Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH  

Opinion   

share
email
print
font size
options
 
READER FEEDBACK
Post a comment


3-1-1 isn't meant to usurp Council

EVERY DAY, hundreds of Philadelphians call various city departments in an effort to solve a variety of problems.

In many cases, these taxpayers aren't sure which is the right department to call.

Often, in an effort to prompt action, they also call their City Council members for help as well. But regardless of who they call, the administration is ultimately responsible for solving these problems.

That's where the 3-1-1 system is playing a key role.

* 3-1-1 gives taxpayers one

number to call for all nonemergency services.

That means there's no more guessing about where to call with a specific concern. And while there's nothing wrong with contacting a council member for assistance, our goal is to make sure that government works for everyone, regardless of who you are, what district you live in or what the concern is.

* 3-1-1 also provides, for the

first time, a way to track all service requests to ensure that they're completed, and it provides department managers with valuable data on how they're delivering service and helping them engage in the constant improvement of those services.

* 3-1-1 also serves to relieve

the 9-1-1 system by reducing the huge volume of nonemergency calls inappropriately going to 9-1-1.

Similarly, 3-1-1 can be a tremendous boon to members of Council by reducing the number of minor informational calls that are made to their offices and serving as a clearinghouse for requests that come in to all 17 City Council members.

But, to be clear, in no way, shape or form is 3-1-1 meant to displace or replace City Council's constituent services. The system will not and should not hamper the good work that Council members do in listening to constituents' problems and holding the city administration and its departments accountable for providing efficient and effective customer service.

The 3-1-1 system is less than a year old and has had to sustain budget cutbacks owing to the impact of the great recession on Philadelphia and the city's revenue collections. It is a work in progress, as any new service agency would be.

But through monthly problem-solving meetings, we are addressing the issues surrounding the development of our 3-1-1 system.

Council staffers are attending these meetings and more should take advantage of the opportunity. Where any persistent problems are uncovered, I remain committed to meeting with any Council member to deal with the issue.

IN FACT, I recently met with Council members to get their input into the ongoing development of our 3-1-1 system. And we are making weekly reports to Council on feedback relating to system performance.

I wholeheartedly agree with Councilman Greenlee in his recent op-ed that the 3-1-1 system is not in competition with the constituent service function in each City Council office.

Our mutual job is to work effectively and at the lowest cost to resolve our customers' problems.

Taxpayers in Philadelphia deserve nothing less.

Camille Barnett is managing director of the city of Philadelphia.

Comments   
Posted 08:13 AM, 11/02/2009
rabbit23
311 just adds another layer to a phonecall of complaint. I called to complain about a big pothole the city had left on my block. 311 transferred me to the Streets Dept, who told me to call PGW, who told me to call the water dept. I could have been given the run-around all by myself without 311 and Camille Barnett's help, thanks very much. next time i'll call Greenlee instead - at least he might not be as self-righteous as Barnett appears.
Posted 09:54 AM, 11/02/2009
btruth
rabbit is right. I had a horrible 311 experience, and know several others who didn't get correct direction. It's yet another bureaucratic layer, a waste of money, and Barnett needs to spend less time finding staff to walk her dogs and more time actually understanding what is going on in the city and government so she can make a contribution to improving the mess in city hall.
Posted 09:55 AM, 11/02/2009
templealumna
311 is a poor replacement for the previous system. Every time I have used this system - and I have used it at least 4 -5 times, I have been disappointed.
Posted 03:17 PM, 11/02/2009
Chaz0611
As a community person, I have made hundreds and hundreds of complaints to the city online using their website(s). As soon as 311 started, the wait for a person, any person, to answer dominated much of the time of the call duration. The fact that voice mail of Mayor Nutter repeating himself over and over probably exacerbated the grating voice that reminds the caller over and over that no one was going to answer quickly. Online complaints, on the other hand, were quick, efficient and allowed me to keep a log. The mayor promised a tracking number was coming, which in most cases did not, and when connected to the department they claimed they did not issue tracking numbers. Recently, the wait time as been uneven, but in most cases were noticeably shorter. However, the response time is inadequate and the most glaring shortfall is the misinformation provided to the caller is stunning. A citizen called for help with rats on the street and was told the city does not do rats. Really, I called the one shining beacon in the city's arsenal, Vector Control, and in days the dead rat was discovered dead on the same street. No tracking number, no lost paperwork, just exemplary service. We don't need no stinkin CLIP, like in the NE, just a department like Vector Control or the Community Service program or the Controllers office. City departments that do not adhere to the city mantra of being city workers but just do one thing. "They do their job, period". City Council does have their moments but only because the district council people know that when they don't feel like it or tell their constituents to call their committeepeople; the citizens can call the Council AT Large who do a yeoman's job. Especially, Bill Greenlee and Bill Green and Frank Rizzo even though he is an R, but he does not care what party the caller is, like his other At Large people he just knows the caller needs help. 311 is a work in progress, but city services shouldn't be, It should be a given.
Posted 10:08 PM, 11/02/2009
PhillyGirl21
Are you guys for real? I am a "normal" citizen who pay taxes in the City and I have used 311 on several ocassions with no problems. If you have problems, ask to speak to the manager or head of the department as you would with another other department. Have you tried calling Comcast customer service lately??? Talk about bad customer service!
Posted 12:49 AM, 11/04/2009
maggieanne
Who do I call to get Vapor Intrusion and Toxic Plume testing? There is a site full of contaminated ground water surrounding my house and it's making me ill. It was "remediated" illegally and the city looked the other way because it was one of Council Donna Reed Miller's pet projects. It went bankrupt , but still, contaminated fumes fill my house. Gas Co and Fire Dept was sent -no gas leak or carbon monoxide. They didn't even know what Vapor Intrusion was. I told them to look it up. I feel really bad for some of the city workers. They know they are working for jack asses and being mistreated. The chemical dumping was right next to me and on the site of a creek, prime conditions for Vapor Intrusion and Toxic Plume. I have to move again because the over load is getting too much again. A bunch of politicians in the NW and their connected friends basically committed some serious environmental crimes and they refuse to follow the law regarding toxic contamination and are putting people'e lives at risk to cover their crime.
6 comments
  • Top Jobs
  • Top Homes
  • Top Cars
 
SEARCH JOBS
Rittenhouse Square


$389,000
1728 CHESTNUT ST #1
Northern Liberties


$525,000
960 N AMERICAN ST
SEARCH CARS

Buy Inquirer, Daily News & Philly merchandise here including:

 
Books
 
Movies
 
Page Reprints
 
Photo Licensing
 
Photos