Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH  
share
email
print
reprint
font size
options
 
Brian Westbrook (right) chats with Jason Avant in second half.
RON CORTES / Staff photographer
Brian Westbrook (right) chats with Jason Avant in second half.
READER FEEDBACK
How long should Westbrook be out for?
RELATED STORIES
 
Bob Ford: Eagles feast on Redskins' mistakes
 
Paul Domowitch: Two big plays, but much sputtering
 
Phil Sheridan: Real tests are still ahead for Eagles
 
Eagles dump Redskins, but Westbrook, Jackson hurt
 
Big Eagles debut for Witherspoon against Redskins
 
Eagles-Redskins: What we saw


Rich Hofmann: How hard will Westbrook's concussion hit Eagles?

"A boxer losing by way of a Technical Knock Out (TKO) resulting from head blows shall receive a medical suspension and shall not participate in any boxing activity for a minimum period of thirty (30) days. A boxer losing by way of a Knock Out (KO) shall receive a medical suspension and shall not participate in any boxing activity for a minimum period of sixty days. At the discretion of the physician, longer suspension periods may be issued for either the TKO or KO."

- From Regulatory Guidelines of the Association of Boxing Commissions

LANDOVER, Md. - If Brian Westbrook were a boxer, which he is not, and if he were indeed knocked cold last night after a knee rudely encountered his head, which he was, he would not be playing again until about the Eagles' 15th game of the season.

Because this is football, no one expects that. But as the Eagles enter the meat-grinder part of their schedule, it seems pretty clear that they will be doing it without their top running back.

As the real games begin - Giants and Cowboys and Chargers and et cetera - it appears as if the Eagles will have to scheme their way and Wildcat their way and Shady McCoy their way around the absence of their most accomplished runner. If Westbrook were to play Sunday against the Giants, it would be as miraculous as it would be irresponsible.

With 7 minutes and 3 seconds left in the first quarter of the Eagles' 27-17 win over the Redskins, Westbrook was motionless on the field for several minutes after taking an accidental knee to the back of the neck from Redskins linebacker London Fletcher. It was one of those scary NFL moments, easily identified not as much by the play or the injury but by the obvious concern expressed by players from both sides as the player is being attended to.

When players start kneeling in prayer in the vicinity of the fallen player, you know they are worried. When they need to be shooed away by the officials and only leave with reluctance, you know. In this case, there was the additional, poignant gesture made by Eagles coach Andy Reid. As the players from both teams were moved away, Reid made sure that one of the Redskins stayed with him near the fallen Eagles star. The player was Byron Westbrook, Brian's brother, a Washington special-teams player.

Eventually, Westbrook moved his legs and sat up and then stood up. He was immediately walked to the Eagles' locker room. Within minutes, it was announced in the press box that Westbrook had suffered a concussion. Such a quick public diagnosis is rare for this team. That told everyone, right there, how clear-cut the injury was.

Twice, he has suffered terrible injuries on this field - the field closest to his hometown of Fort Washington, Md. In 2003, it was a torn triceps in a late December game that ended his season and greatly affected the Eagles in later weeks, particularly in their NFC Championship Game loss to Carolina. Now, this.

How bad it is remains unknown. So much about concussions remains unknown. The good thing is, Westbrook has no known concussion history. The bad thing is, every concussion is different and every concussion sufferer is different. It is why boxing has those mandatory suspension rules - because nobody knows for sure.

But, well, this is football - where there are no mandatory medical suspensions, where the players deal with an entirely different set of imperatives, where self-preservation tends to diminish with each higher rung in the standings. The truth is, they lie and tell the medical people they are fine and they take stupid risks all the time.

"We're not going to put him out there if he's at risk," said Eagles coach Andy Reid.

Earlier, Reid said, "I think he's going to be all right . . . We just have to see how he does with the concussion. He's feeling better. He told me he couldn't remember anything so he didn't want to talk to you guys."

With all of that, it is hard to see Westbrook playing in the next week or 2, at the absolute minimum. And with that, they are left with their so-far-unimpressive Wildcat offense - be it the Michael Vick flavor of the spread option or the direct snap to a non-quarterback - and they are left with McCoy, who has not run the ball great lately, either.

Still, this is what they worked to fix in the offseason - life without the oft-injured Westbrook. It was what Vick was about in some ways, and what McCoy was about in every way. It also was, in their own way, what tackle Jason Peters and guard Stacy Andrews were about, too.

And now, earlier than anyone had hoped, we are going to find out what that offseason was all about.

Send e-mail to

hofmanr@phillynews.com,

or read his blog, The Idle Rich, at

http://go.philly.com/theidlerich.

For recent columns go to

http://go.philly.com/hofmann.

Comments   
Posted 06:04 AM, 10/27/2009
Seed
We pray for Westbrook and hope there is no longterm effect on his health. Eagles does not seem to be getting any break from health point. Westbrook looked so good and helped Eagles to control the tempo of the game until the unfortunate event. It was such a freakist collision. Get well Brian!
Posted 06:33 AM, 10/27/2009
Mass EagleFan
There are a few differences between between boxers and fighters - last time I checked, boxers didn't wear helmets. And, the good news is, the Eagles actually have a few viable weapons this year besides Westy. They'll miss him, of course, but they don't need to rush him back...
Posted 06:48 AM, 10/27/2009
afrdmd
I hope Westbrook recovers quickly now that their tune-up games are over and the "real season begins".
Posted 07:17 AM, 10/27/2009
azguz
he needs to be out as long as it takes
Posted 07:20 AM, 10/27/2009
PhillyNH
Time to draft a BIG back
Posted 07:29 AM, 10/27/2009
CoolRunnings
Heal quickly Mr Westbrook. We are going to need you in a few weeks. Now, I guess, is when we find out if the Vick experiment has any value. Until now, it doesn't look to be good, but if they have been sitting on something special it's time to roll it out of the garage
Posted 07:42 AM, 10/27/2009
Kenny Junod
b west is killing my ffb team
Posted 07:57 AM, 10/27/2009
Dave Clemens
Have people been paying attention to the studies on former NFL players who suffered concussions while playing? They tend to end up as seriously unbalanced or even drool cases by the time they're 40. In other words, their brains never really recover. Westbrook should consider his future, invest the money he's already made and leave football.
Posted 08:03 AM, 10/27/2009
nuggett
as long as it takes toinsure his health
Posted 08:10 AM, 10/27/2009
Gringo4
Time to get #7 into the offense !
Posted 08:10 AM, 10/27/2009
Gringo4
Time to get #7 into the offense !
Posted 08:16 AM, 10/27/2009
shakenbake
Westbrook can continue to be an edges rusher and a great receiver, but the Birds need to get a big between the tackles guy. Shady is more like Westbrook, so I don't think its him. Really, they should know this already and have had this taken care of. If the wildcat was supposed to be for this problem, sorry but it won't work. As it stands now, all the more reason for AR to fire it up 50 times a game. Every year some type of hole gets exposed in their roster. True or not?
Posted 08:17 AM, 10/27/2009
joed1
well Rich the only thing you left out were the violins. concussions happen in this sport where you usually lead with your head. We are all glad he will be ok but once again no westbrook when they need him the most and sadly that is the story of his career.
Posted 08:18 AM, 10/27/2009
SayHello2MyLittleFriend
Save him for the playoffs next season.
Posted 08:18 AM, 10/27/2009
Leegles
Here's a must-read article on dementia in former football players related to head trauma. It mentions Vick and Andre Waters: http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2009/10/19/091019fa_fact_gladwell?currentPage=all
  • Top Jobs
  • Top Homes
  • Top Cars
 
SEARCH JOBS
Center City


$1,399,900
1111 LOCUST ST #9B
Southwark


$184,900
1310 S HOWARD ST
SEARCH CARS

Buy Inquirer, Daily News & Philly merchandise here including:

 
Books
 
Movies
 
Page Reprints
 
Photo Licensing
 
Photos