Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH  

TEXT SIZE: A A A A
email this
print this
reprint or license this
In a huge fight during last night´s game, Montreal´s Steve Begin jumps on top of Flyers Derian Hatcher. (Ron Cortes / Inquirer).
In a huge fight during last night's game, Montreal's Steve Begin jumps on top of Flyers Derian Hatcher. (Ron Cortes / Inquirer).
PARTNER OFFER
Flyers game tickets
ComcastTix
When: ONGOING
Tickets: Check availability
RELATED STORIES
 
Flyers not satisfied with 3-2 win over Canadiens
 
Flyers-Canadiens: Game 3 recap
 
Flyers-Canadiens: Three stars
 
Growing pains for Montreal goalie Price
 
Sam Donnellon: An anti-Flyers conspiracy?
 
Tense 15 minutes for Flyers' Hatcher
 
Phantoms-Albany series comes down to Game 7
 
FLYERS PLAYOFF BLOG
READER FEEDBACK
Post a comment
SAVE AND SHARE


Sam Donnellon: Are the Flyers playing Canada's team?

DERIAN HATCHER has arguably been the Flyers' best defenseman in the playoffs. If not, then Kimmo Timonen has. So far in this series with Montreal, we have seen a sucker punch with intent to injure on Timonen go unpunished, and in last night's harrowing 3-2 Flyers victory, we watched Hatcher get thrown out of the third period of a playoff game for a boarding penalty that occurred almost simultaneously with Tomas Plekanec's blatant attempt to injure the Flyers' R.J. Umberger by taking out his knees away from the puck.

Oh, yes, there was that phantom call on Mike Richards that led to the Canadiens' overtime win in Game 1, and that Montreal goal in the same game that seemed to be scored by a high stick.

And all that before the Canadiens trailed in this series.

Can't wait to see what's in store for tomorrow night.

This series is just three games old, and already there is way too much circumstantial evidence to support the perennial theorem embraced in the lower 48 at this time of year.

Namely, that Canada looks out for its own.

It's not just the yahoos in the upper levels who believe this, or the bias of announcers paid by the club. Chris Therien, Canadian-born, spoke on Comcast SportsNets's "Daily News Live" yesterday of strange calls made when the Flyers played the Maple Leafs in the playoffs, expressed the belief - nay, conviction - that he and his team felt they were playing Canada's team then.

Sunday, after Canadiens coach Guy Carbonneau suggested Timonen deserved his cheap shot for celebrating a clinching goal in Game 2, Flyers coach John Stevens hinted not so subtly that such a play, and such a statement, would not be celebrated if uttered by him, or made by one of his players - say, Steve Downie. It sounded as if he, too, believed in this Canada's-team concept, but after surviving last night's hairy third period, he kept his lip as stiff as a puck.

"Do you feel you're going up against Canada's team?" he was asked.

"That's why you guys get paid the big bucks," he said with a smile. "We're trying to win a game against the Montreal Canadiens, and we have to play better from a discipline standpoint. The bulk of their opportunities came on the power play."

Their power play took up nearly 20 percent of the game. Stevens did let his hair down a bit when discussing the unfair treatment of Downie, who, if he wasn't skating toward the penalty box, was sitting in it. Downie not only had to sit through his three penalties, but he was chosen to sit out the evicted Hatcher's as well.

They should let him bring some magazines next game.

Downie is no angel, but it doesn't seem right that he can get sent off for trying to dig a puck out of goalie Carey Price's skate (Price fell), yet be subjected to a pummeling at the side of Montreal net while the referee watches indifferently on the side.

Maybe this kind of treatment is what has made him so angry in the first place.

Anyway, the bitter irony of last night's too-close-for-comfort Flyers victory is that Hatcher gave Francis Bouillon a boo-boo, but left him in good enough shape to take a crosscheck to the back after the whistle blew. Umberger needed help to get off the ice, although he, too, was able to play the remainder of the game.

Hatcher was not. And that made those 10 long minutes after the Canadiens scored two power-play goals excruciatingly long, and seemingly unfair. Was it a 5-minute major? That in itself was worthy of debate. But dispatching him for the game took away a guy with one of playoff's best plus-minuses, a guy who has been integral to Martin Biron's playoff success.

Without that, you might be looking at tomorrow's game as a fight for survival, and not an opportunity to put both thumbs on the throat of an entire, desperate country. Without that, Ed Snider might have already found his way to the referee's room by now.

So what about this conspiracy theory, Marty?

"No, I don't think we're up against Canada's team," he said. "I'm sure that because they're the last Canadian team standing, a lot of people in Canada are rooting for them. But I don't think we're looking at it as the league and Toronto and all that. Because it's really not.

"We're going to face adversity in a lot of different forms. One thing I learned watching a lot of playoff hockey is it's not always going to be calls going your way." *

Send e-mail to

donnels@phillynews.com.

For recent columns, go to

http://go.philly.com/donnellon.

Comments
08:58 AM, 04/29/2008
C'mon Sam. "Not just Yahoo's in the upper level or the bias of announcers paid by the club"? Basically what you are saying is that until YOU agree, everyone else is wrong? Your column is dead on, just take out the one line and it isn't nearly as condecending.
Posted by phillybob
09:00 AM, 04/29/2008
It is pretty evident there is a bias against the Flyers, this season and in particular the playoffs. Whether it is a conspiracy or not is up for debate I suppose. However, it probably has more to do with them being the 2nd most penalized team during the regular season. Unfortunately, the refs have watched Hartnell, Downie, etc. all season long and have carried that into the "new" season instead of reseting the bar. Nonetheless, last night was ridiculous. Again, we have a player rolling on the ice, play goes on, Hatcher retaliates with a good check. Granted it was a boarding penalty. It was certainly not a major. Bouillon was not in the "prone" position, back to the play, that has been called all season. Instead, Hatcher really just put his face in the glass. With the blood, maybe you give a double minor, but a major? Cheap shots and dirty hits happen in the playoffs. It is a fact. The Flyers, this year, and in years past have gotten the short end of the stick. You really have to wonder why. The relationship with the Toronto head office has to be considered, unfortunately.
Posted by DrZ88
09:08 AM, 04/29/2008
How about instead of concocting ridiculous conspiracy theories, you focus on the fact that the Flyers should consider themselves lucky to have won that game having been outshot by 20?? Biron should be getting free drinks from the team for the rest of the year! When your team gets suspension after suspension for cheap shots during the regular season, you shouldn't be surprised that they get the penalties in the playoffs...
Posted by jayco1999
09:13 AM, 04/29/2008
If you take away the Canadiens penalties last night that were matched with Flyers penalties, that left the Canadiens short-handed only three times. Once, they had to be called for flipping the puck in the stands. Once, they had to be called for having too many men on the ice. That means, in a 60-minute game, with the Canadiens taking liberties all over the ice, they were only whistled for a judgement call penalty by a referee, a two-minute hooking penalty a couple of minutes into the game. That tells you how big of a joke the refs have been against the Flyers. One unattached, judgement penalty, in a game that featured a Flyer on the receiving end of a knee-to-knee.
Posted by yahmpy
09:17 AM, 04/29/2008
Maybe this bias is what the team needs to pull them together! I'm so old I remember back in the early Cup days when I'd hope for a penality because the Flyers were great scoring short handed - not sound thinking I know but wasn't it a thrill to see it??? Maybe this team has those types of thrills in them for us. Let's go Flyers!!!!
Posted by o280949
09:23 AM, 04/29/2008
There is absolutely no doubt there is a conspiracy. After game 2, I was watching "NHL on the Fly" on the NHL network, owned by the NHL. The commentator on the show said that "Sometimes you need to attempt to hurt the other team's best players," referring to the cowardly sucker punch leveled on Timmonen. Yet, when Hatch goes and hits someone, it's a game misconduct. A league review of the play will happen today - and a suspension would leave no doubt of a conspiracy. Did anyone see Price throw off hit helmet to make the Downie play look more dramatic? Does anyone realize all 4 officials on the ice were Canadian? Did the officials not see the attempt to injure RJ, but also the blatant interference? But wait - according to the NHL, attempting to injure the other team's stars is just "part of the playoffs"
Posted by nittanyguy07
09:26 AM, 04/29/2008
blah....conspiracy...blah..blah..blah...typical whining..Hatcher should know better. Heaven forbid if the Flyers commit a good penalty. An attitude adjustment is in order or this series will be lost.
Posted by Mark1
09:29 AM, 04/29/2008
The Flyers are a stupid team that takes a lot of bad penalties. In this series Montreal has played the same way but just hasn't been called. Where are all the refs from? Canada? You bet. This sport is almost un-watchable because it looks like a fixed prize fight. You can see with your own two eyes what's going on then it's called a different way. If the NHL wants to keep me as a fan they better fix this non-sense. And by the way, the French always have been and always will be cowards, GO Flyers
Posted by Philly monkey
09:30 AM, 04/29/2008
jayco didnt watch the game last night. shut up. who cares if youre outshot when you score more goals?
Posted by mikeb
09:48 AM, 04/29/2008
Watching the Flyers from a distance (Chicagoland) is very frustrating because of the clear anti-Flyers bias that permiates the NHL. In the Washington series it was all about Ovechkin, everything he did was spectacular, the Flyers were just an average team. Sure they won, but wait until the Caps get a little more mature! (which team is younger?). Now with the Habs it gets a little rough, and it must be the broad street bullies out there again, and they must be squashed, even though the sucker punches, swinging hips and crosschecks seem to be mostly coming from players with the C and H on their jersey... The NHL and Canadians have never forgiven the Flyers and Simon Nolet for punching out John Ferguson on a Sunday afternoon game back in 1973.
Posted by cravingcheesesteaks
09:49 AM, 04/29/2008
Sam My frinds and I discussed this on a conference call during the game last night. In places they don't talk about this ( can you sayToronto?) this league needs the Flyers. They need their road attendance. They need the swagger. They need our orange shirts. They need us to boo everything. I see Guy C. and he is everything that makes me want to hurl about this league. Do you ever see a shot of his where his nose is not pointed up at the sky. He's another prima donna. They let guys get away w/ all that garbage against our players and we move a whisker and the arm is raised. This is not to say that we don't get away w/ a few of our own..we certainly do..but there is no justice for the fox that rules the hen house. Long live the orange and black albeit from the confines of the sin bin!!
Posted by mrtibbs
09:58 AM, 04/29/2008
Sam, I thought you were better then this. You officially jumped the shark as a reporter
Posted by K333
10:02 AM, 04/29/2008
I will say that this article is as truthfull as any I have read. Even in Montreal the paper headlines have to read "Flyers get the shaft, and still rape the Habs" The refs have done a horrible job calling games fair that the Flyers have played in this Post Season, including the Capitals series. This series is worse than the first however. How did Hatcher catch a major for that check? That is rediculous. The Hab's have been given break after break, chance after chance, and still sit one game behind in the series. The Fly-Boys are taking this momentum they are building right into Pitt for what I think will be better to watch than the Stanley Cup itself. If you think Montreal is going to win this series you need to watch the replay of last nights game, just the first 6 minits when the Flyers were in a 3 on 5 situation and the Hab's only got what, 2 shots on goal? We scored our second a man down. The ref's really need to readjust what they are doing, because I will say if this series comes to a game 7 in Philly and they make these same kinds of calls, If you felt Bad for Santa at the Eagles game a few decades ago, wait untill you see what happens to these Zebras.
Posted by bigp0ppaj0sh
10:04 AM, 04/29/2008
This bunch of clowns would be golfing right now if it wasn't for a BAD CALL AGAINST WASHINGTON. No way, no how do you call tripping in a Game 7 like that. This is why I hate Flyers fans.... all they do is whine, cry and complain about refs. Are you all Steve Coates' love children or something? At least Eagles fans hold accountability where it belongs - with the players and Andy.
Posted by John E Cat
10:04 AM, 04/29/2008
This bunch of clowns would be golfing right now if it wasn't for a BAD CALL AGAINST WASHINGTON. No way, no how do you call tripping in a Game 7 like that. This is why I hate Flyers fans.... all they do is whine, cry and complain about refs. Are you all Steve Coates' love children or something? At least Eagles fans hold accountability where it belongs - with the players and Andy.
Posted by John E Cat
151 comments | View All Comments