Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH  
share
email
print
reprint
font size
options
 
TOM GRALISH / Staff Photographer
A cyclist pedals in the Spruce Street bike lane. The SEPTA bus at rear has blocked the single lane for motor vehicles.
1 of 6
READER FEEDBACK
Post a comment
RELATED STORIES
 
YouTube: Bicycle Coalition video of the Pine Street bike lane
 
Web site: Bicycle Coalition of Greater Philadelphia
 
Photos: Bike Lane Violations in Philadelphia
 
Changing Skyline: Let the master planners decide how to get to the Delaware waterfront
 
Fox29's Mike Jerrick fills his apartment with art
 
Hail to the chief White House decorator
 
They dig garden tools
 
LifeStyle
 
Your Place: The struggle to remove rust streaks from concrete
 
Auctions: Houses ready for Black Friday shoppers
 
Antiques: Presidents' china is prime attraction at Main Line show
 
Antiques/Art/Crafts
 
Time to ...
 
Garden Calendar


Changing Skyline: Pedaling in a lane that's their own

I was idling at a red light on 17th Street the other afternoon, at ease on my nameless, burgundy-colored three-speed as I enjoyed the gentle fall sun, when a taxi driver pulled up in the left lane and barked: "Do you always stop at lights?"

I figured I'd answer honestly. "I try to," I told him.

"Then I'll give you respect," he allowed, before flooring the gas and charging off into Center City traffic.

Though his tone was grudging, I considered the exchange a hopeful break in the long-running cycle of animosity that seems to divide drivers and bicyclists in Philadelphia. I'll never forget a previous conversation with a motorist waiting behind me at a red light near Rittenhouse Square. That guy threatened to run me over unless I got out of "his" lane.

Yet, for all the palpable anger on the streets these days, times have never been better for the urban cyclist. In June, Mayor Nutter issued an executive order compelling the city to give equal treatment to bikers, drivers, and pedestrians, redressing an imbalance that has existed virtually since the first Model T rolled off the assembly line.

In short order, his transportation czar, Rina Cutler, launched a bold experiment to put policy into practice. With a few cans of white paint, her staff reconfigured the traffic stripes on Pine and Spruce Streets to transfer a car lane's worth of asphalt to the bicycle. If the new bike lanes pass a city review in December, the city will create more permanent versions, perhaps with colored asphalt, when the two streets undergo their scheduled resurfacing next summer.

To anyone who travels on two wheels, it's already clear that the new bike zone has solved a major headache: getting crosstown in Center City during business hours. The generous lanes, separated from cars by a hatched buffer, provide the missing link in Philadelphia's growing downtown bike circuit, connecting the successful Schuylkill Banks trail to the brand-new, 1.3-mile Delaware River bike path that opened this month between Lombard Street and Pier 70.

Already, bike traffic on the two city streets has more than doubled, according to the Bicycle Coalition of Greater Philadelphia. Just as important, the reallocation of space has brought a welcome order to every form of ambulation. Now that drivers, bikers, and walkers have clearly defined boundaries, they appear to be interacting better on those streets. That can't help but make bikers safer.

For all that, resistance to the new bike lanes remains intense. Some motorists are convinced that any gain for the bicycle is a loss for the car. Exactly one day after the bike lanes debuted, Daily News columnist Stu Bykofsky gave voice to their resentment when he denounced the city's decision to sacrifice "precious space" to two-wheeled vehicles.

"I like bicycles," he explained. "It's bicyclists I hate."

In making his case, Bykofsky offered up the usual litany of accusations against cyclists: They ride on sidewalks. They ignore stop signs and red lights. They weave through traffic.

He's right that some bicyclists ignore the rules. In Pennsylvania, bikes are considered slow-moving vehicles, much like horse-drawn carriages and tractors, and need to follow traffic laws. Sadly, a bicyclist may have been responsible for last week's death of pedestrian Andre Steed near 16th and Locust Streets, a hit-and-run as unconscionable as any involving a car.

But let's remember that drivers don't always behave perfectly either. And those disorderly Goliaths are far more likely to kill you when they break the rules. Yet no one would ever suggest that cars don't deserve space on the city streets because a small percentage of motorists flout the traffic laws.

One of the most common complaints Cutler has heard about the new bike lanes is that they've slowed traffic to a "snail's pace" on Pine and Spruce Streets. Her retort: "Traffic has always moved at a snail's pace."

Actually, calming traffic is a good thing, improving the quality of life for residential neighborhoods and pedestrians alike. Philadelphia has allowed too many downtown streets to evolve into raceways. Besides, the extra driving time on the two streets is minimal: If the traveling speed across Center City is reduced from 30 to 20 miles per hour, that adds just two minutes to the two-mile trip.

Still, it's no surprise that some motorists would perceive themselves as the injured party in the city's decision to reallocate its street space. The same psychology causes people to clamor for more highways and parking garages, even though they know deep down that cities with easy driving and parking are cities that no one cares to visit.

There remain some bugs to work out before Cutler's transportation staff makes the bike lanes permanent. Many drivers see the new zone as a convenient place for short-term, and sometimes, long-term, parking. During a recent trip, it seemed there was at least one vehicle blocking the lane on every block. Contractors' trucks seemed to dominate. The city also allows churchgoers to park in the bike lanes on Sundays, rendering them useless.

Cutler suggests educational advertising could help, followed by stricter police enforcement. That includes getting tough with wayward bicyclists, especially those who ride on the sidewalks.

No less an authority than David Byrne, the former Talking Heads front man, makes a good point in his new book on urban cycling, Bicycle Diaries. "If bikers want to be treated better by motorists and pedestrians then they have to obey the traffic laws."

So next time a motorist stops you at a red light, tell him that's exactly what you're doing.

 


Contact architecture critic Inga Saffron at 215-854-2213 or isaffron@phillynews.com.

 

Comments   
Posted 07:10 AM, 10/30/2009
lupulin
I was skeptical of the bike lanes: I'm not scared of cars, so I rode those streets even without lanes. However, I have noticed a huge increase in cyclists on Spruce and Pine, and it's an easier ride now that (most) cars stay out of those lanes. Good to see the Bicycle Coalition's data back up that observation. You're exactly right about all sides needing to give, and get, more respect. I truly hope the police will step up enforcement and start changing the culture of reckless driving (and riding) in this city.
Posted 07:59 AM, 10/30/2009
Hortguy
I ride my bike to work every day. The new bike lanes along Spruce and Pine make the ride civil. What an unusual experience compared to riding along Broad Street wondering if someone on a cell phone is going to clip me or open a door on me. As demographics continue to change in the city, I think you'll find these bike lanes to prove very popular and successfull
Posted 08:15 AM, 10/30/2009
nuggett
Both sides need to chill out.....cycling is here to stay....cost effiecent, cleaner and convenient......both sides pay the same amount in taxes......both sides need to obey the rules....and courtesy is not a bad thing folks....neither side "owns" the streets......a few weeks of stricker enforing of the rules by the police will go along way to change the culture of "me first everybody else is dirt" by both parties...
Posted 08:39 AM, 10/30/2009
Peacemaker
Here's the problem with cyclists: They ride on sidewalks. They ignore stop signs and red lights. They weave through traffic.
Posted 08:50 AM, 10/30/2009
cuch
Most negative comments written and verbally expressed to me are by people who never ride a bike in the city. Those of us who do both will tell you, that by far, drivers are the cause of slowed traffic, dangerous situations, and overall aggression. Bikers do not for the most part fly through stop signs and lights without slowing down at least to check for on coming traffic. Bikers are not nuts, we understand in a collision with a car we're losing. For some reason drivers, again which I am one, speak as if all bikers line up pedetrians to smash into them, fly down sidewalks at 25 mph, run every light, and give the finger to all those who stand in their way. After years riding on our streets, I can tell you every day I am amazed at the cars that run red lights, only to get to the next, slow from 45 mph to 25 mph at a stop sign and consider that stopping, along with the walkers who just plain walk accross the street against the light or in the middle of the block daring you to hit them on your bike. It is sad that someone died due to a bike this past week, but is almost a common occurance for a biker to get hit by a car that takes off. Drivers who complain about cyclist should try riding in the city for one day and then form an oppinion of where the problem lies.
Posted 08:56 AM, 10/30/2009
Mark in Mount Airy
Bike lanes on Pine and Spruce Streets was a good but very tiny start. Philadelphia should really emulate Montreal and create physical separation between bike lanes and vehicular lanes -- thin concrete dividers the height of a sidewalk. In that way the habitual violators -- the taxis, the churchgoers and people from north and south philly visiting CC -- have to respect the space. We also need a more streets with bike-only lanes, which will also draw bikes off of surrounding streets. It makes a big difference and it costs very little money -- Montreal is a city that has done a tremendous amount in making a city more livable without spending a lot of money on it.
Posted 09:33 AM, 10/30/2009
John Psuedonym
Why is there a special parking exemption for churchgoers? So their reverence to an imaginary friend who lives in the sky is so important that they get to block traffic every Sunday morning? Sounds like government endorsement of religion to me. Their church attendance is a personal choice and should grant them no special parking status. To me their frivolous Sunday morning tradition deserves no more accomodation than me parking and going into a corner store. This is supposed to be a society ruled by secular laws, so tell me why the city government allows them to circumvent the law for worship; a clearly non secular activity?
Posted 09:36 AM, 10/30/2009
Justiceman
The bicycling community could go a long way towards improving relations with the driving community if someone in the bicycling community steps forward with information regarding Andre Steed's killer. The reward fund is now over $10,000. He's a white male (or possibly part-Asian), about 5'9" tall, 140-150 pounds, in his late teens or early twenties, with black hair, and was wearing a white hoodie with red spots in the background and riding a white mountain bike. If you have information, contact the Citizens Crime Commission of Philadelphia (215-546-TIPS; http://www.crimecommission.org/philadelphia.html).
Posted 09:56 AM, 10/30/2009
Mark in Mount Airy
Amen to that, John Pseudonym! That point reminds me of how Inquirer columnist Steve Lopez practically got run out of town for a series of columns about the flagrant violations of south philadelphians parking in the middle of Broad Street.
Posted 10:01 AM, 10/30/2009
cuch
Justiceman, what do you think the biking community is harboring this idiot, like we are protecting him because he rides a bike. If anyone knows who it is turn him in.
Posted 10:06 AM, 10/30/2009
Fitzy31
The more bicycles [and bicyclists} in Philadelphia, the better!!
Posted 10:12 AM, 10/30/2009
priley
I lived in Philly for over 10 years, biking the whole time, and I can tell you I would get a lot of grief from drivers even when I did follow all the laws! It was amazing to get cut off and yelled at, as Inga observed, while you're actually following the rules, because when you do follow the rules, you're more likely to be in the wolf pack with the cars and somebody's precious ego will be threatened.
Posted 10:48 AM, 10/30/2009
Fernando08
More bikes, less bike hate Ecology Food Coop Forever!
Posted 10:52 AM, 10/30/2009
Gina V
next time your cruising maybe it will be on one of these... www.woodybicycles.com
Posted 10:57 AM, 10/30/2009
WSWMom
I travel both Spruce and Pine every day, and often park on either St. in Society Hill. At this point, I think it's a great idea. The bike riders I've seen have been law abiding in their lane as well. I can't say the same for my fellow motorists. I see many cars going into the bike lane as though it doesn't exist and not for valid reasons like making a turn or avoiding a parked car in the car lane. I hope it changes soon, or I fear we may hear about an injury to a biker because a car decided to get into the bike lane without looking.
  • Top Jobs
  • Top Homes
  • Top Cars
 
SEARCH JOBS
Northern Liberties


$475,000
912 N 2ND ST
Bustleton


$255,000
9610 BIRWOOD ST
SEARCH CARS

Buy Inquirer, Daily News & Philly merchandise here including:

 
Books
 
Movies
 
Page Reprints
 
Photo Licensing
 
Photos