Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH  
share
email
print
reprint
font size
options
 
READER FEEDBACK
Post a comment
RELATED STORIES
 
SEPTA strike over, but fare hikes loom
 
Crowds gobble up free SEPTA tokens
 
How Pa. can prevent the next SEPTA strike
 
How the SEPTA deal got made
 
City unions emboldened by SEPTA settlement
 
Unpunched TransPasses good for exchange or credit
 
SEPTA as contract template? No way, says Nutter
 
SEPTA commuters "thrilled" strike is over
 
Editorial: Detour transit strikes
 
Philadelphia expects to end fiscal year $31M in the red


City unions emboldened by SEPTA settlement

For all the political drama and commuter inconvenience it caused, the SEPTA strike may have been just a curtain-raiser to a bigger act of labor strife, featuring the City of Philadelphia and 22,000 unionized city workers now laboring under expired contracts.

Fiscally, the SEPTA walkout has nothing to do with the city or its four unions. But the transit strike's impact on public opinion, the political landscape, and Mayor Nutter's image could well influence the deals the city eventually reaches with the unions, observers said.

At least some city workers appear to be inspired by the transit strike.

Members of the city's white-collar union, District Council 47 of the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Workers, yesterday passed out leaflets in City Hall encouraging employees to take off work Friday to protest the lack of progress on their contracts. D.C. 47's contract, like those of the blue-collar workers, police, and firefighters, expired June 30.

Referring to the mayor as "Mayor Cutter," the leaflets - not officially sanctioned by the union - read: "The Cutter is not negotiating with our Municipal Workers Unions but he found time to get involved in SEPTA's union. . . . Straighten your back and tell Mayor Cutter you are a city worker who deserves to be treated with dignity."

Former D.C. 47 president Thomas Paine Cronin said city workers "have a perfect right to say they want a similar contract. If I were a current city union leader, I would be saying, me too! Me too!"

However, in interviews, few city and union officials, or political observers, said they believed that sanitation workers and other municipal employees would get fatter paychecks solely because that's what bus drivers would receive under the new five-year SEPTA contract. The situations are unrelated, they said.

"The [Transit Workers Union Local 234] contract is of limited impact because it really is a state thing," Democratic political consultant Dan Fee said.

The TWU negotiated with SEPTA, a state-created agency funded in part by the city, the state, and Philadelphia's four surrounding counties, and not with City Hall and its declining coffers.

Also, while Gov. Rendell helped seal the SEPTA contract with $7 million in state money, it's highly doubtful that he could, or would, bring a similar infusion of funds to the city's negotiations.

At the same time, though, the resulting SEPTA deal - and the talks leading up to it - could complicate matters for Nutter.

At one point, the mayor was barred from negotiating sessions by Local 234 president Willie Brown. The union boss blamed Nutter, in part, for the strike, and dubbed him "Little Caesar."

For some, the episode raised questions about Nutter's ability to handle high-stakes contract talks under the threat of a strike.

"He didn't look good on TV, standing on the sidelines as the governor came swinging in with a $7 million early Christmas present," said local NAACP president J. Whyatt Mondesire.

Nutter, in response, said he had no money to offer, and the governor was the point man on negotiations.

"But as mayor of the city that was facing, at least that weekend, the prospect of a strike, [SEPTA talks were] something for me to be involved with, whether I have dollars to put on the table or not," Nutter said yesterday.

He also stressed that he participated in the negotiations at the invitation of U.S. Rep. Bob Brady, who has had much success mediating previous Local 234 strikes.

Nutter dismissed the tensions between him and Brown.

"In contract negotiations, a lot of things happen," he said. "It's over. This is not the Dr. Phil show. . . . Let's not have a psychology class here."

Nonetheless, the mayor will now be dealing with union leaders emboldened by the actions of their SEPTA counterparts.

"I'm proud of Willie for sticking up for his membership, and I'm glad he stood tough against the politicians - the mayor, the governor, Brady, all of them," said Bill Gault, president of Local 22 of the International Association of Fire Fighters.

"I haven't spoken with Willie Brown or leadership over there, but it seems like they did a good job," said John McNesby, president of Lodge 5 of the Fraternal Order of Police. "He represented his members well, and he delivered."

But while union leaders may have been heartened by the strike and the contract it yielded, public frustration over the SEPTA walkout may play to Nutter's advantage, said Peter Capelli, director of the Wharton School's Center for Human Resources.

"The public was so unhappy with the union's argument that it's quite possible the next time a strike is threatened, the public would be more willing to side with the administration," said Capelli.

The public, Capelli said, is not likely to make fine distinctions between SEPTA workers and city workers, even if city employees were seeking less generous contract terms than those sought by transit workers.

Nutter, for his part, sought yesterday to emphasize that the SEPTA deal and the city contract talks "could not be more different."

Noting Philadelphia's 11.1 percent unemployment rate and declining tax revenues, he said, "Our financial condition is deteriorating."

He also downplayed any chance of a strike by municipal employees, noting that SEPTA workers lost a week's wages and that such a move would hurt the city.

"I'm not sure what the purpose of such an action would be," he said. State law bars police and firefighters from striking.

The mayor anticipated reaching pacts with the four municipal unions "as relatively quickly as possible."

Of the four unions, the police are furthest along, having completed arbitration hearings. A decision by independent arbitrators is expected later this month or early next month.

Arbitration hearings with the firefighters began in late October and will go into February.

Far less progress has occurred with the city's nonuniformed employee unions, D.C. 47 and District Council 33. Neither has met with city negotiators since July.

However, two sources said Nutter and his chief of staff, Clay Armbrister, did meet privately two weeks ago with Pete Matthews, president of D.C. 33, which represents nearly 10,000 blue-collar workers.

 


Contact staff writer Marcia Gelbart at 215-854-2338 or mgelbart@phillynews.com.

 

Comments   
Posted 05:48 AM, 11/10/2009
tr88
You voted for it, you got it!
Posted 07:00 AM, 11/10/2009
principled
While it may be illegal for police and fire too strike. The convention center does receive city funds and a job action at this location is not out of the realm and incourage all city employees to ponder the possibility. By calling on those AFL-CIO workers at this siteto honor such a demostration. All labor unions must stick together.
Posted 07:00 AM, 11/10/2009
Taxpaying Voter
Lets hope that Nutter has more guts then Septa did is willing to cut workers and costs.
Posted 07:09 AM, 11/10/2009
cecelia
the mayor doesnt want to give emlpoyees a raise they havent had one in two years everything has gone up but CITY COUNCIL can geta 5% COLA raise. Naybe he should get get rid of some of his upper staff so there is money for the employees who do work can get a raise.
Posted 07:25 AM, 11/10/2009
phljoe
As disgusted as the public is with the TWU, how can the city's unions expect any sympathy from the taxpayers? I, for one, would rather weather a strike than see these unions gain any more leverage or power to make life miserable for the the everyday taxpayer. I wish they would stop dragging this city down.
Posted 07:28 AM, 11/10/2009
asiathepoet
Good morning Taxypaying Voter: don't forget that municipal workers are taxpaying voters, too.
Posted 07:40 AM, 11/10/2009
asiathepoet
Hello Phljoe: I say you find a way to get rid of your trash & recyclables. Also, you will have to find another way to receive running water and to discard of your family’s waste when using the lavatory. Do not forget that if you have any questions about your taxes or potholes, street lighting, if the traffic light is broken on your thoroughfare you will have to handle this on your own. By the way, if you become a victim of a crime, you will have to defend yourself. God forbids, if your property catches a fire, what do you do then? You appear to me that you are a sports fanatic… are you? Well, those beautiful stadiums? In order for them to be built they had to be approved by a city agency called License and Inspections. Yes, they go through the building plans examiners. Municipal workers do not receive their jobs via patronage! We take exams and are qualified, certified and dignified employees who deliver. So when are you relocating to the rainforest? Without municipal workers and services, that is where it will feel like you live. However, I know your type. You ridicule municipal workers until your child or your sibling obtains a job within the municipality. Or maybe you were declined because you couldn’t pass an exam. Whatever the reason take a humanitarian course!
Posted 07:43 AM, 11/10/2009
phljoe
Asiathepoet: yes, and the unions are trying to get back every cent. I'm not averse to the workers, per se. It's the union leadership and the goon mentality that has to go.
Posted 08:39 AM, 11/10/2009
MattPSU
This is what happens when you vote Democrat collectively for 50+ years. Cost of living actually went down since the last contract, not up. We need to do something about the unsustainable pension system and do it now.
Posted 08:40 AM, 11/10/2009
xi_lives
Ever wonder how bus drivers end of making over $50,000 per year? Simple, they negotiate with politicians who pay them with our money and in return they get their votes.
Posted 08:41 AM, 11/10/2009
aNutterInDgutter
"City unions emboldened by SEPTA settlement" You writers act as if this is new. It's a normal cycle every time it's time to renegotiate the contracts. Privatize all these non-essential jobs to save money.
Posted 08:56 AM, 11/10/2009
bgorton
lets give them all 100% wage increases, 100% pention contribution and free medical. lord knows they definitely deserve it. This city is a f*cking joke. gets some republicans with backbones in here to clean out the garbage.
Posted 08:57 AM, 11/10/2009
thinking
Unions fighting for fair wages and benefits does not have to resort to "goon mentality". Management always takes of themselves and ensures that their salaries and benefits are protected. But when union members want a fair contract, they are seen as greedy. In this country, the rich continue to get richer while the poor and middle class get squeezed. Many workers are losing their benefits and pensions. We should all support those who are still trying to hold onto theirs. Remember, the unions helped to build the midle class of this country. Without them, the middle class will be gone.
Posted 09:00 AM, 11/10/2009
VAD
The union is a legal way for people to intimidate, harrass, and blackmail the government to get what they want. How many people were screwed last week so these guys could get a raise? In this economy, where nobody has any money they do this. They are all scum. The next time they strike I will give rides to everyone who needs one. And everyone should do the same thing. There is a reason why we do not negotiate with terrorists. The reason is that once you negotiate anything, all the other terrorists think that you will negotiate with them also. Philadelphia is so screwed now. Every single union out there will want a piece of this. They should have fired them all and rehired everyone who wanted a job. Leave the other idiots on the picketline. A union is nothing better than a legal mafia, and I don't understand why the city is putting up with it. Well I understand Nutter, he is completely retarted.
Posted 09:00 AM, 11/10/2009
psyrus
If they strike, fire them. It can't get any simpler. Open up the city jobs to those in the suburbs and you will be flooded with qualified people. Its time for the "entitled" to go.
  • Top Jobs
  • Top Homes
  • Top Cars
 
SEARCH JOBS
Germantown


$349,900
410 W CHELTEN AVE
Rittenhouse Square


$1,350,000
2104 DELANCEY PL
SEARCH CARS

Buy Inquirer, Daily News & Philly merchandise here including:

 
Books
 
Movies
 
Page Reprints
 
Photo Licensing
 
Photos