Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH  

Currents   

share
email
print
reprint
font size
options
 
Former Judges Mark A. Ciavarella Jr. (left) and Michael T. Conahan.
Citizens' Voice
Former Judges Mark A. Ciavarella Jr. (left) and Michael T. Conahan.
READER FEEDBACK
Post a comment


Editorial: Order in the court

Even before two judges were charged with racketeering in the Luzerne County kids-for-cash scandal, most Pennsylvanians told pollsters they suspected state justice was for sale - since judicial elections were awash in campaign donations. Many judges agreed with that perception, other surveys showed.

So it's a challenge of the highest order for the state Supreme Court - which oversees the court system - to try to instill confidence in the judiciary the wake of the upstate scandal. If public cynicism was high before the scandal broke early this year, it has surely spiked since.

After a late start, though, the court, led by Chief Justice Ronald D. Castille, is making the right moves to reassure citizens.

Even with a politicized judiciary, the treachery of the conduct attributed to the former judges, Mark A. Ciavarella Jr. and Michael T. Conahan, is breathtaking. Federal authorities have charged the pair with taking $2.6 million in payments from the operators of two privately run detention centers where Ciavarella then dispatched hundreds of teens after perfunctory hearings.

So the court's Oct. 29 ruling tossing out 6,500 juvenile-court cases tainted by the alleged kickback scheme was a major step.

While deliberating over that ruling, Castille and his fellow justices also joined with Gov. Rendell and state lawmakers to launch an inquiry by a panel that began holding hearings last month.

The key question the 11-member Interbranch Commission on Juvenile Justice has been wrestling with is how Ciavarella and Conahan could get away with what was described last week as "an almost routine disregard for the rights of juvenile offenders."

At hearings over two days in Wilkes-Barre, the panel heard how a conspiracy of silence from lawyers, court employees, and school officials enabled the rogue judges to trample over the rights of thousands of teens.

The hope has to be that the eventual recommendations from the commission will prompt reforms that could prevent another such perversion of justice.

On a related front, the Supreme Court made it clear it will follow all of the tentacles of the Luzerne County scandal. The court overturned a multimillion-dollar defamation award last week against a Wilkes-Barre newspaper because the judges conspired with a reputed mobster to fix the case. Conahan, then president judge, had assigned Ciavarella as judge in the case against the Citizens' Voice.

The justices ordered a new trial "to remedy the pervasive appearance of impropriety in this case, and to give justice . . . an opportunity to prevail." All of the other judges' cases should be examined.

As Castille's court also noted, "A jurist is either fair or unfair; there are no acceptable gradations." Indeed, the state courts need such stirring words coupled with decisive action to finally tear down those "For Sale" signs.

Comments   
Posted 08:41 AM, 11/15/2009
janenee79
Really? The Supreme Court, after a late start, is making things right? Really? And what do you suppose would have happened if the US Attorney's office had not filed charges against Ciavarella and Conahan? Do you really think the Supreme Court would be doing the right thing? They were FORCED to do the right thing because they looked like fools - or worse, were complicit. They had no intention of doing ANYTHING. They had the exact same evidence before that announcement as they did after, The statistics didn't change, the percentage of kids appearing without attorneys didn't change. The outrageous number of children being taken from their homes for infractions that should never have been taken to juvenile court didn't change. But the public pressure did change - it became intense. The Supreme Court knew things were terrible wrong in Luzerne County - they had heard about it from numerous sources. Judge Lokuta, Judge Muroski, Juvenile Law Center, the Scranton Times, multiple insurance companies. They turned a blind eye over and over and over again. Why?
Posted 10:08 AM, 11/16/2009
John Law
Why is Corbett (State Attorney General)being allowed to use the job he's repeatedly failed at to get the job he's not qualified for? It looks like this "Bonus Gate" affair and the pace of it's prosecution are being timed to help get Corbett free press for his election bid for Governor. We're paying for him and his staff to run for Governor...and then if he fails, he's still drawing a pay check, etc as a lame State's Attorney General! Why are we and our legislature letting him to get away with that? What about the Parole Board Corruption he's been told about, with evidence, for years now? What about the "Rendell Murders"? What about his repeated betrayal of public trust? Who investigates the Attorney General? Who does he answer to... by his own repeated lack of action... it's not the good, decent families of Pennsylvania! "I was elected to go after bad guys". Well "Bad Bett Corbett", won't be chasing himself! Why isn't the U.S. Attorney General (Eric Holder) investigating Tom Corbett!?
Posted 11:55 AM, 11/16/2009
tiredoftheBS
This corruption is not rare, it is the rule rather thanthe exception. that it has become obvious in this singular case of the judiciary in some hole of a county such as Luzerne, makes us stil believe that it couldn't happen "here". Tut the obvious conclusion that must be drawn is that it is happening HERE. We need some serious and competent investigative reporting to analyze the justice system of all counties in PA and to examine in detail all fcets of the judiciary to verify that we have justice in PA. We need it. WE DEMAND IT. CONFIDENCE IN JUSTICE AND GOVERNMENT DEMANDS IT. The fact that Luzerne county happened means that corruption is the RULE and must be made the exception.
3 comments
  • Top Jobs
  • Top Homes
  • Top Cars
 
SEARCH JOBS
Jenkintown


$115,900
130 ZANE AVE
West Chester


$349,900
734 S EVERHART ST
SEARCH CARS

Buy Inquirer, Daily News & Philly merchandise here including:

 
Books
 
Movies
 
Page Reprints
 
Photo Licensing
 
Photos