Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH  
share
email
print
reprint
font size
options
 
READER FEEDBACK
Are you satisfied with the Phillies' season?
Yes
No
Post a comment
RELATED STORIES
 
Pedro's dream season with Phillies falls short
 
Bullpen not nearly as mighty as Phillies needed it to be
Photos: Phillies return from New York
 
More World Series coverage
Audio: Utley, Howard, Manuel reflect on loss
 
Sam Donnellon: Scrappy Phillies come up short
 
Phil Sheridan: Phillies didn't play like champions
 
Phillies can't stop Yankees from winning 27th title
 
Buy Phillies jerseys, playoff t-shirts, hats, and more
 
Purchase Phillies playoff photos & reprints
Photos: 2009 Phillies
 
Relive the memories: Coverage of the World Series run


Gonzo: Phillies good (but not great) year ends with loss

NEW YORK - When the last out was recorded, Yankee Stadium shook from the energy. A deep, primal howl reverberated from the stands. It was the sound of victory, of ultimate triumph - sweet music to the locals, pure pain to Philadelphians.

The Yankees won their 27th championship last night and celebrated in full view of thousands of sickeningly happy New Yorkers. It was a difficult thing to watch.

Back in Philly, after the Fightin's won Game 5, I had a conversation with a stadium worker at Citizen's Bank Park. The guy is a loyal Phils fan, and he hoped they would pull off the two-game sweep in the Bronx. But he also knew it would be difficult, and he acknowledged the possibility of failure. In so doing, he summed up how a lot of people probably feel today.

"It would be tough - not calling them 'the World Champs' anymore," he whispered.

Like the Roots famously said, "It don't feel right."

The Phils were the best team in all of baseball last year, and this season only one club was better. That's an astounding feat.

But as good as the Phils were - and they were truly terrific, even though things didn't ultimately work out the way any of us wanted - this season didn't carry quite the same vibe that saturated the city last year. Something was just . . . off.

Forget about the regular season record - 2009 wasn't nearly as smooth as 2008. Brad Lidge struggled, and so did much of the bullpen. Cole Hamels wasn't the same dominant pitcher that crushed the Dodgers in the National League Championship Series and dismissed the Rays in the World Series. Charlie had to tinker more. And Harry Kalas, may he rest in peace, left us.

It felt as though almost everything went right a year ago - while, this season, it was more like the Phils kept pushing toward their final destination even though the road they traveled was lousy with potholes. When the series was tied at a game apiece in Tampa last year, there was a sense of inevitability. When the series was tied at a game apiece in the Bronx, the outcome seemed less certain.

A few days ago, I had the same conversation with two different people - Wax and another friend from our sister paper - about how the Yankees-Phillies clash felt a bit like the Lakers-76ers NBA Finals from 2001. Like the Sixers, the Phils were the underdogs in the minds of most pundits (not to mention the Vegas odds makers). Like the Sixers, the Phils faced a historic franchise with a mouthy, aggravating fan base. Like the Sixers, the Phils took Game 1 on the road, then failed to seize countless opportunities as the series continued. And, like the Sixers, the Phils looked like a great team that was unfortunately pitted against a squad that was simply better. The Phils ultimately held on a little longer than the Sixers, but the eventual outcome was sadly the same.

Because New Yorkers are endlessly smug and annoying, the impulse will be smack them over the head with your cap instead of tip it to them. Try to fight that instinct. As much as it stings, the Yankees deserve a good deal of credit. The Phils lost but, more than that, the Bombers won. They capitalized on mistakes and played exceedingly well and earned their forthcoming parade.

But as heartbreaking as that is, this really wasn't about the Yankees, and it wasn't about Philly's never-ending rivalry with Gotham, either. This year wasn't about losing to New York any more than last year was about beating Tampa. The run we've witnessed over the last two seasons was about this town and this team. It was about a special group and the connection those players made with our city. It was about a club that helped a notoriously surly and pessimistic town change the way we think. It was about bringing us together and making us smile. It was about hope and happiness. It was about burying 25 years of abject disappointment. It was about being reborn.

This space frequently serves as a reminder that sports are a distraction and not to be taken too seriously. But there are instances, rare and wonderful, when sports become something more - something meaningful and real and indelible. It might happen once in a generation - or not at all. The Phillies gave us that extraordinary gift - a present only a select, fortunate few ever receive - and it should be cherished.

The Yankees are the new World Champions of baseball. The trophy that made its home in Philly for a year will move to New York now. That's the sad, inalterable truth. New York cannot take your memories, though. Those are yours to keep. They are the ultimate souvenirs, and they will last a lifetime.

 


Contact columnist John Gonzalez at 215-854-2813 or gonzalez@phillynews.com.

 

Comments   
Posted 05:29 AM, 11/05/2009
PhillyTrue
It wasn't too many years ago that this team was usually good for a last place finish only. They have improved and should continue to get better. There are talented players in the farm system waiting to come up and compete. See you again next year Bankees (or whomever is filling your shoes)
Posted 06:19 AM, 11/05/2009
nostrarollins
i'm proud of this team
Posted 06:36 AM, 11/05/2009
mistahkleen
Congrats to the Phillies. You guys had a great year. But the Yankees were a little better. Go Yankees! World Champs!
Posted 06:38 AM, 11/05/2009
Radioheadless
Proud of the team but sad that Lidge and Hamels lost their form from last year. I am very thankful to those two men, however, for being a huge part of the 2008 WS victory. We must never forget their contributions. I hope both return to form in 2010 and the Phils move Happ to the starting rotation, and/or pick up another solid starter.
Posted 06:50 AM, 11/05/2009
High Hopes
Well that hurts, we didn’t go back to back. Nonetheless, the Phillies gave me such wonderful memories yet again this season. These past 13 months have been my favorite time as a fan of any team. And am looking forward to the new memories of a lifetime that they are gonna give all of us here in the near future. Thanks again for an unforgettable season…Harry Kalas, we fans will always love you, and will forever hear your voice during each & every Phillies game. It’s officially the offseason, you & Whitey can now get your rounds of miniature golf in. And we’ll all do this again next year…Go Phillies!
Posted 06:52 AM, 11/05/2009
Conshy04
Good job phills.... The fact that they even made it to the playoffs with a half-dead bullpen and mediocre Hamels is impressive... This team has 2 more years left with this group, lets see if they can pull one more out....
Posted 07:00 AM, 11/05/2009
jingles
Put the series loss on Manuel. Managed the pitching staff poorly. Can we please get rid of this guy, and get a real manager.
Posted 07:09 AM, 11/05/2009
Kenny Junod
great yr... if cole & mole were right they would of repeated
Posted 07:11 AM, 11/05/2009
Jonny U
Phils need a third baseman that can hit. Pedro Feliz sucks.
Posted 07:18 AM, 11/05/2009
Will T.
The Phils biggest strengths last year are the most telling weaknesses this year; Brad Lidge and Cole Hamels. We needed just one win and one save from each. It didn't happen that's why they lost.
Posted 07:34 AM, 11/05/2009
wolfburn
well for the World Series, you also have to blame the loss on Howard. Yeah he hit that meaningless 2 run homer last night, but what else has he done? Strike out more times than Hideki Matsui had at bats?
Posted 07:35 AM, 11/05/2009
Dadair1
It was fun while it lasted, look forward to a stronger season next year!!!!!!!1
Posted 07:41 AM, 11/05/2009
Apollo Creed
Ryan Howard with the worst series of all-time.. 13 strikeouts in 20 something at bats???
Posted 07:41 AM, 11/05/2009
lefty1117
Yep, Will T has it, pitching did us in. I only hope this is an abberation for Hamels and not something bigger. With Lidge, I don't know, it seems like his fastball was down a few MPH all year. He couldn't blow it by anybody. Phils need to start thinking about another closer. If Hamels gets right for next year & we get Drabek or someone else in here to be a solid 3 or 4, this team wil be right back in it. I know people get on Pedro for his bat, but his D is unbelievable. He saved a number of runs this series with his quick glove.
Posted 07:42 AM, 11/05/2009
OBLawyer
For Hamels, this was a huge learning experience. If he has got what it takes, he will learn another pitch and come back much stronger. I would like to see them sign Lee for a few more years. I also believe Lidge will come back. He has shown he can do it. Tough season for him, but I would go with him for our closer for the start of next year before going in a different direction. I just heard Mirch Williams who agrees. He has the stuff.
  • Top Jobs
  • Top Homes
  • Top Cars
 
SEARCH JOBS
Southwark


$356,900
716 FULTON ST
Old City/Society Hill


$469,000
7 N COLUMBUS BLVD #116
SEARCH CARS

Buy Inquirer, Daily News & Philly merchandise here including:

 
Books
 
Movies
 
Page Reprints
 
Photo Licensing
 
Photos