Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH  
share
email
print
reprint
font size
options
 
1 of 2
READER FEEDBACK
Post a comment
RELATED STORIES
 
Man pleads guilty in murder of Officer Cassidy
 
On Pa.'s death row


Trial starts for man who faces death penalty in Officer Chuck Cassidy's fatal shooting

When Leslie Beasley was sentenced to death for murdering Philadelphia Police Officer Ernest Davis, Ronald Reagan had recently entered the White House and John "Jordan" Lewis was not even born.

Beasley, 58, with 28 years and three months served on death row, is the dean of Pennsylvania's condemned cop killers.

There are 11 of them, including six from Philadelphia, according to the state Department of Corrections. In all, 221 people are on death row for the crime of first-degree murder with aggravating circumstances.

Lewis, 23, will be the next among that lot if the District Attorney's Office has its way.

Opening arguments are set to begin this morning in the murder trial of the bulky, North Philadelphia high-school dropout who is accused of firing a bullet into the brain of Philadelphia Police Officer Chuck Cassidy on Oct. 31, 2007. The 25-year department veteran, husband and father of three, died the next day. He was 54.

But even if the jury finds Lewis guilty, then sentences him to death, he's likely to have many years ahead of him on death row.

That's because the lengthy federal and state appeals process afforded to defendants in capital cases has rendered the death penalty virtually comatose. Since the U.S. Supreme Court reinstated capital punishment in 1976, six Pennsylvania governors have signed 364 death warrants, but just three inmates have been executed, according to the Department of Corrections.

The executions of Keith Zettlemoyer and Leon Moser in 1995, and Gary Heidnik in 1999, were carried out only after they had dropped all appeals.

The other condemned inmates use appeals like lifelines to stay put indefinitely.

Beasley, for example, has survived death warrants signed by three governors. He was actually convicted and sentenced to death twice for two 1980 murders - Officer Davis' in July and civilian Keith Singleton's in April.

Overall, no death warrants are active on any of the 221 death-row inmates, said Susan Bensinger, a spokeswoman for the Department of Corrections.

The reprieves fuel mounting frustration for the family members of slain victims. "Hurry up and lay him on the table," Michael Caesar, 30, said of Christopher Roney after a March court hearing, during which Roney's public defenders argued to have his death sentence tossed out due to childhood abuse and depression.

He was sentenced to death for the Jan. 2, 1996, shooting death of Caesar's mother, Officer Lauretha Vaird. Roney, now 39, shot Vaird in the abdomen while robbing a Feltonville PNC Bank, making the single mother of two sons the first female Philadelphia police officer slain in the line of duty.

"The bottom line is, [Roney] had a choice - to walk out the door or stay and do what he did," Caesar said. "He deserves the death penalty. My whole family is hurting behind this."

Michael Piecuch, executive director of the Pennsylvania District Attorneys Association, said that the system is being "thwarted" by anti-death penalty judges who've placed a de facto moratorium on capital punishment.

"That does not give light at the end of the tunnel for victims and prosecutors who work so hard on these cases," he said.

"The issue is not really in the statute and the rules of the appellate procedure, but in the implicit message of the Third Circuit Court of Appeals that there is a de facto moratorium," he continued. "The Third Circuit Court will not uphold a death-penalty sentence in Pennsylvania."

Last year, that federal court threw out the death sentence of the state's most notorious inmate - Mumia Abu-Jamal. The former Black Panther Party member and onetime radio talker has become internationally famous for fighting his execution for more than 26 years.

Convicted of murdering Officer Daniel Faulkner in 1981, Abu-Jamal, 55, is serving a life sentence without parole while awaiting word from the U.S. Supreme Court on whether his death sentence will be reinstated.

Mark Bergstrom, executive director of the Pennsylvania Commission on Sentencing, said that he also believes that death sentences are not being carried out due to the federal courts.

"One of the key things about sentencing is that you are able to follow through and carry out the sentence," he said. "There does seem to be a disconnect if our statute is valid and sentences are not being carried out."

But William DiMascio, executive director of the Pennsylvania Prison Society, which advocates for prisoners' rights, said that the death penalty is unpopular because innocent men have been exonerated while on death row and it does nothing to stop crime.

"If this were a way to bring Officer Cassidy back, fine," he said. "But we know that's impossible. We also know that this death penalty has not served as a deterrent. So what is to be gained?

"The death penalty is such a terminal sentence, there's no going back, and people have begun to question whether we should be doing that at all."

Even in the age of terrorism and mass murderers like D.C. Sniper John Allen Muhammad, who was executed by Virginia on Tuesday night, imposing the death penalty is still a tough sell for many. It took prosecutors and defense lawyers four days to find 12 jurors to hear Lewis' case, which is expected to run three weeks. Many of the more than 300 potential jurors said that they were opposed to capital punishment.

Families of victims are all over the map with their stances on the death penalty, said Kate Roach, program director for Families of Murder Victims, a nonprofit that sends staff to accompany family members during court proceedings. Some want the death penalty imposed when it is not legally permissible, while others never express interest in the ultimate punishment, she said.

"What is becoming very apparent to me is there is not a lot of knowledge about the law," Roach said. "People look at the death penalty in black-and-white, but there is a lot more complexity to it. People are transfixed by television, 'Law & Order' and 'Boston Legal.' But that's not what we do."

Television of another sort will be used against Lewis at trial. Police have said that a surveillance camera inside the West Oak Lane Dunkin' Donuts that he was robbing at gunpoint captured him turning and firing at Cassidy as the officer entered the store.

Then, after he was arrested in Miami days later, Lewis told a scrum of reporters and cameras that, "Yes," he had confessed.

 

Comments   
Posted 07:23 AM, 11/12/2009
blackknight
Vote out all Liberal judges and start to make our streets safe again. Mumia should be the poster child for what is wrong with the death penalty. All of the appeals that they file are paid for by us the taxpayers. The estimated $38k a year it takes to keep an inmate fed, clothed, etc. is paid by the taxpayers. It's time to change the laws on death penalty cases and limit the appeals to 1 only and if found guilty then bring all parties to an adjourning room and carry out the death sentence. The death penalty is probably not a deterrent but it would save the taxpayers some money and bring some closure to the victims families. The thought that Daniel Faulkner's widow could die before the scum bag who killed her husband is just wrong. As far as wrongly accused? In this age of forensic pathology and DNA unless you are OJ it is almost impossible to get away with murder with the technology available to us.
Comment removed.
Posted 08:22 AM, 11/12/2009
johnny o
What's the holdup? Get it on with the trial and get it on with the sentence.
Posted 11:39 AM, 11/12/2009
John Law
Ladies and Gentilmen...let's review the crime problem in Killadelphia over just the last year...K? Let's look at Gov. Rendell, the State Parole Board, The Mayor, City Council, State Attorney General and remember the following small, partial list of State Parole Offenders who made the papers.... Besides Murchison and Wilson (The PIAZZA MURDERS) and Porter, Evans (Murderers), let's add Carrisquillo (Rapist), Shaw (Frankford Rapist), don't forget Burgess (Serial Killer and Rapist); Giddings, Cain, Warner (COP KILLERS); Wilson, Norman, Magee, Lassister, Hill, Trinsey, Wise, Latham, Bryant and the 4 out of the 5 gunmen who just recently murdered "Piggy" the mother of 4 children (All are Shoot-Out Artists and again were under State Parole "Supervision"). Why were they on the street and kept on the street? Money...to save money. State Budget Monies (specifically) that were spent on "No Bid" and about 60 million on other "Inappropiate" Contracts that went to Campiagn Contributors and friends of Governor Rendell. Why are so few Parole Violators being sent back to prison for serious offenses and even kept on the street while they have new open court cases...like Carrisquillo? Why are there so few State Parole Field Agents in Killadelphia? Why are 2,000 State Inmates being released each month? MONEY. The Mayor, City Council, State Legislature, State's Attorney General were all told about 21 months ago about this SCANDAL and they have done nothing to stop it. Studies...proposed legislation...it’s all more opium for the masses. Want to help? Encourage all the victims and surviving family members to sue the State. Ask our Mayor and City Council to sue the State and get our money back! Email Mike.Levy@usdoj.gov and ask him to investigate and prosecute "The Rendell Murders", he'll know what you are talking about 215-861-8200. The President's Comment Line = 1-202-456-1111. Remember State Parolees are responsible for our Murder and Crime Rates. Take action...make some calls.
Comment removed.
Comment removed.
Comment removed.
Comment removed.
Posted 05:42 PM, 11/12/2009
philliekev04
While im really glad there will be justice for this monster, what i dont understand is why is he being punished so much more severely for killing a cop than he would if he just killed any average person on the street. Its not that im not glad that he's getting the punishment that he is getting but I dont think special treatment should be involved. Whether you kill a cop or any other person the punishment should be the same.
Posted 05:58 PM, 11/12/2009
Fernando08
Poor people have been denied adequate education, they have slum housing, poverty wages if any legal job at all, lousy trash pick up, no street repairs, bad utility, no internet and so on. But what is never really explained is that there is absolutely no meaningful policing hence no law and order. Some zip codes in the city are the functional equivalents of failed states run by drug warlords. That because that is what they are. When we send troops to Afghanistan and 8 years later, everything they did to throw out the bad guys is vaporizing before our eyes, and now the answer must be working with people to do nation building activities. It is unlikely that the carnage will stop in the city until we admit that there are places outside of anything we understand and anything we can control with band aids and slogans. This kid is a cold heart killer, the marines can't even make guys like this as easily as our most violent neighborhoods seem to. He should die for what he has done now that his guilt in beyond doubt. Every killer like him should be brought to justice and die the same way. The problem is, he has 20 or so replacements the minute he is gone. It is a giant violence factory out there run by murder inc. and business is good. Real good.
Posted 04:38 PM, 11/13/2009
godiva615
John Law - you make good points. The vast majority of murderes seemed to have been paroles. I have always wondered what would possess the parole board to allow first degree murderes and rapist back on the streets at all. the statistics clearly show that criminals usually repeat the same crimes over and over. I've heard of a person who was convicted of murder about 3 times by his 40's. If they would have given the appropriate sentence for murder #1 then 2 and 3 may still be alive today. 7 years imprisonment is nothing. Time flies these days. The focus should be keeping the prospective victims safe. A murder or rapist deserves no rights. Rights are for people who abide by the law and do not engage in criminal activity. Keeping them locked away will solve the problem. Pay the money. They will increase tax rates to save the economy or save banks and large publically traded businesses but not to help raise funds for crime. There needs to be a petition sent through whole country asking for a change in murder, abuse of minors and rape charges and the parole and appeal processes and rules. In addition to this somethig needs to change with the gun selling/buying rules. Some owners are selling 30 guns to one individual in a month time span. He was not charged for a murder committed with one of the weapons based on some screwy technicality. there is no real gun control law in place to consider this neglegent or a violation of rules. I think a person buying multiple guns within one month is clear sign of them illegally selling to others. Sex offenders should face charges of a murderer - you kill a child mentally when you abuse them! Some of those poor victims never heal from the horrible acts inflicted upon them and end up suffering one way or another throughout whole life. Their organs are even damaged in many cases. Thats one way abuse is noticed!
Posted 12:49 PM, 11/17/2009
Ryanrepublican
I don't understand why these people, when put to death, get lethal injection and not a gun shot to the head. Eye for an eye!!! A bullet is cheaper if you ask me. Also, I do not believe they deserve a last meal. With the way the economy is, give that great meal to somebody that needs it!
12 comments
  • Top Jobs
  • Top Homes
  • Top Cars
 
SEARCH JOBS
Rittenhouse Square


$1,225,000
202-10 W RITTENHOUSE SQ #1809
Rittenhouse Square


$249,900
2101-17 CHESTNUT ST #1717
SEARCH CARS

Buy Inquirer, Daily News & Philly merchandise here including:

 
Books
 
Movies
 
Page Reprints
 
Photo Licensing
 
Photos