Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH  
share
email
print
reprint
font size
options
 
READER FEEDBACK
Post a comment
RELATED STORIES
 
Buy Phillies jerseys, playoff t-shirts, hats, and more
 
Purchase Phillies playoff photos & reprints
Photos: 2009 Phillies
 
Relive the memories: Coverage of the World Series run


Daniel Rubin: Near Fenway, a kindred spirit

BOSTON - When you haven't played a meaningful game against a team since 1950, it's easy to forget how much pleasure can come from hating it. And where better than Boston could I go for a few lessons in loathing the New York Yankees?

"Today we are all Philadelphians," Kevin Cullen, metro columnist for the Boston Globe, told me.

File this under: The enemy of my enemy is my friend.

Cullen was invoking the spirit of a famous headline in the Paris newspaper Le Monde after Sept. 11, 2001. When it comes to Boston's feelings about the Yankees, all is historic, nothing is understated. We're talking about a rivalry that's referred to as Athens vs. Sparta, good vs. the Evil Empire.

"Honestly," said Hart Brachen, who writes the "Soxaholix" blog, "the hate has been going on so long that it's like the Hatfields and McCoys, where nobody can even remember what started it."

Philadelphia needs no pointers when it comes to disliking New York teams, but for decades the Yanks have been in another league, so to speak. Since the Whiz Kids' loss in a sweep to the Yankees nearly 60 years ago, the teams had not met when all was on the line until yesterday's World Series game.

Good cheers

I've come here in search of a Beantown bar that would embrace a traveling Philadelphian. Cullen recommended Cornwall's Tavern, which sits under the Citgo sign that lures the faithful to Fenway Park like rowdy moths with wicked accents. Because Cornwall's is near Boston University, which is known to accept more than a few New Yorkers, the bar tends to get a bit spirited during sporting events, Cullen advised.

"Atta boy," said Beth Walsh, clapping under the big screen as the Yankees made their first out in the first inning. Unlike some of the others at the bar, she was rooting for the Phillies as much as she was rooting against the Yankees.

"I like the Phillies," said Walsh, 45, an administrative assistant wearing the Sox jersey of captain Jason Varitek. "I like how their fans travel to Fenway in buses. I'd like to see them go back to back. And if that means the Yankees lose, that's gravy."

This rivalry stretches back two centuries, but for all intents we can understand it by starting in 1920. That was after Harry Frazee announced he'd sold a heavy-hitting pitcher named Babe Ruth to the damn Yankees.

Separated at birth

Cullen says Philadelphians can appreciate how much of the ill will comes from feelings of municipal self-worth. "We hate the Yankees because they epitomize greatness and remind us of our own historical mediocrity, both as a team and as a town when compared to the great metropolis. New York loves a winner. We mistrust anyone who speaks so openly about trying to achieve greatness. . . . We are deeply suspicious of ambition, which might in fact be a Puritan hangover."

What's our problem? Must be that Quaker humility. Owen Wister, a Philadelphia writer whose 1902 Western, The Virginian, became an instant best-seller, said people in his hometown had "a civic instinct of disparagement."

Here's a reason to resent New York from my own childhood. I grew up just outside Boston and didn't visit the big city until I was nearly 20. ("Why would you go to New York when you have Boston and Cambridge right here?" my Aunt Ethel once asked me.)

So it's freshman year of college, in Evanston, Ill. Homecoming weekend, I remember, because my roommate's mother was visiting from the Upper West Side. The three of us step into an elevator in our dorm, and there stands an older couple, husband and wife, who look as straight out of the prairie as anything Grant Wood ever painted.

My roommate's mother asks them, "Are you from New York?"

Why not? It's that New York sense that they are the world, that everything revolves around them, that they are deserving of it all, every season, year after year. God, I need therapy.

Well, I've come to the right place.


Contact Daniel Rubin at 215-854-5917 or drubin@phillynews.com.
Comments   
Posted 09:18 AM, 10/29/2009
Dutch of N
Great article.
Posted 09:38 AM, 10/29/2009
longshanks
Red Sox fans are the scum of the earth...thanks but no thanks...keep your niceties. If the Phils were playing the Sox, Bostonians would be a million times more arrogant and obnoxious than New York fans.
Posted 11:44 AM, 10/29/2009
KevSim
Of course they are kindred spirits. Both their baseball teams are anti-dynasties. 10,000 losses and 86 series without a WS win. Losers like seek solace together
Posted 03:21 PM, 10/29/2009
Greg S
have you been to any sawks/phils games? do you really want to associate yourself with boston fans? they are worse than the yankees fans, at least the yankees fans have a reason for their smugness, since they have been so successful. boston fans are just think they are the greatest thing in the world because they stuck by their team who went all those years without winning. even though most of them didnt become sawks fans until it was the cool thing circa 2000, and its not like most of the real fans had been alive for that whole title drought. not to mention the arrogance of them to assume they are somehow better fans for sticking with a titleless team. you want pain, talk to pirates fans.
Posted 03:30 PM, 10/29/2009
kingofpoker
BOSTON FANS-GET ON THE BANDWAGON-we want you-join us in HATING THE YANKEES......Grab Cleveland, the TWIN CITIES and LA....GO PHILLIES!!! YANKEES SUCK!!!! YANKEES FANS SUCK MORE!!!!!
Posted 06:01 PM, 10/29/2009
WesleyL1284
I am a West Chester Area Resident or was until I decided to attend school up in Boston; I agree that if the Phils were playing the Sox it would be loads of trouble for me - I had people running there mouths when the DCSs were going on. But Now, I can where my Phillies gear with pride and people are slapping hands with me and pulling for OUR Phillies. It isn't has bad as you all say but there is some merit to your arguments.
Posted 06:01 PM, 10/29/2009
WesleyL1284
I am a West Chester Area Resident or was until I decided to attend school up in Boston; I agree that if the Phils were playing the Sox it would be loads of trouble for me - I had people running there mouths when the DCSs were going on. But Now, I can where my Phillies gear with pride and people are slapping hands with me and pulling for OUR Phillies. It isn't has bad as you all say but there is some merit to your arguments.
7 comments
  • Top Jobs
  • Top Homes
  • Top Cars
 
SEARCH JOBS
Mount Airy


$99,900
6655 MCCALLUM ST #404
Southwark


$184,900
1310 S HOWARD ST
SEARCH CARS

Buy Inquirer, Daily News & Philly merchandise here including:

 
Books
 
Movies
 
Page Reprints
 
Photo Licensing
 
Photos