Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH  

Opinion   

share
email
print
reprint
font size
options
 
READER FEEDBACK
Post a comment


Letters: Taxes & govt. are the answer

LETTER-writer Stuart Caesar says tax cuts are always the answer. But for society to function even remotely fairly, it needs revenue. Our leaders have decided to go into debt for things they deem essential. The only way to pay off that debt is to return tax rates to those of the early Reagan years.

If Republicans in Washington can't agree to that, then their cries of "generational theft" drip with hypocrisy and are nothing more than a fancy platitude to confuse us serfs out here on Main Street. Why tax the rich? If bank robber Willie Sutton were advising the politicians, he'd tell them, "That's where the money is."

Roy Lehman

Woolwich Township, N.J.

According to Stuart Caesar (Nov. 2), "the government is always the problem, and tax cuts are the only answer."

So Medicare, Social Security, the FDA, FAA, etc., are what's wrong with our country. But tax cuts, there's the answer. You know, like the eight years of prosperity after Bush II gave away the store.

Caesar, laughingly, suggests that the writer of an earlier letter should "face facts." Well, these are the facts, as anyone with a computer or library card can easily check out:

For more than 50 years, our GDP and job-creation have been consistently higher under Democratic administrations (you know, the ones who are always raising your taxes), and government is and always has been the answer to the collective needs of any population.

To live in a great country like the U.S. is to belong to an elite club. Your taxes are your dues. What you get for those dues is access to all rights and privileges of the club.

As one who is collecting Social Security and is protected by Medicare, just as Mr. Caesar either is or someday will be, I thank the Lord (and Democrats in Congress, past and present), for the "problem" that, for so many of us, offers security and peace of mind.

Robert Leonardo, Palmyra, N.J.

Comments   
Posted 07:40 AM, 11/04/2009
tr88
Anyone who tries to align the economic cycle with the electoral cycle is a fool and take political credit for it is a fool. The problem as I see it is only half are paying the dues these days and the half that arent are getting way too much.
Posted 09:10 AM, 11/04/2009
constantine
Rob & Roy need to look at reality. Fairness? Elite Club? The problem with "fairness" is that the morals/ethics of fairness can always be twisted around by rich whiney activists who have little else to show for. Some club this is. The true financial elite continue to slide around the taxes from the loopholes created by Republicans and Democrats or favors from their friends in the BRT. Meanwhile, the middle class gets slammed and shrunk for the sake of shifting their hard-earned money to the members of society who often refust to work while getting free/subsidized housing, free food, free healthcare, free transportation, free afterschool programs, free money, free etc. while careening around Philly in beamers & SUVS sporting expensive jewelry and clothing all without ever paying income tax. Some club! Society does not need taxes to operate. I am not a libertarian by any means (quite the opposite - but I just don't want my taxes going into wasteful spending or spending that will make society worse), but the reality is that Switzerland has held out against aristocratic rule for the past 2000 years and still attracts people in part because of its low taxes. Apparently the majority of French soccer players and pop stars live in Switzerland as do North American stars like Tina Turner, Celine Dion, Shania Twain, and Yoko Ono. Weren't Vermont or the Rockies good enough for them?
Posted 09:19 AM, 11/04/2009
Imagine
It is not the taxes that I complain about, it is how the taxes dollars are used. I have no problem with my taxes dollars being used to support schools, libraries, swimming pools, etc. I do have a probelm with my taxes dollars being used to pay for choice wars, city council lap dancers and other high priced city worker's that don't work.
Posted 09:53 AM, 11/04/2009
jmc
If Social Security is so great, why do we need 401k's? If Medicare is so great, why do we need private Medicare supplemental insurance. If everyone loves Social Security, why not make it voluntary? These two are useful idiots who will exchange their freedom for the scraps that fall from the Democratic Party table. Their given just enough to keep them voting Democrat and seem to love it.
Posted 11:47 AM, 11/04/2009
longshanks
The point is that the folks on the right want all of the benefits of Social Security and Medicare and our nation's longstanding socialist systems but they don't want everyone to receive those same benefits. They prefer to live like the Lord of the manor while the majority of the people fill in as the serfs. It's like Republicans being gung-ho for war but only if your kids are going to be the soldiers. We live in the world's greatest superpower and to continue to do so that requires taxes and a larger government. We will never have a small federal government. That's the reality.
Posted 01:04 PM, 11/04/2009
keapitreal
Leonard is either an idiot or ignorant. Not sure which...he talks about what a great country this is because he gets SS and Medicare...why is that? because he didn't work enough years to fend for himself or get a pension that the pittance SS gives is so good? Does Mr. Leonardo realize that if people keep espousing these so-called wonderful programs, this country will soonlook nothing like it does now or should look. The key to this being such a GREAT country is Hard Work, not your hand out... Longshanks....you're not too well informed either. Everyone can have what they want....it's just NOT supposed to come from the Government! It's supposed to come from hard work which equals success. Who wants to be beholden to anyone especially the Gov't??
Posted 01:18 PM, 11/04/2009
chrisrr
The little secret is that in the past, lower taxes have resulted in increased economic activity which increases the taxes that the US has taken in (see Reagan tax cuts, JFK tax cuts). 2 trillion ($2,000,000,000,000 dollars isn't enough, so Obama has to spend an extra 1.4 trillion to make ends meet?
Posted 01:20 PM, 11/04/2009
keapitreal
NO ONE deserves to get anything for nothing. Not the way this country became so great. Should only get back what you put into anything. Work for your own Success and Security is what made this country
Posted 02:55 PM, 11/04/2009
jfeliccia
SO keapitreal. You don't get SS or Medicare. Right?? Neocon TWIT
Posted 05:01 PM, 11/04/2009
keapitreal
No Felicia, I don't take the pittance handout of SS. I will not rely on it for my retirement. Instead I will WORK hard and save my own hard earned money for a secure retirement...understand? Also, I am not someone who plays disabled who in turn takes SS and Medicaide as many Dems do....
Posted 12:05 AM, 11/06/2009
pjsz1261
Longshanks you seem to know an awful lot about what people on the right want. Let me boil the whole right vs. left thing down. People on the left want to be able to live their lives however they see fit. People on the right want to live their lives however they see fit. People on the left want someone else to pay the bill. In response to your assanine assertion that we want social security and Medicare all to ourselves, you truly have no idea what we on the "right" want. I am willing to relinquish any claim to SS benefits and Medicare benefits for the rest of my life if the gov't is willing to stop collecting those taxes from me right now. The gov't can keep every penny I've paid into either system with my compliments. Let me go it alone. I GUARANTEE most conservatives under say 50 years of age would take that offer. It won't happen because the gov't needs US to keep paying the way for the 50% of people in this country that pay ZERO and get to enjoy the same benefits. You know nothing about conservatism that you don't get from MSNBC.
Posted 12:24 AM, 11/06/2009
pjsz1261
Another thing....if these social programs are such a great deal, then why isn't participation voluntary? Why does the government need to compel it's citizens to particpate? Longshanks and his friends feel this is a left vs. right issue. The fact is that it is a non partisan liberty and self determination issue. Give Americans the choice of going it alone or partipating in the social justice, welfare, Medicaid, etc. system. But the gov't can't afford to take that chance! Not with more than half the country paying little or nothing into the system. The mass exodus of tax PAYERS would cause the collapse of the system the social justice participants depend on. Margaret Thatcher said it quite well...the problem with socialism is that sooner or later your run out of other people's money.
12 comments
  • Top Jobs
  • Top Homes
  • Top Cars
 
SEARCH JOBS
Mount Airy


$95,900
6655 MCCALLUM ST #404
Feasterville


$73,000
3541 ROSE AVE
SEARCH CARS

Buy Inquirer, Daily News & Philly merchandise here including:

 
Books
 
Movies
 
Page Reprints
 
Photo Licensing
 
Photos