governance at the University of Minnesota, points to changes instituted in the 1970s as a turning point in the way primary elections were contested. Responsibility for choosing nominees, he said, was transferred from party officials to the voters.

Rather than simply adjusting the order of this modern presidential-primary system, Jacobs said, the GOP could return to a time when party leaders had a more definitive role in choosing the party standard-bearer. The Democrats, he noted, are already moving in this direction by empowering superdelegates.

"Frankly, it doesn't matter if Iowa and New Hampshire go first - which certainly have moderate elements - or if it's Georgia and Florida and those states go first," he said. "It's the fact that in each of those states you tend to get this narrow segment of party activists driving the process."

Of course, the notion of allowing "elites" to overrule the will of the people isn't as politically viable today as it was 50 years ago. And there is certainly risk for the GOP in alienating its conservative base.

But 2012 will be a referendum on President Obama. And while conservatives might head to the voting booths kicking and screaming if the GOP nominee is too moderate for their liking, they're not going to stay at home.

As Jacobs told me: "That group, that conservative movement is now watching in Washington as Barack Obama I think is about to pass probably the most comprehensive social-welfare legislation since the New Deal. And that's going to be a very sobering sort of moment."

Time for the GOP to look beyond 2010. For 2012, the time is now.


Contact Michael Smerconish via www.smerconish.com.

Comments   
Posted 06:37 AM, 10/25/2009
cosrivron2
Running for Republican National Committee advisor Mikey? Please take your me-me-me is wonderful show to Podunk, VT. and leave us alone. I gave up listening to you three years ago.
Posted 07:40 AM, 10/25/2009
SBVFT Contributor
we had a middle of the road/reach across the aisle candiate in 2008. his name was John McCain. COLUMN FAIL.
Posted 07:48 AM, 10/25/2009
SBVFT Contributor
And Mark McKinnon is a fairy when it comes to playing to win. Newsweek 2-1-08: "Even if Republicans don't convert in more significant numbers, the friendly outreach may blunt the ferocity of GOP attacks. One senior aide to John McCain has already said he's reluctant to attack Obama: last year, McCain's adman Mark McKinnon wrote an internal memo promising not to tape ads against the Illinois Democrat if he becomes the nominee."
Posted 08:13 AM, 10/25/2009
94Bravo
It doesn't matter what the GOP does as long as groups like ACORN continue to exist register people early and often, dead and alive. The continuing disenfranchisement of traditional GOP-voting military overseas absentee voters continues as well, which sickens me.
Posted 09:09 AM, 10/25/2009
jimy_max
cosrivron2: but you still read him voraciuosly .... and for three years. do you hate yourself?
Posted 09:10 AM, 10/25/2009
jimy_max
SBVFT Contributor: if not McCain in 2008 then who? any other GOP candidate last year may have been ga-ga for the right wingers ... but would have failed on the national stage miserably. since the GOP is a resembling a vast wasteland of 'holes' I think this is advice right up your 'alleys': the first rule of holes is that when you're in one, stop digging. pass it along, jimy_max
Posted 09:14 AM, 10/25/2009
Thoughtful&concernedvoter
Smerc is an embarrassment of epic proportions. His uncritical embrace of BHObama, given Smerc's personal political history, is shameful. Today's column shows why Smerc should have his column writing privileges suspended. To start out by quoting, out of context, a hopelessly flawed WaPo/ABC News poll that deliberately undersampled GOP voters shows why. Check this blog post out: http://hotair.com/archives/2009/10/20/wapoabc-poll-uses-skewed-sample-to-show-public-option-support/ And neutral political analyst Larry Sabato posted the following tweet earlier this week: Party ID totals in WaPo/ABC poll are very misleading. They show 33%D, 20%R, 42%Independent. Ridiculous. 10/20 4:47 P.M. -
Posted 09:17 AM, 10/25/2009
jimy_max
94Bravo: are you aware how much the 2000-2006 Bush/Republican Congress bestowed on ACORN? it will astound you ... look it up -- gobs of Federal money from the conservative hands of Bush & Repubs to the so-called grubby little hands of suppossed leftist pinkos. so does that make George W. Bush and all his Republican cronies a bunch of anti-American, Socialists for supporting ACORN for ALL those years and for ALL those $$$$$ ? ain't Patriotic Democracy grand, - jimy_max
Posted 09:36 AM, 10/25/2009
janann
Well the first four posts clearly explain the inherant problem with the party that will be more comfortable destroying their own party than admitting they need to not change,,,,but go back to their REPUBLICAN roots. Unofrtunately for the party, they will take the word of Media Manipulator and Republican Schill, Pinnochio Joe Scarborough that he is the moderate that can bring the party back together,,, when he is actually the one whose arrogance reved up the decline of a once great party. Turn to Glenn, Rush and Hannity for all your knowledge,,,, it has been a really stellar successss ----- I look forwardto the Huckabee/Palin Ticket in 2012.
Posted 10:10 AM, 10/25/2009
RalphInPa
And here's yet another useless GOP advise column from the sily and insignificant Mikey Smerconish. Where was Mikey's advise column to his failed friend Pres. Obama against picking Marxists and Rascists advisors such as Vann Jones? Nowhere on this matter, of course, but little Mikey continues to wrongfully advocate that shallow 'GOP needs to widen its tent' mantra. This silliness just demonstrates Mikey's basic lack of intellect once again. You do know Mikey that wide tent advocates such as yourself have only given conservative GOPers such horrible 'moderates' as John McCain, Arlen Specter, Olympia Snowne, Lincoln Chaffee and Lindsay Graham. Yeah, Mikey, the GOP needs more of these clowns, especially since you say so. Stick with what you're qualified, Mikey; talk candle-making with J.C.
Comment removed.
Posted 11:34 AM, 10/25/2009
John O
One cannot forget that smerconish's political mentor is arlen spector; the epitome of the socalled "mdoerate". Spector will not be elected by the democrats because he is hated by them as much as he is hated by the repulicans. However, the real truth is that smerconish who is a big supporter of the Philadelphia one party machine rule wants one party rule for the entire country. The entire country run just like Philadelphia and its corrupt one party machine; better secession and civil war than a smerconish like state; good for lawyer but horrible for decent hard working people. Smerconish is a silly narcissitic buffon who only excels at selling and huckstering on radio all day; how many different cars has he endorsed and how many different blinds etc? Mikey is out for Mikey and his political opinions are as shallow as his intellect.
Posted 11:40 AM, 10/25/2009
jimy_max
mensaman: your response belies your screen name. or is the reference to "mensa" your attempt at irony? i think i'm giving you way too much credit .... regardless, empty-headed, bumper sticker slogans parroted by an obedient radio listener ALWAYS sitting on the Right side of the room is why you and yours are looking at a gloomy forescast of a rather llooonnnnggggg hard winter out in the partisan Wilderness. make sure to wear a heavy sweater or a Snuggie, it gets chilly out in the Hinterlands. - jimy_max
Posted 12:18 PM, 10/25/2009
PlumberJoe
Given the Obama track record, any "natural born" teleprompter over the age of 35 will wup Obama in 2012. regardless of party.
Posted 01:04 PM, 10/25/2009
jimy_max
PlumberJoe: how about Palin/PlumberJoe in 2012 -- it has a nice ring to it. your compatriot Joe the Plumber was a major boost in the 2008 campaign ... maybe you can throw some cabbage his way and he will front you guys again. any GOP combination in 2012 is a recipe for success given that 20% of Americans identify with the Party of Lincoln. that's the ticket, - jimy_max
  • Top Jobs
  • Top Homes
  • Top Cars
 
SEARCH JOBS
Feasterville


$289,999
2648 OLD LINCOLN HWY
Mount Airy


$495,000
500 WOODBROOK LN
SEARCH CARS

Buy Inquirer, Daily News & Philly merchandise here including:

 
Books
 
Movies
 
Page Reprints
 
Photo Licensing
 
Photos