Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH  

Opinion   

share
email
print
font size
options
 
READER FEEDBACK
Post a comment


Berlin & Jerusalem: Phony divided cities

THIS MONTH, Berlin will mark the 20th anniversary of the fall of the city's infamous wall.

Made of stark concrete and barbed wire, and dotted with watchtowers, it divided the heart of Berlin into eastern and western sectors. Hundreds died there trying to cross into freedom.

Berlin became a city early in the 14th century, when two feudal villages merged. Unified for hundreds of years, its division into eastern Soviet and western Allied zones grew out of the devastation of World War II.

Berlin was divided for just over 44 years, until the collapse of East Germany (another arbitrary relic of the cold war) in November 1989.

Reunification was greeted with acclaim, and reference to East Berlin and East Germany was relegated to historical allusion.

Archaeological evidence suggests that Jerusalem has existed for as long as 5,000 years. King David is said to have made the city his capital 3,000 years ago. The New Testament describes Jesus in Jerusalem and the existence of the Jewish Temple 2,000 years ago.

Jesus was crucified in Jerusalem by Roman legionnaires early in the first century. Many of his fellow Jews were forcibly expelled, and, over the subsequent two millennia, Jerusalem was continuously ruled by a variety of outside conquerors, including the Ottoman sultan Suleiman the Magnificent, who built the Old City's famous walls.

Divided for just 19 years by Jordanian occupation, which ended in 1967, two decades before Berlin's reunification, the place known as "East Jerusalem" in Mideast peace parlance has no more enduring historical validity than "East Berlin."

I was in Jerusalem in 1960 and looked across the Mandelbaum Gate from Israel into Jerusalem's Jordanian sector. I was unable to cross even to the Jewish Quarter of the Old City because of machine gun-toting Jordanian soldiers and the barbed-wire barriers they'd constructed that ran through Jerusalem.

Today, even with map in hand, it's virtually impossible to envision that unsightly barricade in a city fully restored to its millennial unified state. But for Suleiman's 16th-century walls (which, until 1948 and since 1967, have contained the Old City's Jewish quarter, along with the homes of Christians and Muslims), the 1948 armistice line is practically imperceptible.

Continued use of the term "East Jerusalem" is misleading. It suggests the natural condition of that ancient city is to be cut in two, with an ugly barrier running through its heart.

At a time when people who massacre civilians in buses and mosques, or who fire missiles into towns and cities are called "militants" rather than terrorists to avoid the appearance of any prejudgment, it's difficult to understand anyone's use of the term "East Jerusalem," as if it were a real place.

FOR 5,000 years,

there was only one Jerusalem, just as there is only one Berlin - ironically, two cities painfully linked by more than their common history of temporary forced partition.

"East Jerusalem" has no more historical legitimacy than "East Berlin," as both cities have had their short-lived and artificial dividing walls torn down. We should celebrate the reunification of both this month and let "East Jerusalem" join "East Berlin" in history's ash can.

John R. Cohn is a professor of medicine at Thomas Jefferson University. He writes frequently about the Mideast. E-mail: john.r.cohn@gmail.com.

Comments   
Posted 02:43 PM, 11/05/2009
himills
Great article. I suggest you go to Tehran, Amman, and Riyadh and give speeches about this opinion on the street corners.
Posted 02:49 PM, 11/05/2009
himills
Also, for all readers, I suggest you search online for Cohn's name along with this title, "A DISPROPORTIONATE RESPONSE TO CRITICISM" . I'm not saying I am pro-Palestinian or anti-Israeli; I just want readers to be aware that the author here penned this piece from a pre-existing pro-Israeli mindset. What else would you expect him to say here than what he did?
Posted 05:35 PM, 11/05/2009
PHILEXILE
There were Germans on both sides of Berlin. There are not people of one language/nationality on both sides of Jerusalem. There are two nationalities with competing claims to the city. The Israelis would not trust the Palestinians to rule them and the Palestinians have no reason to trust the Israelis.
Posted 06:26 PM, 11/05/2009
himills
Their nationality, language, and religions might be different, but their ethnicity is the same: Semitic. When most people hear the phrase, "anti-Semitic," they think anti-Jewish or anti-Israeli, but the Semitic peoples are the ancestors of both Israeli Jews and Palestinian Muslims.
4 comments
  • Top Jobs
  • Top Homes
  • Top Cars
 
SEARCH JOBS
Rittenhouse Square


$729,000
202-210 W RITTENHOUSE SQ #2403
Center City


$899,900
1101 LOCUST ST #2F
SEARCH CARS

Buy Inquirer, Daily News & Philly merchandise here including:

 
Books
 
Movies
 
Page Reprints
 
Photo Licensing
 
Photos